HomeMy WebLinkAboutPackets - Historic Preservation Commission (101) AGENDA
Historic Preservation Commission
Monday,June 9, 2008
Town of Oro Valley Council Chambers
11,000 N. La Canada Drive
I. Call to Order: at or after 5:00 p.m.
II. Roll Call.
III. Call to the Audience.
IV. Approval of May 14, 2008, minutes.
V. Introduction of commission candidates: Patrick Foley, and Valerie Pullara.
VI. Discussion and possible action regarding Steam Pump Ranch.
VII. Discussion and possible action regarding Oro Valley Historical Society Liaison.
VIII. Discussion and possible action regarding HPC Work Plan.
a. CLG Application
b. Cultural Resource Inventory Plan
c. Budget
d. Community Outreach
e. Process Plan for Historic Designation
f. Role of the HPC
g. Training
IX. Discussion and possible action regarding HPC special projects:
X National Alliance of Historic Commission
X . HPC Rules
L XII. Santa Cruz Heritage Alliance
_XI'II. Announcements.
�X . Items for future agendas.
X I X Adjourn.
,� fou n.
Posted: 06 05 08
2:00 p.m.
cp
\\Colndev\pz l\PROJECTS\Historic Preservation Commission\agendas\2008
The Town of Oro Valley complies with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). If any person(s)
with a disability needs any type of accommodation, please notify the Town Clerk's office at (520)
229-4700.
INSTRUCTIONS TO SPEAKERS
Members of the public have the right to speak during any posted public hearing. However, those
items not listed as a public hearing are for consideration and action by the Commission during
the course of their business meeting. Members of the public may be allowed to speak on these
topics at the discretion of the Chair.
If you wish to address the Commission on any item(s) on this agenda, please complete a speaker card
located on the Agenda table at the back of the room and give it to the Recording Secretary. Please
indicate on the speaker card which item number and topic you wish to speak on, or if you wish to
speak during "Call to Audience", please specify what you wish to discuss when completing the
blue speaker card.
Please step forward to the podium when the Chair announces the item(s) on the agenda which you are
interested in addressing.
1. For the record, please state your name and whether or not you are a Town resident...
2. Speak only on the issue currently being discussed by Commission. Please organize your speech, you
will only be allowed to address the Commission once regarding the topic being discussed.
3. Please limit your comments to 3 minutes.
4. During "Call to Audience" you may address the Commission on any issue you wish.
5. Any member of the public speaking must speak in a courteous and respectful manner to those present.
Thank you for your cooperation.
"Notice of Possible Quorum of the Oro Valley Town Council and the Planning and Zoning
Commission: In accordance with Chapter 3, Title 38, Arizona Revised Statutes and Section 2-4-2
of the Oro Valley Town Code, a majority of the Town Council or Commission may attend the above
referenced meeting as a member of the audience only."
\\Comdev\pzl\PROJECTS\Historic Preservation Commission\agendas\2008
DRAFT MINUTES
ORO VALLEY HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
REGULAR SESSION
IT'May 1-5, 2008
ORO VALLEY COUNCIL CHAMBERS
11000 N. LA CANADA DRIVE
I. Call to Order: at of after 5:00 p.m.
II. Roll Call.
Present: Chair Bob Baughman
Commissioner Marilyn Cook
Commissioner Lois Nagy
Commissioner Daniel Zwiener
Excused: Commissioner Pat Spoerl
Also Present: Pamela Pelletier, Planner
Lexa Mack, Civil Attorney
Scott Nelson, Special Projects Coordinator
III. Call to the Audience.
No speakers.
IV. Approval of April 14, 2008 minutes.
Commissioner Zwiener asked if there should have been something in the minutes on
Item VI to reflect that there was some action to forward information to the council.
Chair Baughman suggested since there was no motion last meeting forwarding
information to the council, that the current minutes should note the Historic Preservation
Commission (HPC) discussion on the preservation easement for Steam Pump Ranch
resulted in positive changes that benefited the Town.
MOTION: Commissioner Nagy MOVED to approve the Historic Preservation
Commission April 14, 2008, meeting minutes as written. Commissioner Zwiener
seconded the motion. Motion carried 4:0.
V. Discussion and possible action regarding election of Vice Chair for two
months.
Vice Chair Salette Latas has resigned effective May 12, and the Vice Chair vacancy
needs to be filled for the two months, and until her position is filled.
Commissioner Nagy nominated Commissioner Zwiener to fill the Vice Chair position.
May 15, 2008 Draft Historic Preservation Commission Minutes
There being no other nominees, Chair Baughman asked for a motion of acclamation.
MOTION: Commissioner Nagy MOVED to elect Commissioner Zwiener by
acclamation. Commissioner Cook seconded the motion. Motion carried 4:0.
VI. Discussion and possible action regarding the Oro Valley Historical Society
Liaison.
Chair Baughman asked for a motion to table this item until Commission Spoerl is in
attendance as she has been involved in the Oro Valley Historical Society since founded.
MOTION: Commissioner Zwiener MOVED to table item VI until the next HPC
meeting. Commissioner Cook seconded the motion. Motion carried 4:0.
VII. Discussion and possible action regarding Historic Preservation Conference
in Rio Rico June 12-14, 2008.
The Planning and Zoning Director would like the HPC to nominate a commissioner to
attend this conference in place of staff. Registration and hotel costs will be paid for.
Commissioner Zwiener volunteered to go to the conference.
MOTION: Commissioner Nagy MOVED to authorize Commissioner Zwiener to
attend the Historic Preservation Conference in Rio Rico June 12 - 14, 2008.
Commissioner Cook seconded the motion. Motion carried 4:0.
VIII. Discussion and possible action regarding Heritage Grant for Steam Pump
Ranch.
Mrs. Pelletier gave a brief descripti8on of the Arizona State Parks Historic Preservation
heritage Fund 2008 Draft Grant Application. The State Historic Preservation Office
(SHPO) has been consulted and they support the concept for the Pusch ranch house.
Chair Baughman stated for the record that SHPO did participate in the Steam Pump
Ranch Task Force.
The Commissioners reviewed the Draft Grant Application and suggested corrections.
MOTION: Commissioner Zwiener MOVED to approve the grant application; to
draft a letter from the Commission to the Town Council recommending approval
of the grant application; to draft a letter from the commission to the Arizona State
Parks Historic Preservation Heritage Fund for inclusion in the grant proposal,
recommending that the Fund approve the grant application, and to authorize the
Chair to approve each letter. Commissioner Cook seconded the motion. Motion
carried 4:0.
2
May 15, 2008 Draft Historic Preservation Commission Minutes
IX. Discussion and possible action regarding the Role of the HPC at Steam
Pump Ranch.
Mr. Nelson said there is no role for the HPC as a whole for the short term.
Commissioners Zwiener and Spoerl's expertise will be needed to go through what is
left, after the Lieber's have moved their possessions, to decide what has historic
significance. Those items identified can be stored in the barn. There may be a definite
long term role for the HPC.
Chair Baughman said he would like to continue this discussion including a long term
role as a future agenda item.
MOTION: Commissioner Zwiener MOVED to continue item 9, the long term role of
HPC at Steam Pump Ranch, and items 10 and 11. Commissioner Cook seconded
the motion. Motion carried 4:0.
X. Discussion and possible action regarding HPC Work Plan. (This item was
continued per item IX motion above.)
a. CLG Application
b. Cultural Resource Inventory Plan
c. Budget
d. Community Outreach
e. Process Plan for Historic Designation
f. Role of the HPC
g. Training
Xl. Discussion and possible action regarding HPC special projects: (This item
was continued per item IX motion above.)
a. National Alliance of Historic Commissions
b. HPC Rules
c. Santa Cruz Heritage Alliance
XII. Announcements.
- May 23 is Mrs. Pelletier's last day with the Town. Scott Nelson will be taking on the
staff role as the Planning and Zoning liaison to the HPC. Staff role will be different.
- Mr. Nelson volunteered for this role as liaison to help the team. He stated that he will
not be able to give the amount of staff support that Mrs. Pelletier has given over the
past year. Council has indicated they want to make the department whole. Once the
budget is passed, additional positions will be filled and another staff person may take
over this role.
- Legal staff will not be attending future meetings unless their presence has been
requested by the Planning and Zoning Director, by order of the Town Attorney.
- A Transportation Enhancement grant proposal is being worked on and will go to
Council as a resolution on June 4. It will be emailed to the commissioners for review
3
May 15, 2008 Draft Historic Preservation Commission Minutes
and commentary by the end of the week.
- A photo, of the back of the Lieber house, dated June 26, 1940, was shown. The
Lieber's are setting items aside for the Town.
- The Lieber's physically vacated Steam Pump Ranch on April 23, 2008. The Police
Department and a Task Force designed a security plan consisting of night and daytime
patrol. Motion detector lights will be replaced with photo cell lights that will be on dusk
to dawn. Once the Lieber house is cleaned, the police will be able to do paperwork
there at night. The bike patrol, when organized, will operate out of the house.
- Interviews for HPC vacancies will be May 19, at 2:00 p.m. Interviewers are Mrs.
Pelletier, Chair Baughman, the Council liaison and Scott Nelson.
- Mr. Nelson reported on the budget session from May 3. Currently there is $40,000 to
$50,000 in the budget for the survey.
- Chair Baughman expressed thanks to Mrs. Pelletier for her efforts in progressing the
Commission to their current position.
XIII. Items for future agendas.
No new items were added.
XIV. Adjourn.
MOTION: Commissioner Zwiener MOVED to adjourn the HPC meeting.
Commissioner Cook seconded the motion. Motion carried 4:0.
Meeting adjourned at 5:55 p.m.
Prepared by:
Diane Chapman
Senior Office Specialist
4
',L
•
s
•1`- yY¢..+moi o'�'c"__Tn
A
4
• -.1111111111.
ORO VALLEY VOLUNTEER APPOINTMENT APPLICATION
Dear Oro Valley Citizen:
We appreciate your interest in the Town of Oro Valley. This informational form,when completed, will allow us to quickly process your
application. A list describing the Town's Boards and Commissions is attached for your reference. Information reflecting the procedures
surrounding the appointment process to Boards is also attached. Your application will remain on file for two years from date of receipt.
Your supplying this data will greatly assist us in understanding how we can best use your talents and experience. We thank you kindly for
volunteering to serve the Town.
Please note: No volunteer shall serve on more than one standing Board at any time and must have resided in the Town for 1 year.
Please return to the Town Clerk's Office,11,000 North La Canada Drive,Oro Valley,Arizona 85737.
Name lx C Cx V CA\Q rule --
—
Last First Middle
Address Oro hu` SS-439
Street City State Zip
Home Phone Business Phone Sad- b Email
Number of Years in Oro Valley a / (Must be a resident of the Town for 1 year.)
Signature(1)citents), D. Date -1 13 -0
' x�
Please indicate the board or commission you wish to join:'1:=1S r r,�: vc� �_ Fi 1'\cr)($.I Bz r'10
Please list your volunteer services in Oro Valley and with other organizations including any boards or commissions on which you have
served:(board/commission,civic,educational,cultural,social,etc.)
t v ot.Lmk- Cor �.. C.DC7 5xLc() club cab li;. &.5al r ar arty i e x r c mhu,Y'e;
P,w ,Arbon pr erok Cz n-m k.slk s s_ r..Q S u,ryNa. PAY FLAN\NV) 1).it,k c s
How does your previous volunteer service prepare you for the board or commission appointment for which you have applied? Please
describe an issue considered at a meeting of the Board or Commission for which you are applying.
1-x &sz. si c s (srn(SI cnr) r S J tv)c csz c r\s- k, r1 •
S rn i 1)Lo n . i ,Grn 0 oke, S cu.A.D 515r r ti n Tth rvir ) ego PCAA k.S
p.r e\JLCA. SAIL N_as rte. .
Have you attended the Citizens Planning Institute? N 0 Are you willing to attend? CS
Briefly describe your educational/vocational background.
rniv5tiz.rs in riNG.na rr rvi . ,L uno�s C• rrr f r 1 r f
• a
L.00 S+rr>I c. tLs cam, hcA.W2 CV.O.S4 psr UnCK, orm0 k cin rf\u r>cL
c\T CCCSL Om hlsAc r C. PnQ U40,tLln
IF DESIRED,ADDITIONAL INFORMATION MAY BE ATTACHED
NA ww.tcm noforoval le\.com 4/18/06
Valerie D.Pullara
Objective A position with a dynamic municipality that will offer exciting challenges and allow me to utilize my
vast skills and experience in Human Resources to make a positive contribution to the growth and
stability of the organization.
Summary of Comprehensive hands-on experience in organizational management,human resources,inter-
Qualifications company infrastructure development,program implementation,regulatory compliance and strategic
planning for two cities,non-profits and for-profit companies.
Manage full P&L and budget functions,along with contractual negotiations and administration,
accurate documentation and report preparation,grant writing and knowledge of proactive
long/short term resource development.
Consistently recognized by executive management and clients as a Change Agent with multi-tasking
talents in team leadership,organization,communication and problem resolution in high-pressure
situations.
Work Experience Human Resources Director, Call Maximizer,Tucson,AZ Juy 2006-Cur-rent
Direct all human resource operations for a high tech multi-site global
contact center for 150 employees.
• Successfully assisted company business leaders design and manage the
organization review process which includes detailed succession planning,
organization design,development planning and workforce planning.
• Effectively partner and provided dynamic tools to support
organizational initiatives such as organization design,large scale change,
team effectiveness and individual coaching at individual,team and
organization levels.
• Successful development and implementation of new payroll,HR,and
time/labor systems.
• Successful management of performance management which includes
written reviews and ratings,clearly linking pay to performance,and
defining potential and leadership.
• Creation and implementation of an employee evaluation and leadership
development programs.
• Coordinate recruiting,hiring,benefits and training programs to support
multi sites.
• Provide Management with effective tools,techniques,and processes to
help identify and develop high-organizational development potential.
• Successfully developed Leadership Development Programs and
participant placement. Act as a partner with business operations to
recruit and select candidates for the growth opportunity programs.
• Assisted in the creation and implementation of skill set assessments and
perform gap analysis to determine and deliver appropriate training
programs.
1
Administration/Development Director, Tucson Audubon Society, June 2005—Jut,2006
Tucson,AZ
Responsible for the leadership and management of all development
activities to ensure the long term financial stability of the organization.
• Developed a successful membership program that retained and increased
memberships.
• Developed new fundraising activities that brought in over$40,000 to the
organization.
• Researched grants opportunities with 90%success rate in obtaining
funding.
• Developed long term giving programs to establish a sustainable revenue
stream through strengthening community and donor partnerships.
Executive Director,American Red Cross,Butler County,OH(350,000 May 2003 March 2005
pop.)
Served as the Executive Director for the sixth largest Ohio Red Cross
Chapter. (merger of two large chapters)
• Instituted new human resource programs to facilitate the merger of two
large chapters.
• Developed long term health and safety programs to establish a
sustainable revenue stream through strengthening community,
government and donor partnerships.
• Instituted new financial development initiatives that increased the
Chapter's financial donors by 3%.
Chief Operating Officer,Brighton Properties,Newport,KY March 2001 May 2003
Responsible for all non-profit property management,(20 million)and
economic development(1.2 million)company.
• Instituted a wide range of effective resources for economic development
and construction revitalization programs to promote single-family home
ownership and downtown community development.
• Project manager for the development and building of 2.5 million dollar
community center.
• Successfully developed strong partnerships with local governments,
funders and corporate entities to create new economic revitalization and
homeownership opportunities.
2
City Manager, City of Wheat Ridge,CO December 1999-September 2000
Responsible for all municipal services under Council/City Manager Charter
form of government. Oversaw a staff of 250 employees,$16 million dollar
operating budget,separate capital improvement fund and several enterprise
funds.
• Instituted a wide range of effective economic development and
construction revitalization programs to promote city economic
diversification and modernization.
• Key participant in opening a 71,000 square foot recreational facility with
state-of-the-art services.
• Served as the City's Human Resource Director. Developed and
implemented new personnel policies.
• Lead the implementation of completely revising and updating the zoning
and building compliance codes to streamline area development plans.
• Acquired and developed plans for parks and open space by expediting
negotiations for the Clear Creek Greenbelt with Coors Brewing
Company.
City Administrator, City of Fenton,MO December 1993—December 1999
Responsible for all municipal services under Council/City Administrator
Charter form of government. Oversaw a staff of 200 employees,$7.5
million dollar operating budget,separate capital improvement fund and$10
million in reserves.
• Instituted a wide range of effective economic development and
construction revitalization programs to promote city economic
diversification and modernization.
• Directed the entire design/construction of a$24 million 72,000 square
foot recreational facility with state-of-the-art services.
• Served as the City's Human Resource Director. Developed and
implemented new personnel policies.
• Lead the implementation of completely revising and updating the zoning
and building compliance codes to streamline area development plans.
• Acquired and developed plans for 400 acres of parks and open space.
• Successfully negotiated contracts for telecommunications networks,
information systems,cable access,city utilities,MDOT infrastructure
and other vital community services.
• Spearheaded successful"A"Bond rating for a$52 million tax increment
financing bond issue.
Previous Experience:
Oversaw all contractual and risk management compliance
policies/procedures as Regional Contracts Manager for 8 offices around the
United States for a$30 million environmental consulting,facility design and
construction management company.(1991-1993)
Supervised a team of three as a Senior Paralegal for several law offices in
Madison and Milwaukee,Wisconsin for over six years,specializing in
complex employment law,litigation,construction,insurance and workers
compensation law. (1985-1991)
3
Education Masters—Management, Webster University
B.S.in Political Science/Education,University of Wisconsin
ABA Approved,Lawyers Assistant Program
Additional Familiar with MS Windows,UNIX,PeopleSoft,ADP,HR/Benefit
Information Software,Excel,Powerpoint,Access,HTM programming and other
complex programs.
SHRM Member,GT-SHRM member,Co-chair for Call Center HR
Directors Consortium,active grants committee member for Arizona
Greyhound Rescue,CDO Soccer Club Board Member and Club Registrar,
volunteer for Tucson Audubon Society,completed the ICMA University
Workshops,as well as courses on facilitation skills,personnel management
and strategic planning.Serviced on the Times Beach Recovery Committee,
Served as Chairperson,South Bank—Economic Revitalization Citizen
Advisory Committee,Past member of Colorado Telecommunications
Negotiation Team,volunteer for Junior Achievement,and past Board
member for Arizona's Environmental Fund Action Group.
4
•
9-,,i,.i''14'4 i.r;',:,..,:. ,....i.,, ,-,..*,-,....-n f,,,,.. • :f3:
'..).VW, •
ii';i4.,i;‘..,..;,?L'.;iq-hgti . .
(04
y,6-, se •
ORO
VALLEY VOLUNTEER APPOINTMENT APPLICATION
Dear Oro Valley Citizen:
We appreciate your interest in the Town of Oro Valley. This informational form,when completed,will allow us to quickly process your
e
application:.A list describing the Town's Boards and-Commissions is attachedfor your reference. Information reflecting the procedures
surrounding the appoin process rocess to Boards is.also attached. Your application will remain on file for two years from date of receipt.
•
• us in understandinghow we can best use your talents and experience. We thank you kindly for
Your supplying this data will greatly assist
volunteering to serve the Town.
Please.note: No volunteer shall serve
*on more than one standing Board at any time and must.have resided in the Town for 1 year.
's•Office, 11 000..North La Cafiada Drive,Oro Valley,Arizona'85737.
Please return to the Town Clerk ,
• PATRICK - ARTHUR
Name FOLEY. .•L . . • Fust • Middle
•
•
Street City State Zip
.Phone 326-4343 Email
Home Phone Business.Pho
::FIVE YEARS ust be a resident of the Town for 1 year.)
Number of Years in Oro Valley _
nature d
' Date APRIL 28, 2008
7 —
• • • ' • • •L.,�bi������f•��H9�"�� ��`,,mss'� �� rt�I�t^/Pa Ji�+`S AND J�/C.,
j.:X'M 3 e�r is
Please indicate the board or commission you wish to join.
OR PLANNING AND ZONING
Please list yo
ur volunteer services in Oro Valley and with other organizations including any boards or commissions on which you have
served:(board/commission,civic,educational,cultural,social,etc.)
_CUENT BOARD MEMBERARIZONA FUNERAL DIRECTORS ASSOCIATIO
QUINCY •AND
ADAMS COUNTY HISTORICAL SOCIETY—PAST BOARD MEMBER
DIRECTOR OF QUINCY IL. MASTERS ADULT SOCCER LEAGUE—PAST DIRECTOR
•
volunteer.service prepare you for the board or commission appointment for which you.have applied? Please
How does your previous P P
describe an issue considered at a meeting of the Board or Commission for which you are applying:
COMMITMENT TO ATTENDANCE AND PARTICIPATION, KNOWLEDGE OF. BOARD PROCEDURES
ISSUES. HISTORICAL PRESERVATION—INCREASED DISTRIBUTION OF EDUACATIONAL MATERIALS TO
AND REC: INCREASE OF SMALLER REGIONAL & RESIDENTIAL PARKS DEVELOPMENT
G
THE PUBLIC, PARKS .
• . , NE.`. v%� • • ••1•i • •� I t •� ' ANT
PLANNING & ZONIN : MAINTAINING:..RU . FEEL I F i I.
& HIGH TRAFFIC AREAS WITHOUT IMF_F. DING. DEVELOPMENT .
-lave you
attended the Citizens Planning Institute?: -•-YES Are you willing to attend? .....
3riefly describeour educational/vocational background.
GRADUATE OF WORSHAM COLLEGE OF MORTUARY SCIENCE.— CHICAGO, IL
FUNERAL DIRECTOR FOR 14 YEARS, ILLINOIS & ARIZONA
LICENSED . .
LICENSED LIFE INSURANCE AGENT — ARIZONA
.•. IF DESIRED;ADDITIONAL INFORMATION MAY BE ATTACHED
. • www.townoforovalley.com 4/18/06
_GENERAL MANAGER OF ADAIR FUNERAL .HOMES, INC„ FIVE LOCATIONS IN ARIZONA
OWNER OF ARCHITECTURAL PLAQUE AND MONUMENT COMPANY— ORO VALLEY
;;;.....,..
Ch.. Fwd 11PC mooting etc
. . . June 6, 2008 3:22:18 PM GMT-07:00
Q n++or�hmar�+c' e„6.7 V1
L1 I n t LCd c t l 1 a its, i\LJ
Bob. I notice that a possible liaison between the HPC and OVHS is on the agenda again for the
HPC meeting Monday.Monda . Since I won't be there 1 would just like to note that when President Dick
Eggerding spoke to the HPC he suggested that we might have a joint study session to talk about
gg g
ways the HPC and OVHS can work together. I checked with Dick to make sure that was the case
rather than having a liaison person appointed. That was his intent. Steam Pump would be a good
project long-term that involves both entities. Dan and I talked a little about cooperative efforts to
help the Town with cleanup and inventory while we were working at the Ranch this week.
Pat
Original Message
From• Chapman, Diane <achaprnan@oro
To• ct_1ti
Cc: Nelson. Scottei c; @ _ Eu& a �__�� :>; More, Sarah < t .. ;
Sent: Fri, 6 Jun 2008 1:42 pm
Subject: HPC meeting, etc.
Attached please find the posted agenda for the Monday, 6/9/08, HPC meeting. I
o included the last meetingminutes foryour review. Seeyou Monday at
have a s
5:00 pin the Council Chambers.
Diane Chapman
Senior Office Specialist
Planning and Zoning bepartment
Town of Oro Valley
520.229.4815
Cpatspri@aol.
FwdM• IPC�r mooting, etc
■
June 6, 2008 3:22:18 P M GMT-07:00
J Attachments, 86.-7 1Q3
Bob, I notice that a possible liaison between the HPC and OVHS is on the agenda again for the
HPC meeting this Monday. Since I won't be there I would just like to note that when President Dick
Eggerding spoke to the HPC he suggested that we might have a joint study session to talk about
ways the HPC and OVHS can work together. I checked with Dick to make sure that was the case
rather than having a liaison person appointed. That was his intent. Steam Pump would be a good
long-term project that involves both entities. Dan and I talked a little about cooperative efforts to
help the Town with cleanup and inventory while we were working at the Ranch this week.
Pat
Original Message
From: Chapman, DianA <, rha^ a n@o v nov..
>
.
Cc: Nelson. Scott `�
<��} � �����������?���������-�� �� _�> More; Sarah .: �-���,� orc:.ai� ./a .ar•,v>
Sent: Fri, 6 Jun 2008 1:42 pm
Subject: HPC meeting, etc.
Attached please find the posted agenda for the Monday, 6/9/08, HPC meeting. I
have also included the last meeting minutes for your review. See you Monday at
5:00p.m. in the Council Chambers.
Diane Chapman
Senior Office Specialist
PlanningZoning and bepartment
Town of Oro Valley
520.229.4815
Report on Work at Steam Pump Ranch
June, 2008
Commissioners Spoerl and Zwiener
Introduction
As per discussion and recommendation of the Commission at its regular meeting May 15, 2008,
Commissioners Spoerl and Zwiener conducted a preliminary survey of historic artifacts and features
inside the buildings and around the property at Steam Pump Ranch. Scott Nelson, Oro Valley's Special
Projects Coordinator, accompanied the commissioners during much of the inspection. Most of the
survey was conducted on Wednesday and Thursday, June 4-5, 2008. On Friday, June 6, Commissioner
Zwiener and Coordinator Nelson also met with Lieutenant Ed Schaefer of OVPD's Technical Support
Division and Sergeant Amy Sloane of the Community Resources Unit to discuss security at the site.
Both commissioners made a photographic record of the survey.
Survey of Historic Artifacts
The commissioners, in order to identify historically significant artifacts and resolve storage issues for
those items, completed a preliminary,building-by-building survey. The outside grounds were also
inspected. The following observations are reported.
The Ranch House
The Ranch House should be ready for cleaning after removal and storage of four items:
1. A Sames brand piano and bench found in the southeast porch. Commissioner Spoerl reports
that Sames pianos were in production in Birmingham, England from the 1860's until at least the
1920's when the factory may have burned. Perhaps we could ask Cheryl Leiber or Hank Zipf if
they remember anything about the piano. We suggest removal and storage of the piano and
bench and possible restoration if indicated.
2. A possible antique bed in the southwest room. Further inspection of this bed will be possible
if it can be safely cleaned and removed for storage.
3. A possible antique casserole dish found in the kitchen cupboard. It was removed to the
Procter/Leiber kitchen area for storage.
4. A sketch or watercolor of an unidentified woman. Also removed to the Procter/Lieber
kitchen.
There was a box of recent personal records found in the southeast room. After removal of the above
items, the Ranch House should be ready for environmentally safe cleaning in preparation for further
work.
The Pump House
Upon inspection and photographing, the commissioners suggest close monitoring by archaeologists prior
to and during restoration work. The underground features and infrastructure in the vicinity of the Pump
House may need mapping, and recovery of artifacts in the area may be needed. It is suggested that the
spatial relationship of this structure to surrounding features and activities at the site be further studied.
The Bunk Houses
Both Bunk Houses were inspected and only a possible antique wicker coffee table and candleholder
were removed to the Proctor/Leiber kitchen. A cash register located just outside the entrance to the north
Bunk House should be removed for storage.
Garage/Workers Housing
This building holds the bulk of items that will be in need of further inspection and storage. A large
number of furniture items,books, and personal records are stored here. Initial inspection revealed estate
records dated to the 1940s that included a 1945 Brand Certificate. A box of personal items was moved
to the Proctor/Leiber kitchen. The room designated 172 NSF on the west side of the building contains
several furniture items of interest. It is also suggested that a more thorough inspection be made of the
walk-in cooler on the west side with the possibility that it be preserved. Also outside this room to the
north is an older-model condenser that may be preserved as well. This building, along with the chicken
coops, will be the focus of a larger scale effort to identify and preserve historic items.
Proctor/Leiber Residence
Any items of historic interest here have been moved into the kitchen area. This would include a box of
personal records with a large number of stationary pages, a wooden clock, a framed watercolor, and a
lamp. OVPD, Special Projects Coordinator Nelson, and Commissioner Zwiener were unable to resolve
what should be done with the safe located in the bathroom at the extreme north end of the house. This is
an area of the house that is a recent add-on and slated for removal in the master plan.
Carlos' House/Former Barbecue Pavilion
There were no historic items identified here. Any work near or around the barbecue/fireplace inside
should be closely monitored. Although it may be difficult to'do,both Commissioner Zwiener and
Spoerl suggest that the seating area consisting of an arrangement of personal items created by caretaker
Carlos be preserved in place. It is suggested that the tree to the south of the building and an area roughly
10 Ft. in diameter containing items hanging from that tree and buried beneath the soil be preserved if
possible.
Chicken Coops
Until issues resolving this area are completed, it is suggested that the large number of historic items
contained in the remaining rooms be removed and inspected for historic importance. There will be some
safety issues to be resolved prior to any activity in this area. It is also suggested that any building
materials altered or removed in this effort be preserved. It may be that a photographic record could be
made of the roofing materials in place prior to removal for storage,making the area safer for any work
that would be done there. Any items deemed historically important should be removed and stored.
Tack Building
A piano of unknown brand name was located in the Tack Building on the extreme north end of the
property. It should be determined if it should be removed for storage.
Remaining Grounds and Buildings
An antique jukebox (possibly from the 1940s)was located in the machine repair shops located at the
west side of the property. It should be removed and stored.
All other areas not specified above, upon initial inspections, should be clear for future work. The
following general observations and suggestions should be considered:
1. It is suggested that any wood that appears to be of historic origins be set aside for storage. It is
possible that wood found on the site was taken from dismantled buildings and corals, or from the
blacksmith shop. Several current furniture makers in the state use historic wood in their craft.
2. It is suggested that a more thorough survey be made to identify historic features in and around
the Ranch House, historic corrals, and Pump House.
Commissioners Zwiener and Spoerl will continue their work at the site in the following weeks and will
be working with other parties to resolve issues recommended for action at the May 15, 2008 meeting.