Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutOV1601741NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING Oro Valley Conceptual Design Review Board The Conceptual Design Review Board will hold a public meeting on Tuesday, August 9, 2016, 6 p.m. Oro Valley Town Hall,11000 N. La Canada Dr. Oro Valley, Arizona Revised Master Sign Program for the Rooney Ranch Shopping Center, including the Fry's Grocery and Fuel Center, located at 10661 N. Oracle Road, OV1601741. The revision is to allow electronic changeable copy signs for fuel pricing. The meeting will be in the Town Council Chambers. The public is encouraged to attend and will be invited to speak. An agenda for this meeting will be made available at least 24 hours prior to meeting time and can be viewed at www.orovallevaz.gov. For questions and additional information, please contact Patty Hayes, Senior Planning Technician at (520) 229- 4819 or phayes(W-orovalleyaz.gov. Posted: 7/22/2016 Time: 3:00 pm By: rmf \\SILVER\permits\PERMPLUS\DOCS\OV1601741 MSP Rooney Ranchl1 CDRB Notice.doc Town of Oro Valley Development and Infrastructure Services TOWN OF ORO VALLEY NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING Oro Valley Conceptual Design Review Board The Conceptual Design Review Board will hold a public meeting on Tuesday, August 9, 2016, 6 p.m. Oro Valley Town Hall, 11000 N. La Canada Dr. Oro Valley, Arizona Conceptual Architecture for the Canyon Del Oro Baptist Church, located at 9200 N. Oracle Road, OV1601613. Revised Sign Criteria for the Magee Plaza, located at 8085 N. Oracle Road, OV1601513. The revision is to expand the color palette and sign design for the development. Conceptual Model Home Architecture for Mattamy Homes Rancho Vistoso Parcel 5F, located on the northeast corner of Rancho Vistoso Boulevard and Moore Road (OV1315-11). Revised Master Sign Program for the Rooney Ranch Shopping Center, including the Fry's Grocery and Fuel Center, located at 10661 N. Oracle Road, OV1601741. The revision is to allow electronic changeable copy signs for fuel pricing. The meeting will be in the Town Council Chambers. The public is encouraged to attend and will be invited to speak. An agenda for this meeting will be made available at least 24 hours prior to meeting time and can be viewed at www.orovallevaz.gov. For questions and additional information, please contact Patty Hayes, Senior Planning Technician at (520) 229- 4819 or phayes(a.orovalieyaz.gov. POSTED: 07/22/2016 TIME: 3:00 PM BY: rmf Oro Valley, it's in our nature. 11000 N. La Canada Drive, Oro Valley, Arizona 85737 www.orovalleyaz.gov I phone: (520) 229-4800 1 fax: (520) 742-1022 Master Sign Program Revision a ,! Conceptual Design Review Board Staff Report °DNDED 1ST O" CASE NUMBER: OV1601741 MEETING DATE: August 9, 2016 AGENDA ITEM: 4 STAFF CONTACT: Patty Hayes, Senior Planning Technician phayesC@-orovallevaz.gov (520) 229-4819 Applicant: Andy Gibson Request: Revise Master Sign Program Location: Rooney Ranch Parcel D at Oracle Rd. and First Avenue Recommendation: Recommend approval of revised Master Sign Program SUMMARY: The proposed revision (Attachment 1) to the Rooney Ranch Master Sign Program (MSP) is to allow the following: • Electronic changeable copy for fuel prices • An additional monument sign, for the fuel prices, at the First Avenue entrance The MSP currently allows electronic changeable copy for theaters only. Also, the current MSP site plan does not provide a location specifically for a fuel price monument sign on the northern side of the property. The proposed revised MSP will allow electronic changeable copy for theaters and fuel stations and add a location for an additional monument sign for fuel prices. The Conceptual Design Review Board (CDRB) reviews Master Sign Programs and makes recommendations to Town Council. BACKGROUND: The Rooney Ranch Development, as shown in Attachment 2, had a revised master sign program approved in 2012 that specifically limited electronic changeable copy for theaters . The zoning code allows fuel centers to have electronic changeable copy as a component of a sign. The proposed monument sign with electronic changeable copy in the revised MSP is no different than signs already found in the Town as demonstrated in Attachment 3. Existing Site Conditions • Zoning is Rooney Ranch Planned Area Development Parcel D • Development includes completed retail, grocery, fuel and restaurant uses OV1601741 Rooney Ranch Master Sign Program Revision Page 2 of 3 Conceptual Design Review Board Staff Report Proposed Improvements A new fuel center is proposed to be built in the northern section of the development near the Fry's grocery store. As with any fuel station, a sign showing the fuel prices is requested to be placed on the property. Below is a summary of the current and proposed changes to the MSP in comparison with the zoning code. Current MSP Proposed MSP Zoning Code Electronic Allowed only for Allow for theaters, dinner Allows for fuel centers changeable "theater and dinner theaters and fuel stations copy theaters" copy signs Location Not provided One (1) fuel sign in May have more than 2 addition to the previously monument style signs approved multi -tenant off First Ave. including monument sign at the fuel center sign First Ave. entrance. Quantity None One fuel sign per street One fuel sign per street frontage frontage Size None 28 square feet 1 32 square feet DISCUSSION / ANALYSIS: The CDRB reviews Master Sign Programs for conformance with the adopted Design Principles. The Design Principles and Design Standards (italics) are listed below, followed by staff comments. Design Principle Analvsis • Section 22.9.D.5.b.iv. "Signs: Sign colors, design and placement shall be complementary and integral to the projects architecture and sign design themes." The proposed fuel center monument sign continues the same design features and colors as the other monument signs currently found in the Rooney Ranch MSP. Design Standards Analysis • Section 28.B.3. Review of a Master Sign Program shall be guided by the following: Overall character of the entire development, including landscaping, architecture, topography, uses and design. The Rooney Ranch development is an established 41 acre commercial development located on the west side of Oracle Road between First Avenue and Pusch View Lane. The proposed fuel center monument sign continues the same updated style and color scheme as the other signs in the development and in the current MSP. OV1601741 Rooney Ranch Master Sign Program Revision Page 3 of 3 Conceptual Design Review Board Staff Report General Plan Polices • The General Plan requires a balance between a businesses need to attract customers and provide the least intrusive signage. The proposed signage would improve the fuel center's visibility to vehicular traffic while not impacting adjacent properties. The adjacent development across First Avenue is another commercial development with monument signs of its own therefore there would be no adverse impact by the additional sign. RECOMMENDATION: Based on the finding that the proposed application is consistent with the Design Principles and Design Standards and electronic changeable copy signs for fuel centers are allowed by the Zoning Code, it is recommended that the Conceptual Design Review Board take the following action: Recommend approval of the revised Master Sign Program, case number OV1601741. SUGGESTED MOTIONS: I move to recommend approval of the revised Master Sign Program for the Rooney Ranch Center allowing electronic changeable copy and the additional monument sign based on the finding that the request is consistent with the Design Principles and Design Standards. xv I move to recommend denial of the revised Master Sign Program for the Rooney Ranch Center as it does not meet the finding that ATTACHMENTS: 1. Applicants Submittal a) Revisions include: i. Page 5 Note Revision ii. Page D3 Proposed Monument Sign iii. Page D4 Revised Site Plan 2. Location Map 3. Photos of the Similar Signs MzjW 1VJ '/i N�FAJ 'Manager F v ^ ra •w r � = Location of proposed fuel station sign Site Map/Aerial Photo Rooney Ranch (OV1601741) Attachment 2 POvA"i+ AR,2'r OU`�DE[[ to Existing Fuel Signs in Oro Valley Fuel Station Signs Rooney Ranch (OV1601741) Attachment 3 TOWN OF ORO VALLEY NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING TOWN COUNCIL The Town Council invites the community to attend a public hearing on Wednesday, September 7, 2016, 6 p.m. Council Chambers, 11000 N. La Canada Dr. Oro Valley, Arizona Public Hearing: A revised Master Sign Program for the Rooney Ranch Shopping Center, including the Fry's Grocery and Fuel Center, located at 10661 N. Oracle Road, The revision is to allow a monument and sign electronic changeable copy for fuel pricing. (OV1601741). The meeting will be in the Town Council Chambers. The public is encouraged to attend and will be invited to speak. An agenda for this meeting will be made available at least 24 hours prior to meeting time and can be viewed at www.orovallevaz.gov. For questions and additional information, please contact Patty Hayes, Senior Planning Technician at (520) 229- 4819 or Phayes(aD-orovalle a�gov. Posted: 08/19/2016 Time: 10 am By: rmf \\SILVER\permits\PERMPLUS\DOCS\OV1601741 MSP Rooney Ranch\TC Sept\1 TC Notice.doc F APF`R0V,1c:,:D BY* IP IDRBIBOA I'L pZ FRWECT Wi AGER APPROVe1E,!Y ZWWDOA DATE PZ PROJECT MANAGER Oro Valley, 'Ariz @2012 Fluoresco Ughting Signs Master Sign P This original unpublished drawing Is submitted for use In connection with a project being designed for you by Fluoresco. It is not to be shown to outside .1 ,;;tt. ROONEY RANCH PARCEL D TABLE OF CONTENTS 1) Introduction........................................................................3 General Requirements / Freestanding Signage....................................4 Rooney Ranch Parcel D / Freestanding Signs......................................5 Refurbished monument Pusch View Lane......................................D-1 Refurbished monument Oracle Rd...............................................D-2 New double face monument & Theatre monument ............................D-3 Siteplan Parcel D...................................................................D-4 Parcel D Sign guidelines wall signs..............................................D-5a Parcel D Sign guidelines freestanding signs....................................D-5b Traffic & Pedestrian / Traffic Directional........................................D-6 Various Sign Types Elevations......................................................6 ColorPalette........................................................................... 7 ROONEY RANCH PARCEL D The Master Sign Program prepared for Rooney Ranch Parcel D will establish a uniform set of sign criteria to maintain continuity of quality and aesthetics throughout Rooney Ranch for the benefit of all tenants and the Town of Oro Valley. Based on the Oro Valley Zoning Code (OVZC), Chapter 28 and the Town's Design Standards Addendum A, for signage, the Master Sign Program will provide for signage that will vary throughout the development and will permit national and specialty retailers to identify their business utilizing recognized trademarks, logos, and color palettes. The Master Sign program will establish design guidelines for all tenants to follow. It will also establish a hierarchy of freestanding signs that will be used as an etTective waytinding system. All freestanding signs will follow a thematic design integrating the current elements of existing freestanding architectural elements into future freestanding signs as the center is brought up to date. The objective of the Master Sign Program is to create guidelines that will enable Rooney Ranch to update the current signage away from the Copper Patina that was required in the past and to be able to utilize some of the more modern methods and materials that are available. This will enable the signage to become a unique and integrated component of the development, to maintain an attractive and appealing environment consistent with the Oro Valley community. To continue to provide the services to the residents of the Town of Oro Valley in a way that is harmonious with other retail centers in the surrounding area. We would also like to make note of the fact that plans are being made for a re -paint of Rooney Ranch property some time in the near future. The designs and the colors that have been used in the Master Sign program for the freestanding signs will be incorporated into the building architecture in order to keep a consistent theme throughout Rooney Ranch. We trust this submittal meets with your expectations and approval. ROONEY RANCH PARCEL D General Requirements These criteria have been established by the developer for the purpose of maintaining updating the current signage and also to plan for future development of Rooney Ranch. as used herein, the term "Developer" shall also include all future successors. Assigns, and or designated agent. At such time if and when the signs are changed at Rooney Ranch the Town of Oro Valley will use this criteria to conduct there review. 1. GENERAL REQUIREMENTS A. The Town of Oro Valley shall review all freestanding signs for conformance with the criteria and OVZC. In the event that this criteria is silent and fails to address a specific sign type, definition or specification pertaining to a sign installation, and/or operation and maintenance of a sign, the OVZC shall regulate. B. Advertising devices such as attraction boards, posters, banners and flags shall not be permitted in addition to all prohibited sign types regulated by the OVZC. C. All Tenant signage shall be in accordance with the approved Master Sign Program D. No signage will be allowed on the rear of the Anchor, Major and Minor tenant buildings 2. SPECIFICATIONS — FREESTANDING SIGN A. General specification 1. All electrical cabinets, conductors, transformers and other equipment required to illuminate a freestanding sign shall be concealed. 3. GENERAL CONSTRUCTION and MAINTENANCE REQUIREMENTS A. All exterior signs shall be secured by concealed mounting mechanisms using non -corrosive fasteners. B. All signs shall be fabricated in a manor that prevents light leaks. C. All sign installation shall be neatly sealed in a watertight condition. D. No labels or other identification shall be permitted on the Exposed surface of signs except those required by local ordinance. This shall be in an inconspicuous location. E. Each sign shall be maintained in a new or like new condition at all times so as not to constitute a danger or hazard to public safety or become an eyesore to the community ROONEY RANCH PARCEL D 3. FREESTANDING SIGN DESIGN REQUIREMENTS A. Sign Type/ Parcel D 1. The refurbished double face signs (RDF) one at Pusch View Lane and Oracle Rd. and at the Wells Fargo entrance along Oracle Rd. also know as parcel "D". The project shall be identified with individual reverse pan channel illumination reading "Rooney Ranch" utilizing white LED's concealed within the pan channel letterform. Tenant signage will consist of routed out pan with a brushed aluminum overlay where only the characters may emit light. Tenant colors to follow freestanding matrix 2. The new double face sign (NDF) located at the main entrance on 1 st Avenue. This sign will be identified with either reverse pan channel, push thru acrylic letters or routed out copy with the brushed aluminum finish reading "Rooney Ranch" utilizing white LED's. Tenant colors to follow freestanding matrix. 2a. The new double face Theatre sign (NDF Theatre) is to be located along Oracle Road at an entrance point. This sign will use the same techniques as the (NDF) with the addition of an Electronic Message center at a size to be approximately 18"x 120" this will be a red grayscale LED. Tenant colors to follow freestanding matrix. It is important to note no electronic displays or signs with changable copy shall be erected or operated unless in association with a theater/dinner theater or fuel center. The electronic display of signs with changable copy shall cease operation upon discontinuance of the theater/dinner theater or fuel center use in Parcel D. 3. Traffic & Pedestrian Directional Sign (TPD) shall be located throughout the project. They are intended to be placed at traffic intersections and driveways as required to direct vehicular traffic throughout the project. The displays will include vehicular oriented "wayfinding" information such as Tenant listings with directional arrows. All copy will be reflective 3M Scotchlite. the locations and quantities illustrated on the site plan illustrate typical placements. Actual quantities and placement may vary with a maximum of six (6) for Parcel D. 4. Traffic Directional Sign (TD) Shall be located at entry points in the property to direct delivery trucks to the rear of the property. The display will include vehicular oriented "wayfinding" information such as deliveries, shipping or receiving with a directional arrow. All copy will be reflective 3M Scotchlite. The locations and quantites illustrated on the site plan Illustrates typical placements. Actual quantities and placement may vary with a maximum of two (2) for parcel D. ROONEY RANCH (PARCEL D) Monument Sign 7,everse Charm -15" X 93 !�" White halo PAN _ -24• X 66'/" 0 i9 PAN -16" X 66 th" PAN -20" X 32" REFURBISHED VIEW of EXI5TING D/F TENANT MONUMENT SIGN 5CALE:1/2"=1'-O" Refurbish Double Face Tenant Monument Sign Pusch View Lane OPTIONAL LAi'OUT • TARGET '5AME 5QUAR.E FOOTLOCO f..5 9 rr EXI5TING D/F TENANT MONUMENT 51GN Oro Valley, Refurbish Existing Double Face Tenant Monument �.�.�j�U-ORESCO ©2012 Fluoresce Gighling &Signs ��i This arlglnal unp,bil,h,d drawing is s,1bm11t,d for use In Connection with a project belnq designed for yav by Fluare — It is not to be shown to enyone outside of Your organ xatian, reproduced ar usad in any'aehtan srithaut expr � ROONEY RANCH (PARCEL D) Monument Sign Reverse Charnel —15" X 93 ''A" whir halo PAN -25" X 44" G)TARGET FRY S FOOD & DRUG —25 X44" Qiii{i7QitJ�4 ��[t''I i1�ili�1'1! T��d fi .�.__.. ,� �... ...., �.._ .[�ttsv." '` i ,�'+'s•' .n aZ' ,�'°,�3 n za�a'�b'x,X-+,hjr e IZEFUR615HEO VIEW of EXI5TINIG D/F TENANT MONUMENT SIGN Refurbish Double Face Tenant Monument Sign Oracle Rd. OPTIONAL LAYOUT G). MMET 'SAME SfiWRE FOOT L060 A5 EN15TII,*- 'z? • FRTS 5CALE:112"=i'-O" FOOD & DRUG ARG c"l O_fficeMax New t (RDF) F � 1 l EXI5TING DIF TENANT MONUMENT 5IGN � Oro Valley, Ar%& I , • Refurbish Existing Double Face Tenant Monu s, I ©2072 Fluoresco Lfghling & Signs g me This original unpubllehed drawing Is submitted for use in connection with • project being dealgned for you by Flu--. it Is not to ba shorn to snyana outside t 9 o ynur orgamzstisn, reproduced Cr used in any fashion wkhpu4 expressed w I top of cagy 8'-0" to Reverse Ch. to grade grade -15" X 95 tfa" white halo x p Electronic Display ZY) -18" X120" I i New Double Face Monument Sign New Double Face LED Dinner Theater Monument Sign (NDF) Theatre Oro Valley, Ariz4 LUORESCO ©2012 Fluorerco Lighting & Signs New Tenant Monument Signs && This oripinei unpublished drawing is submitted for use In connection with a project being designed for you by Fluoresco. It is not to be shown to anyone outside of your orgsni[ation, reproduced or used In any fashlcn w'. lhou! erpres sed wr tf— appeovs L.","* :6 ROONEY RANCH (PARCEL D) Monument Signs 9'-10 " -- - 7 6 17 I _ 4'-7" Top of Copy to Grade T �i � - �- R Zoi co —f— E (v No T -- r� 5 -1 S D E New Double Face Fuel Monument Sign (NDFF) r f1_ r 0 Oro Valley, Arizona �� • • ©2012 Fluoresco Lighting & Signs New Tenant Monument Signs This original unpublished drawing Ie submitted for u99 n connection witn a project being designed for you by Fluoresco. It Is not to be shown to anyone ootef" et your erye zetien, rprodecea -ttan o-•a+s, "' " ` `:,.: , -sea � am as-., - wtn�ut a=oressea : . ROONEY RANCH (PARCEL D) Monument & Directional Signs (TO) Traffic Directional Sign (TPD) Traffic & Pedestrian Directional Sign 10551 N. Oracle Rd. -Oro Valley, Az. ffic (TD) �.,` ,_� (TPD) BUILDING COLOR LEGEND_ �� New Double Face Fuel Monument Sign (NDFF) o To ~``•� % New Double Face Monument Sign (NDF) Anettor o t gag. - , (TPD) Traffic & Pedestrian Directional Sign 10700 # 9'n5^' �_ ) (TPD) _. N ,�19fi z /�. Maier / p Minor New Double Face LED Dinner Theater Monument Sign /7 (NDF) Theatre Shop Tenant (S\\ ' .'"r _ ✓ // T. ppp / iq, '• / � � (TPD) Traffic &Pedestrian Directional Sign (TPD) (TPD) Traffic & Pedestrian Directional Sign (TPD) j ` `� 10600 N. (TD) Traffic Directional Sign I ' �%< ty„ f , °��. a o t19 / ! Refurbish Double Face Tenant Monument Sign (TD) I y�, ' ` yfi Orate Rd. ! (RDF) Refurbish Double Face Tenant Monument Sign '• �/ �, �04 - f Pusch View Lane ( RDF) 4 ,. � �'r " � (TPD) PD) Traffic & Pedestrian Directional Signco w-•-� - "S�H (TPD) (TPD) Traffic 8 Pedestrian Directional Sign o 10500 N. w r r�Y,G D-4 mor Oro Vaileyi' ORESCO (C�ztl12 Fluoresco Lighting & signs Monument & Directional Signs - Sa This original unpublished drawing is submitted for use in conn.ctien with a project being designed to, ro. by Flu.resso. it is not to be shorn to anyone ..raid. of yo......nicat)nv. rac,tu d • d ;n ony ?. "nn with..; ........I rri3. ROONEY RANCH (PARCEL D) Sign Guidelines 10551 N. Oracle Rd. - Oro Valley, Az. ROONEY RANCH STANDARDS FOR PARCEL D: WALL SIGNS USER SIGN AREA ALLOWANCE COLOR MAX. Char. Ht. illumination Max logo size Sign ConstrutiordLocation Text or logo maybe either halo or internally illuminated and both may be Anchor Tenant ( over used in a sign but each 80,000 sgft.) 1.5 sgft-for each linear foot of bldg. g character,symbol, or logo may use only one 'Rumination type. LED,white neon frontage on which the sin is to be 9 9 Logo -any 1 09 y or equal maybe used. maybe 'pan channel or Reverse channel for letters/cabinets far logos (8 in deep max) placed, riot to exceed 500 sgft. for any Text -any from used for logos provided only characters •Numimlm,Acry§c,Pakded,Mafal,Fiexfare material. -Only two (2) elevations may have wall signs: single user. Must face a street. approved color pallete. emit light 36 sqf1l, 5. 3- in height • If a single tenant occupies an end unit. there may be signs on three elevations. but not the ram. Text or logo maybe either halo or internally illuminated and both may be Major Tenant (15.000 used in a sign but each 59,999 SO.) a character,symbol, or logo may use only 1.5 sgft,for each linear foot of bidg. one illumination type. LED,whRe neon frontage on which the sign is to be Logo -any 1 or equal maybe used. Cabinets may be channel -Pan channel or Reverse channel for leaers/cabinets for logos (8 in deep max) ofic,Pai m channel placed, not to exceed 300 sgft. for any Text- any from used for logos provided only characters 18 sgfl. net to exceed •Numi axface material. •Only two (2) elevations may have wall signs - sin le user. Must face a street. approved color Ilete emit light max. character height -1fasinglo tenant occupies an and unit, there may be signs on three elevations, out not the rear. Text or logo maybe either halo or internally illuminated and both may be Minor Tenant (7,500- 1 s ft for each linear foot of 4 4� used in rsign but each character,symbol, or logo may use only 14,999 sqft.) bidg.frontage, or if the space Is more one illumination type. LED,white neon than 300 feel from the road they may logo -any 1 or equal maybe used .Cabinets may be -Pan channel or Reverse channel for IeO for logos (8 In deep max) use 1.5 sqR for each linear foot of bldg, Text- any from used for logos provided only characters 14 sgft not to exceed •AluretiwmAayGc.Painted,Metat,Flexfacb material. material. -Only two (2) elevations may have wan signs: frontage. approved color pallets emit light max character height • If a single tenant occupies an end unit. there may be signs on three elevations, but not the rear. Text or logo maybe either halo or internally illuminated and both may be Shop Tenant (0-7,499 sgfl.) 1 s ft for each linear foot of q used in a sign but each characler,symbot, or logo may use only bldg.frontage, or if the space is more 36 inches for one Rluminabon type. LED,white neon than 300 feet from the road they may Logo -any 1 single line 24 or equal maybe used. Cabinets maybe -Pan charnel or Reverse channel for letters/cabirlmts fort os 8 in des max og ( P ) use 1.5 sqR for each linear toot of bldg. Text -any from inches each for used for logos provided Doty characters 12 sgfl. not to exceed material. •On two (.4c elevations -Only two (2) elevaeons have frontage. approved color palete two lines emit light max. character height may maywall signs: y wall sgns: - If a single tenant occupies an end unit, there may be signs on three elevations, but not the rear. Text or logo maybe either halo or internally illuminated and both may be Pad Building used in a sign but each character,symbol, or logo may use only • Pan channel or Reverse channel for lehersfCabirets for logos (8 in deep max) text and logos. 1 sqf .for each linear foot of bldg Logo -any 1 36 inches for single line 24 one illumination type. LFFD,white neon or equal maybe used Cabinets may be -Aluminum,Acrykc,Painted,Metal,Flexface material frontage on which the sign is to be Text- any from inches each for . used for logos provided only characters 20 sgft. not to exceed -if a single tenant occupies a pad (freestanding Building) there may be signs on 3 elevations; only two (2) maybeinuminated. If multiple tenants occupy a pad,no more than 2 t e. cunt nnnmernma placed. nr iridncoonm a oved color allele hvo lines emit light max. character h elevations may contain a wall s' n_ 2 Internally Illuminated signs may use LED's 3 No Signs on Raceways 4 No exposed neon l� (��r 1� �� l F D-5a - - --' Ora Valley, ArizonaLUORESCO QC 20f2 Fiuoresco Lighting & Signs Rooney. Ranch (Parcel D) Sign Guidelirges ar° F This original unpubllshad drawing Is avbmlited for use en connaciton with a protect bNnq d•sie^ad for you by Flupra ape. It is not to tra ahnwn to anYona outaida of yqur orean{zatlon, nproduoad p+vaad to any faah,pn wlthpyk R:xpraaaed. 1t1 ROONEY RANCH (PARCEL D) Sign Guidelines _ 10551 N. Oracle Rd. - Oro Valley, Az. �■ ROONEY RANCH PARCEL D STANDARDS FOR MONUMENT SIGNS,TRAFFIC/ PEDESTRIAN DIRECTIONAL, & THEATER SIGN SIGN TYPE OUANITY COLOR ILLUMINATION AREA SIGN CONSTRUCTION New double face Monument Halo illumination or push Signs (NDFM) thru letters for center name Logo and text any from approved color internal illumination for Reverse channel or push thru for center name. tenant pallele approved corporate colors for tenant panels only 72 sgft of sign area panels brushed aluminum opaque background only Parcel D: One (1) anchors charcters may emit light. including logo characters may emit light Monument Signs NDF Halo illumination or push THEATRE SIGN thru letters fur center name internal illumination for Logo and text any from approved color tenant panels only 72 sgfl of sign area Reverse channel or push thru for center name. 1' x 9'5" Parcel D: One (1) palette charcters may emit light. including logo Display area for Red Grayscale LED changeable graphics. Refurbished Monument Signs for Parcel D (RDF) Halo illumination or push WA Refurbished signs to follow criteria set out for refurbished all existing signs to remain thru letters for center name double face monument signs as shown on the approved as is until center is re- Logo and text any from approved color internal illumination for tenant only MSP drawings for Parcel D. If sign is completely replaced it modeled panels will meet the guidelines for a new double face monument palette charcters may emit light. sign. Traffic & Pedestrian Directional 5 permitted for Parcel D Sign (TPD) max height 6 feet N/A Internal illumination only Same as Monuments characters may emit light Maybe internal illumination or non illumination Traffic Directional Sign (TD) 3 permitted for Parcel D max height 3 feet N/A Internal illumination only Same as Monuments characters may emit light Maybe internal illumination or non illumination 1 Monument signs to be placed in landscaping setting 1 f Oro Valley, Arizo6L. LUORESCO ©2012 Fluoresce Lighting B Signs Rooney Ranch fParcel D) Sign Guidelines This original unpublished drawing Is submitted for use in connection with a project being designed for you by Fluoresce. It is not to be Shown to anyone out$lde of your oegbnlzsdton,, 'reproduced or ..ad 1. an, fa.ruo wtlthaut a ,esaaa —'v—.o ROONEY RANCH (PARCEL D) Directional Signs 9"x19'i" brushed alum. firs. t � TErltgrlT � / — fW panda L JWx J.i'ca. TEI-lF9f-1T � ax O � Q U '� � TEr'1f9f'1T � U Ti=(1Rr'1T 13 I TEf'1P9f'iT 0 (TPD) Traffic & Pedestrian Directional Sign (TPD) 3'-O" Cabinet I 3i^5-� 41/2"x 28 Ya' -- br. alum. Itra, s s x x A, o �n DELIVERIES (TD) Traffic Directional Sign 5CALE:112"="-o" (TD) Oro Valley, Arizona ©2012 Fluoresco Lighting & Signs Directional Signs This original unpublished drawing la submitted for use In tonMetion with a prolact being designed for you by Fiuoreaca- It It not to be shown to anyone outside of your organization, yaproduced or used in any fashion .4hout eapreaeeo _tlen apDr�v:a a+.-xxa D-6 s.�.,..sc.anea nr. sa.e ROONEY RANCH (PARCEL D & B) Various Sign Type Elevations PIN r •»-[ •�� ~ -.E Oro Valley, Anzo ©2012 Fluoresco Lighting & Signs Various Sign Type Elev Thl..1191-1 unpubiimh.d dr-ring i.-ub.Itt.d for uN In eanMcfion with 0roi.ct b.1n9 d..lyn.d for you by Fluor..— It 1- not t. b- -horn to -nyon.. out -id, of y -�. c go viz a' on eor. tl:.ceJ or __ed •yr amh:en w'itt;eo: .xpro ms.d' Tenants with trademarked copy and/or logos shall be permitted to utilize any vinyl/or acrylic color(s) necessary to duplicate the trademark and are not subject to limitations or restrictions to the color palette within the permitted logo size allowance. xtdical' TranshlC Fil Graphic ms waeaw DnJ mnaw"c i w.aflma rA+mxE]:ec """;; +" NvaaulDaeBa �6� ?' PaNroxErJJsc Bnfu J.N ha. ® YYrsa ew. nxnrasxc Translucent Films for backlit sign applications 3M LiE)ttt wNb . Eeeran :. PtNWNE NDL Nmuam< /ANloraf talc NarrKtl ham MNfoiF JlBc IblJl Bha vucWJs ]axc 1 1 rr -e r r1 '.p F _ . rr t* I I r �, B 1'rC a n P� r� r 1 h *.... Llam9ement Him asi. rSNer Wm eatta .. GrIWIfle4 6uvMwN PNCGNEINC XJIIE Dram BliaH BHa PlMDNE]BIC U G Pam^ PE 1 nD(voEi EI(rA;E GA BMaAy' >d 1'-+4 h(e f,d.7YJ E.VBX 3N'Gal{MN iqn tM1cl lJpN ael. /AMDNBh!®C IbcR /AN16K Rena ab<bC . -Grt M! pw EI PANfoNE 1YlDC Gfft"re Nham- Susm lNa MtRD1E ii%G PIYiDJf ]m t rumDtts ars DJEW st M1j,D )unl mP3LWemIs DUl Mir,sxlei a4 Cal?d tDaLlM lord Wtl t2 EEeE0 x[: .. 3Nt'tgH . ENNanpnmifNra Bhn Pairtom a)]L Armaat PJNIDK tYCaL NN ' � M1lev PAxEDpE lO9L iwauaYr HvnGM II62G FaraPam nua PAV10Ne Mr< a., eApa Minn Dpfusu Poe ,.. u DaN fbryH Dart&own PANIatF o45 G Nord G! IANNNE MJ L lqH /eeoa iebv fANID1F lab C Paa hue INamrE JYe L ep. 1,un,5 E I weaa Se'OIMua FNn.... DONN4haB IFlporlEln 6 _ and Brews IANror[ Lq L Ioppf Bk _ BriBifnS'vnn ,•Y.. �ia .�. MNWK 3TIL Erarnv Bluv PAIRONE�aL NaJH BIua MMBNf D<L srp4rfBe fn*, &"neY hry hmaa PNpBNf et t NBN nwN Br«e /al(IDrE tar L iNN kuab see Elms onm MNiphE 3m C cr/H Fnamm ® Ilva /bs /rvpa fupDNf 2�ZG aJrf" dVNJM fin Duo 6ry wa«Mlww � Ran,' .NmY ralL ONE "Pon Orvga IAprON[1t35G ® Mau haw MNTNf SriSt. mBegc BYa � Ybw NalaMa famONF Lf L aN'•Blaiautfin PfnNa Nata NaNrrtl rNNmtE rmc „� Y I4alaeW vANroxE rsJc Z" t1EaJGq ham vuamaxrD Pn.m nw ��r�� Pne Jar•elNaounn IYc4 Natla Pl4iDxE ]]!L _._Lt. Bel e..—. ( 8) (Dk. Beige) Match Building Colors Match Building Colors (Beige) Match Tile Color (Brown) Match PMS 476C (Duranodic Bronze) MAP 41-313 (Anodic Black) risco ) Rreated or Pai/lted) MAP 41-33S Brushed Aluminum r—Pn• was Oro Valley, Arkana,iF f26 ©ORESCO 2012 Fluoresce Ughling 8 Signs �Q10 This original unpublished drawing Is submitted for use In conneCtlora with • proleCt "all ned for t " aivA g Tou OY Fluoresce. ]I in nor to be aAown Jo anrone outeIgo al yaur or9ohUr tion, eeprodoeed or uted Tn ang +me:�h wrE?aL,r!. Grasswaf Print Council Communication �4 s Page 1 of 2 !4 Town Council Regular Session Meeting Date: 09/07/2016 Requested by: Patty Hayes Submitted By: Patty Hayes, Development Infrastructure Services Department: Development Infrastructure Services Information SUBJECT: Item # 5. DISCUSSION AND POSSIBLE ACTION REGARDING A REVISED MASTER SIGN PROGRAM FOR THE ROONEY RANCH SHOPPING CENTER, INCLUDING THE FRY'S GROCERY AND FUEL CENTER, LOCATED AT 10661 N. ORACLE ROAD RECOMMENDATION: The Conceptual Design Review Board (CDRB) recommends approval. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: The proposed revision to the Rooney Ranch Master Sign Program (Attachment 1) is to allow the following: • Electronic changeable copy for gas prices • An additional monument sign at the First Avenue entrance for the gas prices A Master Sign Program (MSP) is a set of sign standards established for a multi -tenant commercial development that determines how signs will be used within a development. The proposed revision allows a new gas price monument sign for the new Fry's Fuel Center near the First Avenue side of the development (Attachment 2). It would also allow the existing Shell gas station at Pusch View Lane and Oracle Road to replace their existing gas price sign with a new sign in the future. The CDRB considered the revision on August 9, 2016, and voted to recommend approval to Town Council. BACKGROUND OR DETAILED INFORMATION: When the Rooney Ranch MSP was updated in 2012, a statement was included that limited electronic changeable copy to theaters only. This statement omits gas station fuel signs, which is clearly an error. In fact, this sign type was previously enabled because the zoning accounts for two gas stations. As a result, the current language prevents new or replacement gas price signs within the development. The Zoning Code allows fuel centers to have electronic changeable copy as a component of a sign. The proposed gas price monument sign is consistent with signs already found in the Town as depicted in Attachment 3. A new fuel center is proposed to be built on 13t Avenue near the Fry's grocery store. As with any fuel station, a sign showing the fuel prices is requested to be placed on the property. In summary, proposed changes to the MSP provide smaller and fewer gas station price signs than permitted by the Zoning Code. A full comparison of the current and proposed MSP in relation to the Zoning Code is provided as Attachment 4. General Plan Analysis Zoning Code amendments are reviewed for conformance with General Plan policies. In summary, General Plan policies related to the MSP focus on creating a balance between a business need to attract customers and with concerns of residents regarding over intrusive signage. The MSP meets these policies by providing limitations on the size and number of gas price signs, below Zoning Code allowances. A detailed analysis of the MSP in relation to the General Plan is provided in Attachment 5. Conceptual Design Review Board http://agenda.orovalleyaz.gov:8085/print ag_memo.cfm?seq=2090&rev num=0&mode=... 09/07/2016 Print Council Communication Page 2 of 2 The proposed revision was considered by the CDRB on August 9, 2016. No changes to the proposal were recommended, and there was minimal discussion regarding the MSP. The staff report to CDRB is contained in attachment 6. At the conclusion of the public meeting, the CDRB voted to recommend approval of the Rooney Ranch Master Sign Program revision. The draft minutes as Attachment 7. Public Notification and Comment Public notice has been provided as follows: • All HOAs in the Town were notified of this hearing • Public hearing notice was posted: • In the Territorial newspaper • At Town Hall • On the Town website No comments have been received on the revised MSP. FISCAL IMPACT: N/A SUGGESTED MOTION: I MOVE to approve the revised Master Sign Program for the Rooney Ranch Shopping Center allowing electronic changeable fuel prices and an additional monument sign. Ce17 I MOVE to deny the revised Master Sign Program for the Rooney Ranch Shopping Center allowing electronic changeable fuel prices and an additional monument sign. Attachments Attachment 1 Applicant's Submittal Attachment 2 Location Map Attachment 3 Photos of Gas Signs Attachment 4 Comparision of Current and Proposed MSP to Zoning Code Attachment 5 General Plan Analysis Attachment 6 CDRB Staff Report Attachment 7 CDRB Minutes http://agenda.orovalleyaz.gov:80851print_ag memo.cfm?seq=2090&rev num=0&mode=... 09/07/2016 Attachment 4 Current and Proposed MSP Comparison Current MSP Proposed MSP Zoning Code Electronic Allowed only for Allow for theaters, dinner Allows for fuel centers changeable "theater and dinner theaters and fuel stations copy theaters" copy signs Location Not provided One (1) fuel sign in May have more than 2 addition to the previously monument style signs approved multi -tenant off First Ave, including monument sign at the fuel center sign First Ave. entrance. Quantity None One fuel sign per street One fuel sign per street frontage frontage Size None 28 square feet 32 square feet Attachment 5 General Plan Analysis The Zoning Code amendments were reviewed for conformance with the General Plan's Goals and Policies. Listed below are relevant policies within the General Plan relating to signage in italics, followed by staff commentary: Signage: Signage controls have to balance citizens concerns about the increasing level of signage with the needs of businesses to attract customers. Policy 2.1.10: The Town shall create standards for signage to provide information and direction to allow businesses to attract and maintain customers with the least intrusive signage possible. Policy 11.3.3 The Town shall use existing standards and guidelines, and establish new ones as needed, to ensure that the built environment blends with or enhances the natural environment by restricting signage primarily to identification. The proposed signage would improve the fuel center's visibility to vehicular traffic while not impacting adjacent properties. The adjacent development across First Avenue is another commercial development with monument signs of its own therefore there would be no adverse impact by the additional sign. 3. FREESTANDING SIGN DESIGN REQUIREMENTS A. Sign Type/ Parcel D 1. The refurbished double face signs (RDF) one at Pusch View Lane and Oracle Rd. and at the Wells Fargo entrance along Oracle Rd. also know as parcel "D". The project shall be identified with individual reverse pan channel illumination reading "Rooney Ranch" utilizing white LED's concealed within the pan channel letterform. Tenant signage will consist of routed out pan with a brushed aluminum overlay where only the characters may emit light. Tenant colors to follow freestanding matrix 2. The new double face sign (NDF) located at the main entrance on 1 st Avenue. This sign will be identified with either reverse pan channel, push thru acrylic letters or routed out copy with the brushed aluminum finish reading "Rooney Ranch" utilizing white LED's. Tenant colors to follow freestanding matrix. 2a. The new double face Theatre sign (NDF Theatre) is to be located along Oracle Road at an entrance point. This sign will use the same techniques as the (NDF) with the addition of an Electronic Message center at a size to be approximately 18"x 120" this will be a red grayscale LED. Tenant colors to follow freestanding matrix. It is important to note no electronic displays or signs with changeable copy shall be erected or operated unless in association with a theater/dinner theater. The electronic display of signs with changeable copy shall cease operation upon discontinuance of the theater/dinner theater use in Parcel D. Traffic & Pedestrian Directional Sign (TPD) shall be located throughout the project. They are intended to be placed at traffic intersections and driveways as required to direct vehicular traffic throughout the project. The displays will include vehicular oriented "wayfinding" information such as Tenant listings with directional arrows. All copy will be reflective 3M Scotchlite. the locations and quantities illustrated on the site plan illustrate typical placements. Actual quantities and placement may vary with a maximum of six (6) for Parcel D. 4. Traffic Directional Sign (TD) Shall be located at entry points in the property to direct delivery trucks to the rear of the property. The display will include vehicular oriented "wayfinding" information such as deliveries, shipping or receiving with a directional arrow. All copy will be reflective 3M Scotchlite. The locations and quantites illustrated on the site plan Illustrates typical placements. Actual quantities and placement may vary with a maximum of two (2) for parcel D. OPO'IP_I.EY qA/l�i� TOWN OF ORO VALLEY DEVELOPMENT & INFRASTRUCTURE SERVICES DEPARTMENT 11000 N. LA CANADA DRIVE, ORO VALLEY, AZ. 85737 PHONE: (520) 229-4800 FAX: (520) 742-1022 - www.orovalleVaz.gov/dis , POUNDED 191N /-�'/ /( J � 1.2 GENERAL APPLICATION FORM l office Application Type: ❑ Major General Plan Amendment ❑ Final Plat ❑ Rezoning/PAD Amendment ❑ Pre -Application ❑ Planned Area Development ❑ Zoning Verification ❑ Conditional Use Permit ❑ Sign Criteria ❑ Zoning Code Amendment ❑ Sign - PAD Exemption ❑ Conceptual Site Plan W Master Sign Program i-)- ❑ Conceptual Public Art ❑ Communication Facility — Tier 1 and 2 Minor ❑ Conceptual Architecture ❑ Communication Facility — Major ❑ Final Site Plan ❑ Revised Development Plan ❑ Conceptual Landscape Plan ❑ Other Subiect Property Information: Address: /OC�G/ Al O/ZAGL,- iCA Subdivision / Commercial Center Name: 12«NE y RA—.4 I/Tax Code: Book / Page or Sequence Number: Lot Number(s) Legal Description: &E.u-11A4 Prni sew 7-/z -1Y Section/Township/Range: .�>-o 09- ci3 0 Area of Property: 6.9z Existing Land Use: Ccl.lme.zc's- Proposed Land Use: Applicant Information: * If more than one, attach list Applicant*: Name: Ar�N Firm: avc-z a- b vim= Sj(,,- ec Address: Yoty r. �„� -roN ✓c City: PAc6ij'- State: �4z Zip: gsc)z9 Telephone: Fax: biz- 2?z - y6o s Email: AN3 y (LI 13oo,-2- A v,; DLec'. c n-i Property Owner(s) if different from Applicant*: Name: INd E "--,"- - Firm Address: f O (q it . U F IT F '7 Telephone: b c z- 7!c 3- 6o3.3 Fax: Consultant*: 1111 Name: Address: Telephone: (Discipline) Kilo c E rz cc, City: State: OH Zip: '15LoZ Email: t� (cD rrzys/--,od. (","- Firm: City: _ Fax: Email: 5 State: Zip: Project Description/Narrative: �e5 JeS4 -}6 N^cd,C7 +l-e F-01J±:4 RANch I/Wjer ST&V Profncm fo a1/0ry Alel &A1 11- �n havf` e1\W6R 8-F Capp, AL -SO A eNrJbe 1N ju W,as4-e� < It ag i SkrJ��a �k Duel }0 1414 * A a JP{ Zor✓ -PVYA4 eFIAM'. I hereby certify that I have read and examined this application and know the same to be true and correct. I am the owner of the property or the Owner's authorized representative, and if not the owner, I have obtained the owner's permission to perform stated work. All provisions of laws and ordinances governing this type of work will be complied with whether specified herein or not. The approval of this application does not presume to give authority to violate or cancel the provisions of any other federal, state or local law for which this project may be subject to. Notice: It is the applicant/owner's responsibility to ensure all private rules and regulations (such as Covenants, Conditions & Restrictions (CC&R's)) of the subdivision and/or commercial center are adhered to. Contact your Home Owners Association or property management to determine applicable requirements. It is also th pplicant's res sibility to coordinate with all outside agencies to secure their acceptance or clearance. Failure t so ay de is uance of permits. See attached list of agencies. '7 if�6 Ann ' a s anature Print Name Date Important Note: All submittals received after 4:00 p.m. will be processed the next day Submittals will be rejected if: • Not folded using Pima County fold & collated; • There are missing items on the checklist unless otherwise approved by Planning Division Manager or Town Engineer. • Re -submittals cannot be accepted without a transmittal and a written narrative summary describing the purpose of submittal. C� TOWN OF ORO VALLEY I-C- NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING TOWN COUNCIL 3 C) 9 The Town Council invites the community to attend a public hearing on Wednesday, September 7, 2016, 6 p.m. Council Chambers, 11000 N. La Canada Dr. Oro Valley, Arizona Public Hearing: A revised Master Sign Program for the Rooney Ranch Shopping Center, including the Fry's Grocery and Fuel Center, located at 10661 N. Oracle Road, OV1601741. The revision is to allow a monument and sign electronic changeable copy for fuel pricing. The meeting will be in the Town Council Chambers. The public is encouraged to attend and will be invited to speak. An agenda for this meeting will be made available at least 24 hours prior to meeting time and can be viewed at www.orovallevaz.gov. For questions and additional information, please contact Patty Hayes, Senior Planning Technician at (520) 229- 4819 or phayes -orovalleyaz.gov. - I* q1 Posted: Time: By: SAPERMPLUSTOMOV1601741 MSP Rooney Ranch\TC Sept\1 TC Notice.doc AGENDA ORO VALLEY CONCEPTUAL DESIGN REVIEW BOARD REGULAR SESSION August 9, 2016 ORO VALLEY COUNCIL CHAMBERS 11000 N. LA CANADA DRIVE REGULAR SESSION AT OR AFTER 6:00 PM CALL TO ORDER ROLL CALL PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE CALL TO AUDIENCE - at this time, any member of the public is allowed to address the Board on any issue not listed on today's agenda. Pursuant to the Arizona Open Meeting law, individuals Board members may ask Town staff to review the matter, ask that the matter be placed on a future agenda, or respond to criticism made by speakers. However, the Conceptual Design Review Board may not discuss or take legal action on matters raised during "Call to Audience." In order to speak during "Call to Audience" please specify what you wish to discuss when completing the blue speaker card. COUNCIL LIAISON COMMENTS REVIEW AND/OR APPROVAL OF THE JULY 12, 2016 REGULAR SESSION MEETING MINUTES 2. CONCEPTUAL MODEL HOME ARCHITECTURE FOR MATTAMY HOMES AT RANCHO VISTOSO PARCEL 5F LOCATED ON THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF MOORE ROAD AND RANCHO VISTOSO BOULEVARD, OV1315-11 3. DISCUSSION AND POSSIBLE ACTION ON A REQUEST FOR CONCEPTUAL ARCHITECTURE FOR THE CANYON DEL ORO BAPTIST CHURCH EXPANSION, LOCATED AT 9200 N ORACLE ROAD, ON THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF ORACLE ROAD AND CALLE CONCORDIA, OV16001613 �4. DISCUSSION AND POSSIBLE ACTION FOR A REVISION TO THE MASTER SIGN PROGRAM AT THE ROONEY RANCH CENTER INCLUDING THE FRY'S GROCERY AND FUEL CENTER, LOCATED AT 10661 N. ORACLE ROAD. THE REVISION IS TO ALLOW ELECTRONIC CHANGEABLE COPY SIGNS FOR FUEL PRICING, OV1601741 5. DISCUSSION AND POSSIBLE ACTION FOR A REVISION TO THE SIGN -- CRITERIA FOR THE MAGEE PLAZA LOCATED AT 8085 N. ORACLE ROAD. THE REVISION IS TO EXPAND THE COLOR PALETTE AND SIGN DESIGN FOR THE DEVELOPMENT, OV1601513 6. PRESENTATION AND DISCUSSION ON PROPOSED ARCHITECTURE FOR THE NAKOMA SKY SENIOR CARE FACILITY, PLANNED FOR THE 77 ACRES AT THE SOUTHEAST CORNER, NARANJA DRIVE AND 1 ST AVENUE, OV1601351 PLANNING UPDATE (INFORMATIONAL ONLY) ADJOURNMENT POSTED: 07/28/2016 at 10am by rmf When possible, a packet of agenda materials as listed above is available for public inspection at least 24 hours prior to the Conceptual Design Review Board meeting in the Town Clerk's Office between the hours of 8:00 a.m. — 5:00 p.m. The Town of Oro Valley complies with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). If any person with a disability needs any type of accommodation, please notify the Town Clerk's Office at least five days prior to the Board meeting at 229-4700. INSTRUCTIONS TO SPEAKERS Members of the public have the right to speak during any posted public hearing. However, those items not listed as a public hearing are for consideration and action by the Conceptual Design Review Board during the course of their business meeting. Members of the public may be allowed to speak on these topics at the discretion of the Chair. If you wish to address the Board on any item(s) on this agenda, please complete a blue speaker card located on the Agenda table at the back of the room and give it to the Recording Secretary. Please indicate on the speaker card which item number and topic you wish to speak on, or if you wish to speak during "Call to Audience," please specify what you wish to discuss when completing the blue speaker card. Please step forward to the podium when the Chair announces the item(s) on the agenda which you are interested in addressing. 1. Please state your name and whether or not you are a Town resident. 2. Speak only on the issue currently being discussed by the Board. Please organize your speech, you will only be allowed to address the Board once regarding the topic being discussed. 3. Please limit your comments to 3 minutes. 4. During "Call to Audience" you may address the Board on any issue you wish. 5. Any member of the public speaking must speak in a courteous and respectful manner to those present. Thank you for your cooperation. "Notice of Possible Quorum of the Oro Valley Town Council, Boards, Commissions and Committees: In accordance with Chapter 3, Title 38, Arizona Revised Statutes and Section 2-4-2 of the Oro Valley Town Code, a majority of the Town Council, Board of Adjustment, Historic Preservation Commission, Parks and Recreation Advisory Board, Planning and Zoning Commission, Storm Water Utility Commission, and the Water Utility Commission may attend this meeting a s a member of the audience only."