Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPackets - 2026 General Plan Advisory Meetings (2)       AGENDA 2026 GENERAL PLAN COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT ADVISORY GROUP JOINT STUDY SESSION WITH THE FOLLOWING BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS: TOWN COUNCIL, BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT, BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMISSION, HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION, PARKS AND RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD, PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION, STORMWATER UTILITY COMMISSION, WATER UTILITY COMMISSION, YOUTH ADVISORY COUNCIL January 19, 2023 HOPI CONFERENCE ROOM 11000 N. LA CAÑADA DRIVE OR BY ZOOM WEBINAR: https://orovalley.zoom.us/j/81612722685 To join by phone dial: +1-669-444-9171 Webinar ID: 816 1272 2685        STUDY SESSION AT OR AFTER 6:00 PM   CALL TO ORDER   ROLL CALL   STUDY SESSION AGENDA   1.DISCUSSION ONLY WITH TOWN COUNCIL, BOARD AND COMMISSION MEMBERS, YOUTH ADVISORY COUNCIL AND PUBLIC ATTENDEES REGARDING COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT STRATEGIES FOR THE UPCOMING GENERAL PLAN   ADJOURNMENT     POSTED: 1/17/23 at 5:00 p.m. by dt When possible, a packet of agenda materials as listed above is available for public inspection at least 24 hours prior to the Advisory meeting in the Town Clerk's Office between the hours of 8:00 a.m. – 5:00 p.m. The Town of Oro Valley complies with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). If any person with a disability needs any type of accommodation, please notify the Town Clerk’s Office at least five days prior to the Commission meeting at 229-4700.    2026 General Plan Community Engagement Advisory Group 1. Meeting Date:01/19/2023   Requested by: Milini Simms, Community and Economic Development  Case Number: N/A SUBJECT: DISCUSSION ONLY WITH TOWN COUNCIL, BOARD AND COMMISSION MEMBERS, YOUTH ADVISORY COUNCIL AND PUBLIC ATTENDEES REGARDING COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT STRATEGIES FOR THE UPCOMING GENERAL PLAN RECOMMENDATION: Discussion item only. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: See attached packet. BACKGROUND OR DETAILED INFORMATION: See attached packet. FISCAL IMPACT: N/A. SUGGESTED MOTION: This item is for discussion only. Attachments CE Advisory Group Meeting Packet 1  Community and Economic Development January 13, 2023 Dear Town Council, Board, Commission and Advisory Council members, Welcome and thank you for participating in this advisory group! Your time, expertise and assistance with the 2026 General Plan’s Community Engagement Plan is sincerely appreciated. This advisory group is composed of members of Town Council and the following boards, commissions, and advisory groups: • Board of Adjustment • Budget and Finance Commission • Historic Preservation Commission • Parks and Recreation Advisory Board • Planning and Zoning Commission • Stormwater Utility Commission • Water Utility Commission • Youth Advisory Council All members are invited to join this effort. To date, 36 have confirmed their participation. It’s not too late to join in the conversation, please contact me at msimms@orovalleyaz.gov or 520-229-4836 if you would like to participate. Purpose of the advisory group This advisory group is tasked with shaping the upcoming General Plan community engagement process. In collaboration with Town staff and a marketing consultant, Gordley Group, the advisory group will: • Share knowledge about the importance of the General Plan and identify changes in the community since the previous General Plan effort. Provide opinions regarding key areas of focus for the next General Plan. • Identify key stakeholders and public participation values • Analyze results of the active survey and help shape a communications strategy to reach Oro Valley’s broad demographic range • Select preferred communication methods among three public participation levels or alternatives The final product of the advisory group is to recommend a communication strategy. We need everyone to participate in the meetings to help guide this effort. The results of this collaborative work will be presented to the Planning and Zoning Commission and Town Council for approval in March. What to expect All meetings will be held in-person (preferred attendance) with the option to participate via Zoom. You can expect to receive a packet of information, sent via email, prior to each meeting for your review. Additionally, all meetings will be recorded should you want to go back and listen. If you are going to attend via Zoom, please let me know 24 hours in advance so we can plan dinner and materials accordingly. Meetings will be from 6 PM – 8 PM on Town Campus, located at 11000 N. La Canada Drive. Zoom link to participate online: https://orovalley.zoom.us/j/81612722685 To join by phone dial: +1-669-444-9171 Use webinar I.D. number: 816 1272 2685 2 The advisory group meeting dates, location and topics are provided below along with the tentative public hearing dates. Date Location Topic Thursday, Jan. 19 Hopi Conference Room (see map on next page) History and overview of the General Plan & key areas of interest Thursday, Jan. 26 Council Chambers Guiding principles and stakeholder identification Thursday, Feb. 9 Council Chambers Review survey results & communication methods Thursday, Feb. 16 Council Chambers Preferred communication strategy and budget Tuesday, March 7 Council Chambers Planning and Zoning Commission Wed., March 15 Council Chambers Town Council Survey now open In addition to your participation in the advisory group, please take this brief survey linked below and spread the word about it to your neighbors and friends. Multiple people in a household, of all ages can take the survey until January 26. Please click on this link to take the survey and share it: https://arcg.is/10aGrK1. Results from this survey will be reviewed by the advisory group during the February 9 meeting. If at any time throughout this process you have any questions or concerns, please do not hesitate to contact me. Sincerely, Milini Simms Principal Planner Town of Oro Valley 520-229-4836 msimms@orovalleyaz.gov 3 Community Engagement Advisory Group - Meeting #1 Packet The following items are in this packet to assist the discussion on January 19. Click on each item below to access and gain familiarity with the documents below: • Town campus map (see below) • Meeting #1 Agenda • 2016 Your Voice, Our Future General Plan • 2016 Public Participation Plan • 2022 General Plan Progres s Report • General Plan legal requirements 2026 General Plan Community Engagement Group Meeting #1 Thursday, January 19 at 6 PM Hopi Conference Room 1. Welcome and introductions 6:00 PM 2. Overview and importance of the General Plan 6:30 PM Prep Material: 2016 General Plan and the 2022 Annual Progress Report 3. Overview of the Advisory Group’s purpose 6:35 PM Previous community engagement process and results Prep Material: 2016 Public Outreach Plan 4. Changes in the community since the last General Plan 6:40 PM Prep Material: General Plan legal requirements Group Discussion: In your experience, how has the community changed since the last General Plan? 5. Identify likely focal topics of community discussion 7:10 PM Exercise and discussion: What do you anticipate as focal topics of community discussion for the next General Plan? 6. Adjournment 8:00 PM 5/1/13 Public Participation Plan Page 1 PUBLIC PARTICIPATION PLAN FOR THE ORO VALLEY GENERAL PLAN Adopted by Oro Valley Town Council May 1, 2013 5/1/13 Public Participation Plan Page 2 Acknowledgements Town Council Satish Hiremath, Mayor Lou Waters, Vice Mayor Council Member Brendan Burns Council Member William Garner Council Member Joe Hornat Council Member Mary Snider Council Member Mike Zinkin Planning & Zoning Commission William Rodman, Chair Don Cox, Vice Chair Commissioner John Buette Commissioner D. Alan Caine Commissioner Bill Leedy Commissioner Robert E. Swope General Plan Scoping Committee Bill Adler Board of Adjustment David Atler Conceptual Design Review Board Don Cox Planning & Zoning Commission Helen Dankwerth FOVPL and Board of Adjustment Dick Eggerding Conceptual Design Review Board Ellen Guyer Historic Preservation Commission Joe Hornat Town Council Hal Linton Conceptual Design Review Board Stephen Roche Board of Adjustment Bill Rodman Planning & Zoning Commission Dino Sakellar Conceptual Design Review Board John Scheuring Parks & Recreation Advisory Board Michael Schoeppach Board of Adjustment Bob Swope Planning & Zoning Commission Clifton Wickstrom Parks & Recreation Advisory Board Mike Zinkin Town Council Staff Support Greg Caton Town Manager Paul Keesler DIS Director David Williams Planning Manager Misti Nowak Communications Administrator Chris Cornelison Constituent Services Coordinator Bayer Vella Conservation & Sustainability Administrator Lynn Garcia Administrative Coordinator Daniel Harrison Intern 5/1/13 Public Participation Plan Page 3 Public Participation Plan Table of Contents I. Introduction ............................................................................................................ 4 II. Extent of General Plan Update.............................................................................. 4 III. Purpose.................................................................................................................... 5 IV. Public Participation Plan Process, Status Reports & Changes.......................... 6 V. Public Participation Guiding Principles............................................................... 7 VI. Stakeholder Identification ..................................................................................... 8 VII. Communication Methods and Techniques........................................................... 8 VIII. Planning Process................................................................................................... 12 XII. Public Meeting Scheduling, Location and Access.............................................. 13 XIII. Special Accommodations ..................................................................................... 13 XV. Evaluation System................................................................................................ 14 Attachment #1 – Community Stakeholders……………………………………………………………………….. 15 Attachment #2 – Terms & Definitions for Public Participation Methods.......................... 18 Attachment #3 – Public Participation Plan Methods Flowchart…………………………………………...20 Attachment #4 – Project Milestones………………………………………………………………………………….22 5/1/13 Public Participation Plan Page 4 I. Introduction The Town of Oro Valley is beginning preparations to update its General Plan that will guide and inform critical decisions about the Town’s future. This important effort, envisioned to be inclusive and community driven and supported, will provide guidance for public policy development that both defines the character of Oro Valley and sustains its functioning. The General Plan update will replace the Town’s current one (Focus 2020) that was adopted and ratified by voters in 2005. Since then, a significant increase in population has resulted in changes to the Town’s demographic profile. This General Plan update presents the Town with a unique opportunity to engage the Town’s residents and stakeholders in a dialogue to establish priorities and further define and guide the development of their community. Experience has taught us that only when people of all walks of life come together to discuss, debate and listen to one another do communities gain a larger understanding of who they are and how they want to move forward. This public participation plan is designed to provide the community and stakeholders with diverse and meaningful opportunities for engagement. It specifically targets the Town’s new demographics and includes a variety of ways to consult and collaborate with them. Understanding what stakeholders’ concerns are and the aspirations they hold for themselves and their community are essential to the success of the update. Following the public participation plan should create a sense of community ownership that will ultimately result in an improved, supported and sustainable General Plan. An Arizona state law known as the Growing Smarter Act mandates community planning. In terms of process, Arizona Revised Statutes 9-461.06 requires that a municipality’s General Plan be readopted or a new one be adopted every ten years. Newer legislation extended the ten-year provision to July 1, 2015 for both counties and municipalities. For a town of Oro Valley’s size, the update must be ratified by the voters. The goal is to have the update adopted by the Mayor and Council in time for the 2016 General Election. This timeframe will be used to engage, incorporate their input and educate the community in order to build consensus for a voter-ratified update, while maximizing the efficient use of available resources. II. Extent of General Plan Update The General Plan update process provides an opportunity to simplify language, clarify goals and policies, and better address current and projected needs and trends. Since the last state-required General Plan update, there has been a significant increase in population and changes to the demographic profile of the community. As a result, the needs and preferences of the community have likely shifted. The focus of the current General Plan is on preserving a “suburban/resort community,” and as we move forward with the update, there may be greater appreciation for a “full-service community” that includes employment centers, commercial services and housing choices. An update of the General Plan also provides an opportunity to unify numerous specialized plans that have been developed over the last eight years, including economic development strategies and the Strategic Plan. Furthermore, there are other key planning issues which require updating, such as finance, housing choices, expansion of the Town (Arroyo Grande) and long-range park planning. 5/1/13 Public Participation Plan Page 5 The General Plan Scoping Committee, a team of Town Council, board, and commission members, recognizes the quality of the current General Plan and considers the guiding principles represented in the current General Plan as relevant and sound, serving as a very strong base. The General Plan Scoping Committee recognizes that many of the chapters require very little updating; however, the committee has also identified chapters that will require more extensive work. For purposes of assigning a project scope, a full rewrite of the General Plan is not anticipated; however, on a scale of 0 (no change) to 5 (major change), the expected level of effort is approximately a 3. Because the Town’s ultimate objective is voter ratification, the extent of the General Plan update will be shaped by community participants. During the two-year process, the Town must maintain dialogue with the community to continually test assumptions and adjust accordingly. III. Purpose This Public Participation Plan was designed to support the Town’s primary goal of developing a community- and consensus-based, defensible and voter-ratified General Plan update. To accomplish that, the update must represent a shared community vision and guiding principles, and the public participation must be inclusive, educational and far-reaching. This Public Participation Plan identifies the process to reaffirm or adjust the current General Plan vision, guiding principles, goals and policies so that the update will resonate with the community and be broadly endorsed by voters. The Public Participation Plan outlines the steps Town staff will take to encourage and solicit community involvement in the update process. It identifies specific methods and techniques that motivate members of the community to: • Be informed about the preparation, content and use of the General Plan • Identify key components of community • Communicate needs and expectations for the future • Work together to reach consensus on ways to address key community issues • Contribute to achieving voter ratification This Public Participation Plan establishes strategies that satisfy the state mandates in the Growing Smarter Act. ARS § 9-461.06 requires that municipalities’ “governing bodies shall adopt written procedures to provide effective, early and continuous public participation in the development and major amendment of general plans from all geographic, ethnic, and economic areas of the municipality.” Furthermore, the “procedures shall provide for: a) The broad dissemination of proposals and alternatives b) The opportunity for written comments c) Public hearings after effective notice d) Open discussions, communications programs and information services e) Consideration of public comments.” 5/1/13 Public Participation Plan Page 6 IV. Public Participation Plan Process, Status Reports & Changes Public Participation Plan Process All key building blocks to develop this Public Participation Plan were reviewed by a General Plan Scoping Committee (GPSC). The result is a sound Public Participation Plan with proven techniques to engage the public, as well as new outreach efforts in an attempt to reach and inform more of the community. The GPSC was a 16-member team comprised of residents currently serving on Town boards, commissions and Town Council. The Committee was charged with three primary tasks: • Estimate the extent of General Plan update needed • Review public participation methods and techniques • Identify recommended public participation methods and techniques for review by the Planning & Zoning Commission and Town Council Over the course of five meetings, the GPSC helped develop and review: • Community changes since adoption of the current General Plan • Relevancy of the current General Plan and specific elements • Public participation lessons learned from the 2005 General Plan effort • Lists of key stakeholders and project participants • Future public participation “must-do’s” • Three public participation approaches (base, intermediate and comprehensive) and associated budgets • A recommended public participation approach and budget Gordley Group, a local public relations and involvement firm, helped to refine Public Participation Plan elements. From this base of community and professional guidance, staff drafted this Public Participation Plan. On April 2, 2013, the Planning & Zoning Commission voted to recommend approval of the Public Participation Plan to the Oro Valley Town Council. The Public Participation Plan was formally adopted by the Town Council on May 1, 2013. The Town Council strongly emphasized the need to garner participation by families and youth. It was noted that this demographic has grown substantially since the last General Plan effort. Status Updates Staff will update Town Council on the progress and results of the Public Participation Plan periodically. Changes As the Town implements the Public Participation Plan, flexibility is a necessary component. This plan is a living document that may need to be changed in order to respond to lessons learned during implementation. If one method proves more or less effective than another, resources will be adjusted accordingly. Town Council will be informed of any significant changes to the program. 5/1/13 Public Participation Plan Page 7 V. Public Participation Guiding Principles To meet the Town’s goal for a voter-ratified General Plan update, this Public Participation Plan was designed to connect residents to the Town and to each other. This connection will result in better-supported and more sustainable decisions. The Public Participation Plan: • Is open, transparent, accountable, inclusive, collaborative and ethical • Ensures involvement opportunities are convenient for residents • Promotes sustainable decisions that resonate with the voting community • Seeks and facilitates involvement of all demographics • Will be assessed on an ongoing basis to ensure best practices • Includes how the public’s involvement helps to shape the decisions made for the General Plan Additional guiding principles: • Learn from the past—focus on: o Residents o Targeted voter outreach o Adequate community testing of principles and concepts o Diversified viewpoints and better committee membership selection o Earning voter ratification • Residents’ quality of life o To overcome the challenge that the General Plan is merely a dry technical planning tool, present it as a tool to guide and define the community’s quality of life, focusing on issues with which residents can easily identify o Draw participants and votes by asking—and answering—the question: “Why is this important to me?” • Key objectives o Provide practical, clear and compelling information that directly relates the General Plan to residents’ lives o Use public-friendly, easy-to-understand, engaging, inviting and visionary methods, techniques and social media tools o Report positive, tangible results from the current General Plan to build upon success o Speak to specific and positive outcomes in the proposed General Plan o Reach the broad community of voters to identify and test multiple opinions o Seeks active involvement from typically under-represented populations such as families and youth o Keep participants informed throughout the process in open and direct ways o Maintain a consistent outreach focus throughout the implementation o Go to the community; do not solely rely on the public to attend large forums 5/1/13 Public Participation Plan Page 8 VI. Stakeholder Identification The Town’s residents are the primary stakeholders in this effort. Additional care has been taken to study Oro Valley’s current demographic profile to tailor public participation opportunities. The Growing Smarter Act defines a broad spectrum of stakeholders. The law requires that the governing body “Consult with, advise, and provide an opportunity for official comment by public officials and agencies, the county, school districts, associations of governments, public land management agencies, the military airport…other appropriate government jurisdictions, public utility companies, civic, educational, professional and other organizations, property owners and citizens generally to secure maximum coordination of plans and to indicate properly located sites for all public purposes in the general plan”. This mandate is inline with the Town’s objective to be inclusive. A comprehensive list of stakeholders is included as Attachment #1. Each will be contacted and invited to participate. Because it is important that the Town pays attention to the best ways to reach and listen to all groups, stakeholders will be asked to identify additional stakeholders, groups, organizations and opportunities for community involvement. VII. Communication Methods and Techniques In keeping with the Public Participation Plan’s guiding principles, communication methods and techniques are designed to reach a broad spectrum of the community and educate them about the process, garner meaningful input and, ultimately, obtain voter ratification. Engaging the community will provide them with a sense of ownership for the General Plan and build trust in the Town, resulting in quality participation and greater likelihood of positive voter turnout. All aspects of the General Plan, including the name, must be transformed from an esoteric technical planning tool into an effort for residents and stakeholders to further develop Oro Valley’s high quality-of-life. The first step will be to create a project identity, including an appealing name, logo, tagline and core messaging pertinent to each phase of the project. All General Plan materials will carry this “project look.” Materials will also be clear, easy-to- understand, engaging and show how the General Plan directly relates to the quality of participants’ lives in Oro Valley and why it should matter to them. To provide ample opportunity to residents and stakeholders for participation, a variety of communication methods and techniques will be employed. The variety will also help insure participation by Oro Valley’s diverse age demographic. Individual methods or techniques tend to resonate with only a portion of residents. Rather than use a “one size fits all” approach, multiple methods and techniques are necessary to include everyone in the conversation. By ensuring opportunities are welcoming and convenient, we will expand the pool of participants. To this end, social media tools and small gatherings in convenient locations are key outreach methods. This approach will be supplemented with traditional community outreach, such as community open houses. Public and stakeholder meetings, focus groups, small group gatherings and other activities will be organized to produce results. Leaders will clearly outline participants’ roles and anticipated time commitment, as well as proposed outcomes to the activity. Leaders will ensure there is time for 5/1/13 Public Participation Plan Page 9 participants to get acquainted with each other, the issues and the process. Next steps will be clearly outlined. Activities will be designed so that participants have the time to understand different points of view and resolve issues that may arise. Participants will be encouraged to develop a common sense of purpose and definitions of challenges faced by the community. Participants will also be encouraged to connect with and educate one another. Each meeting will show how previous public input has been incorporated into the General Plan. The matrix on the following page, Exhibit 1, includes a toolbox of recommended methods and techniques, with the corresponding participants targeted. Attachment #2 includes a description of key terms and definitions used in the matrix. 5/1/13 Public Participation Plan Page 10 Exhibit I, Methods & Techniques Method General Description of Participants TARGETED PARTICIPATION Committees Environment Committee Residents. Demographic = Typically attracts boomers and every effort will be made to include families and youth Community Committee Residents and business interests. Demographic = Typically attracts boomers and every effort will be made to include families and youth Development Committee Residents. Demographic = Typically attracts boomers and every effort will be made to include families and youth Joint Meeting of Committee Representatives Residents. Demographic = Typically attracts boomers and every effort will be made to include families and youth Small Event Meetings Leadership Interviews Elected officials, community, environment, business, and school leadership One on Ones with Stakeholders Broad spectrum of interests HOA Meeting Participation Series HOA board members and residents. Demographic = Boomers Community Conversation on Your Corner Residents. Demographic = Boomers, business employees and families Town Department Review Departmental staff Stakeholder Mtgs. - Gov. & Schools District officials and parent organizations Stakeholder Mtgs. - Community Groups Broad spectrum of interests Stakeholder Mtgs - AZ State Land Dept Homeowners, Sierra Club, EPA Stakeholder Mtgs - Developers/Landowners Realtors, developers and major landowners Boards & Commissions Workshops Appointed officials PZ Commission Study Session Appointed officials Focus Group on Land Use Residents. Demographic = Typically attracts boomers and every effort will be made to include families and youth Focus Group on Economic Development Residents and business leadership. Demographic = Typically attracts boomers and every effort will be made to include families and youth Youth Values Institute Residents: Demographic = Families and youth School/Classroom Participation Exercises Residents: Demographic = Youth and families Neighborhood Gatherings Residents. Demographic = Boomers and families 5/1/13 Public Participation Plan Page 11 Method General Description of Participants COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION Large Event Meetings Town Hall I: Project Kick-off & Future Search Residents. Demographic = Typically attracts boomers and every effort will be made to include families and youth Open House Residents. Demographic = Boomers Public Hearings Residents. Demographic = Boomers Community Events Annual HOA forum HOA board members and residents. Demographic = Boomers State of the Town Broad spectrum of community interests. Demographic = Boomers and middle age. School Functions & Parents Association Residents. Demographic = Families and youth Aquatic Center, Parks & Sporting Events Residents. Demographic = Families and youth SAACA & TSO Events Residents. Demographic = Families and youth Town Holiday Events Residents. Demographic = Families and youth TOV Volunteer Dinner Town volunteers. Demographic = Boomers Web and Social Media Facebook Twitter Orovalleyaz.gov Mobile App MindMixer Surveys MindMixer Surveys in NW Explorer Phone Surveys Informal Event Surveys & Comment forms Local News Media NW Explorer - Advertizing Space NW Explorer - Quarterly Article Vista Articles News Release Letters to Editor Response Demographic = Boomers Articles in HOA Newsletters HOA board members and residents. Demographic = Boomers and family Water Bill Inserts Postcards to Advertise Website & MindMixer Broad spectrum of community interests. Demographic = Boomers and middle age Voter Education Postcard Broad spectrum of community interests. Demographic = Boomers, families and youth BALLOT VOTE Residents. Demographic = Vote eligble Broad spectrum of community interests. Demographic = Boomers, families and youth Broad spectrum of community interests. Demographic = Boomers, families and youth Broad spectrum of community interests. Demographic = Boomers and family 5/1/13 Public Participation Plan Page 12 Method General Description of Participants TOOLS & TECHNIQUES Community Strategy #1: This Is Important! Community Strategy #2: Participate Community Strategy #3: Vote Community Speakers Bureau Leadership Bureau Traveling Mobile Display Technical Reports Broad spectrum of stakeholders. Broad spectrum of OV voters. Demographic: Boomers, families and youth The timing of communication methods and techniques is a key to success. Each will be strategically implemented during targeted phases of the project to maximize effectiveness, and key milestones in the process will be appropriately acknowledged and celebrated. Attachment #3 represents the timing of community outreach relative to key project phases. VIII. Planning Process The General Plan process is intended to be completed over multiple years, culminating in a public vote to ratify the Town Council’s adoption of the General Plan. The initial steps entail identifying and gathering information and community resources. The first milestones include development and approval of a Public Participation Plan, budget planning, development of schedules, collection of data pertaining to all General Plan elements and planning committee process. The planned project phases are: Phase I – Issues/Vision/Core Principles: Identification, development and testing of a community vision and guiding principles. This will entail significant community outreach. Phase II – Draft and Committee Review: Goals and policies for all General Plan elements associated with the environment, community and development will be reviewed by committees, boards, commissions and stakeholders. Phase III – Final Draft and Adoption: Adoption of the updated General Plan will occur through a formal public review process: 1) Final draft review by a committee, 2) Review by agencies identified in state statute, 3) Opportunities for community review 4) Public hearings by the Planning & Zoning Commission, 5) Public hearing and adoption by the Town Council. Phase IV – Ratification: A public outreach and education campaign will result in ratification of the updated General Plan by Town voters. Project milestones are provided in Attachment #4. 5/1/13 Public Participation Plan Page 13 XII. Public Meeting Scheduling, Location and Access In planning public and stakeholder meetings, small gatherings, focus groups and other outreach activities, scheduling and location will be made as accessible and convenient as possible, taking into account available resources. Large meetings and forums will be scheduled at different times, including non-traditional business hours, and every effort will be made to avoid conflict with other community activities. When possible, activities will be scheduled in conjunction with other Town or community activities to maximize participation. Public outreach will occur throughout the Town to reach as many people as possible. Public meetings will be held in locations accessible to people with disabilities and will be held near to transit routes whenever possible. XIII. Special Accommodations Every effort will be made to accommodate people with special needs who would like to participate. Summary information related to the update will be made available in languages other than English, as requested. Additionally, notification for public meetings will include the following language or other Town- approved language: “For accommodations, materials in accessible formats, foreign language interpreters and/or materials in a language other than English, please contact [person] and [phone number] or [email address] at least five business days in advance of this scheduled event.” XIV. Process Documentation All outreach will be documented for future use and understanding of how the program was conducted, how the public responded and how the results of the outreach were used in the development of the General Plan. Documentation will include electronic copies of: • The final, adopted Public Participation Plan • Lists and samples of public notification, information and educational materials • Stakeholder database • List of publicity obtained and, to the extent possible, copies of news articles, display ads, etc. • Summaries of public and stakeholder meetings, focus groups and small group gatherings to show outcomes 5/1/13 Public Participation Plan Page 14 XV. Evaluation System To ensure that the process is inclusive and is achieving the Public Participation Plan goals, the following evaluation system will be utilized: • Staff administering this Public Participation Plan will review the effectiveness of implementation on a regular basis to confirm it is meeting goals mandated by state law and principles identified herein. • Opportunities for feedback regarding the public participation activities will be provided through the project website, social media and at meetings, forums and open houses. Feedback will be reviewed and adjustments made where warranted. • A quarterly update on the implementation effort of the Public Participation Plan will be made to the Planning & Zoning Commission and Town Council. • As part of the General Plan adoption process, a report will be presented to the Planning & Zoning Commission and Town Council analyzing the results of the public participation process at the end of the process. 5/1/13 Public Participation Plan Page 15 Attachment #1 – Community Stakeholders COMMUNITY STAKEHOLDERS: Residents (2010 Census): • Households with kids: 25% of Total Households • Boomers (55 or older) = 41.8% • Boomers who live in Oro Valley seasonally • Gen X (35 – 54) = 25.9% • Gen Y (15-34) = 17.3% • Gen Z (14 & younger) = 15.1% Homeowners Associations All within Town limits (110 total) All within planning boundaries Businesses Interests: Oro Valley Chamber of Commerce Large Business Owners (Oro Valley Hospital, Sanofi Adventis, Ventana Roche, El Conquistador Resort, major shopping centers (Oro Valley Marketplace, Rooney Ranch, Steam Pump Ranch, etc.) Small Business Owners Oro Valley Business Club Economic Development Zone Resort/Hospitality Association Tucson Regional Economic Opportunities Inc. (TREO) Building Industry Interests Metropolitan Pima Alliance (MPA) Tucson Realtors Association Southern Arizona Builders Association (SAHBA) Land Speculators Environmental Interests Coalition for Sonoran Desert Protection Tucson Audubon Society Sonoran Institute Arts and Cultural Interests Southern Arizona Arts & Cultural Alliance (SAACA) Oro Valley Historical Society 5/1/13 Public Participation Plan Page 16 Santa Cruz Heritage Alliance Tohono Chul Park Churches: St Elizabeth Ann Seaton, St Odelia, Church of the Apostles, Oro Valley Chruch of the Nazarene, Oro Valley United Church, St. Mark Catholic Church, Pusch Ridge Christian Church, Vistoso Community Church, Church of the Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saint and, Resurrection Lutheran Church, Dove Mountain Church Schools Casas Christian School, Robert B. Wilson Junior K-8th, Pusch Ridge Christian Academy, Pusch Ridge Christian School, Basis Oro Valley, Ironwood Ridge High School, Canyon Del Oro High School, Painted Sky Elementary School, Immaculate Heart Academy, Resurrection Lutheran Child and La Canada Kindercare.* *Focus on governing boards, parent associations, and students (where appropriate) Service Organizations Oro Valley Rotary Club Oro Valley Optimist Club Catalina-Oro Valley Lions Club Other Owners of vacant land – large and small Oro Valley Citizen Advisory Boards and Commissions Let Oro Valley Excel (LOVE) Blog Oro Valley Truth Blog Users of Parks & Recreation Facilities Library patrons Friends of the Library Employees of Large Business in Oro Valley Oro Valley Hospital patrons Southern AZ Hiking Club El Conquistador County Club Golf Association Governing Board & other boards affiliated with golf courses in or adjacent to Oro Valley Oro Valley Democrat and Republican organizations YMCA Jewish Federation Northwest 5/1/13 Public Participation Plan Page 17 REGULATORY AND PLANNING AGENCIES: Federal: Bureau of Land Management Bureau of Reclamation U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service U.S. Forest Service National Park Service State: Arizona Department of Transportation (ADOT) Arizona State Land Department (ASLD) Arizona Department of Commerce Arizona Game and Fish Arizona State Parks Department Regional: Pima County Sonoran Desert Conservation Plan Team Planning and Development Department of Transportation (PCDOT) Parks Department Pinal County Planning and Development Department of Transportation (PCDOT) Flood Control District of Pima County Pima Association of Governments (PAG) Santa Catalina Ranger Station Catalina State Park Coronado National Forest Pima Council on Aging/ Mature Worker Connection Regional Transit Authority Local: Town of Oro Valley Town Manager’s office Development & Infrastructure Services Water Utility Town Attorney’s Office Parks, Recreation and Cultural Services Finance Police Golder Ranch Fire District Town Clerk’s office Courts Information Technology Amphi School District Marana Schools Town of Marana City of Tucson Catalina Coordinating Council Pima Community College Imagine Greater Tucson 5/1/13 Public Participation Plan Page 18 Attachment #2 – Terms & Definitions for Public Participation Methods Annual HOA forum: Utilize a pre-existing forum for HOAs and managers to invite participation and garner input from the neighborhood representatives. Articles in HOA Newsletters: Articles may be provided to local HOA and Neighborhood Associations to attract residents to meeting, participate and discuss, and inform residents to the planning process and update. Boards & Commissions Workshops: Individual sessions with all seven Town boards and commissions to invite participation, identify issues and review General Plan Update items. Topics will be oriented toward the specific focus of each board and commission. Committee(s): Each committee is comprised of Oro Valley residents and categorized by specific topic areas. Committees are responsible for review of drafts developed by staff. • Development: This committee is responsible for sections pertaining to land use, community design, cost of development and transportation/circulation. • Environment: This committee is responsible for sections pertaining to open space and natural resources conservation, water resources and environmental planning. • Community: This committee is responsible for sections pertaining to economic development, public facilities, services and safety, arts and culture, parks and recreation, archaeological and historic resources and housing. Community Conversation on Your Corner: Venue for residents to participate in quality of life discussions at common gathering areas throughout the community. Community Speakers Bureau: A team of volunteer speakers who are residents and well versed in community planning. Their charge is to speak at events and forums throughout the community. The aim is to invite the community to participate and discuss quality of life issues with residences. Community Strategy(s): • #1: This Is Important!: An informational outreach strategy and tools specific to introducing the project. • #2: Participate: An informational outreach strategy and tools specific to seeking participation. • #3: Vote: An informational outreach strategy and tools specific to voter education. Community Participation: A general category of methods used to engage the larger community, opposed to a key stakeholder group. Facebook: Web-based system used to invite residents to participate and share information. Also, notices and updates may be posted to collect comments. Farmers Market: Provide an information and survey booth to invite residents to participate and discuss community values. Focus Group(s): • Economic Development: Topic specific meeting of residents and business leaders in the community with interest in the future economic development of the Town. • Land Use: Topic specific meeting of residents with special training or interest in land use planning and mapping. HOA Meeting Participation Series: Participation in annual or regular HOA meetings to invite participation and discuss quality of life issues. 5/1/13 Public Participation Plan Page 19 Informal Event Surveys & Comment forms: Surveys that are created to directly gather input at specific events. Joint Meeting of Committee Representatives: Meeting of representatives from the Development, Environmental and Community committees. The objective is to insure that findings from the individual committees harmonize to create a holistic approach. Leadership Bureau: A team of community leaders whose purpose is to help advocate community participation and “get out the vote”. Leadership Interviews: One on one meetings to interview local leaders such as Town Council, school boards, key employers, HOA representatives etc. Letters to Editor Response: Town response to address relevant concerns expressed in the NW Explorer. MindMixer: A web-based discussion board that enables participation on a wide range of topics for comment. Participants may also post new topics or ideas. This tool will be used to attract participants such as young families who may not have time to attend evening meetings. Neighborhood Gatherings: Neighborhood block meetings organized by interested residents. Members of the Speakers Bureau or staff will initiate discussions regarding the vitality of the community. News Release: Media alerts to invite participation and share important milestones in the process. NW Explorer - Advertizing Space: Advertising to increase participation in event, meeting, survey and web-based discussion opportunities. NW Explorer - Monthly Article: Articles inviting participation, analysis of key community issues and reporting general plan update progress. One on Ones with Stakeholders: Meetings with special interest stakeholders to discuss issues and concerns. Open House: Opportunity for residents to meet with staff and community leaders to discuss quality of life issues and/or elements of a draft General Plan. Orovalleyaz.gov: Display of General Plan updates, meeting announcements and background reports on the Town website. Postcards: Mailed cards to invite participation in events, electronic surveys and voter ratification. Public Hearings: Formal hearings to vote on the final draft of the General Plan update. PZ Commission Study Session: Updates regarding progress and findings over the term of the project. School Functions: Utilize existing school events to invite participation and survey quality of life issues. Speakers Bureau: Community leaders whose purpose is to meet with community groups (HOA’s etc.), invite participation and lead discussions relative to quality of life issues. Stakeholder Meeting(s): Staff meeting(s) with key stakeholders to discuss potential issues or concerns. • AZ State Land Dept.: The Arroyo Grande area is a sizable component of the General Plan. ASLD must be provided the opportunity to review all General Plans in Arizona. • Developers/Landowners: Developers, realtors and landowners interested in economics, land use policy and community design. • Community Groups: Non-profits, clubs, churches etc. 5/1/13 Public Participation Plan Page 20 • Gov. & Schools: Surrounding jurisdictions and schools (public, charter and private) within Oro Valley. State of the Town: A standing annual event attracting a broad cross-section of community leaders and interests. Surveys in NW Explorer: Published survey to identify community values and needs that respondents mail back to the Town. The aim is to reach a broader audience than can be anticipated at meetings. Targeted Participation: Methods used to “target” specific community groups, locations, and/or topics; rather than the community as a whole. Technical Reports: Baseline information such as census or housing data to use in decision-making. Town Department Review: Internal review process involving Town agencies to ensure timeliness and validity. Town Hall I: Project Kick-off & Future Search: A large event for residents to define project objectives, invite participation and discuss quality of life issues. TOV Volunteer Dinner: Dinner hosted for the volunteers that assisted throughout the General Plan Update. Traveling Mobile Display: An informational display booth to be used at various events throughout the process. Twitter: “tweets” will be used to send event, meeting, and progress alerts. Also Twitter will be used to invite participation in surveys. Vista Articles: Quarterly online articles submitted to the Town. Voter Education Postcards or Newsletter: Mailer used to describe the General Plan ballot measure. Youth Values Institute: A gathering of younger generations to discuss community values, issues and needs. 5/1/13 Public Participation Plan Page 21 Attachment #3 – Public Participation Flowchart Public Participation Plan Methods Committees & Boards Environment Committee ¤ Community Committee ¤ Development Committee ¤ Joint Meeting of Committee Representatives ¤¤ ¤ Small Event Meetings Leadership Interviews (20 persons per set)¤¤ ¤ One on Ones with Stakeholders ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ HOA Meeting Participation Series ¤¤ ¤ Community Conversation on Your Corner Town Department Review Meetings ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ Stakeholder Mtgs. - Gov. & Schools ¤¤ ¤ Stakeholder Mtgs. - Community Groups ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ Stakeholder Mtgs - AZ State Land Dept ¤¤ ¤ Stakeholder Mtgs - Developers/Landowners ¤ Boards & Commissions Workshops ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ PZ Commission Study Session ¤ ¤ Focus Group on Land Use ¤ Focus Group on Economic Development ¤ Youth Values Institute ¤ School/Classroom Participation Exercises ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ Neighborhood Gatherings ¤¤ ¤ Large Event Meetings Town Hall I: Project Kick-off & Future Search ¤ Open House ¤ ¤ Public Hearings ¤ ¤ Community Events Annual HOA forum ¤ State of the Town ¤¤ School Functions & Parents Association ¤ ¤¤ Aquatic Center, Parks & Sporting Events ¤ ¤ SAACA & TSO Events ¤ ¤¤ Town Holiday Events ¤¤ TOV Volunteer Dinner ¤¤ Web and Social Media Facebook ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ Twitter ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ Orovalleyaz.gov ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ Mobile App ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ Mindmixer (software and initial setup)¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ Surveys Mindmixer (design of surveys)¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ Survey Published in NW Explorer ¤ Informal Event Surveys & Comment forms ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ Phone Surveys ¤¤ Local News Media NW Explorer - Advertizing Space ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ NW Explorer - Quarterly Article ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ Vista Articles ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ News Release ¤¤ ¤ Letters to Editor Response ¤¤ ¤ Articles in HOA Newsletters ¤¤ ¤ Water Bill Inserts Postcards to Advertize Website & Mindmixer ¤¤ Voter Education Postcard ¤ Ballot Vote ¤ Phase IV Final Draft & Adoption Vote Targeted Participation Phase I Phase II Phase III Community Participation Environment Community Development Community Values Draft Elements 5/1/13 Public Participation Plan Page 22 Public Participation Plan Methods cont. Communication Strategy #1: This is important!¤ Communication Strategy #2: Participate!¤ Communication Strategy #3: Vote! Community Speakers Bureau ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ Leadership Bureau ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ Traveling Mobile Display ¤¤ Technical Reports (baseline information) ¤ Phase IV Final Draft & Adoption Vote Phase I Phase II Phase III Tools & Techniques Environment Community Development Community Values Draft Elements 5/1/13 Public Participation Plan Page 23 Attachment #4 – Project Milestones Milestone Approximate Date Planning & Zoning Commission review of Public Participation Plan April 2013 Town Council review of Public Participation Plan May 2013 Develop technical background reports May–July 2013 Budget adoption July 2013 Hire consultant/contractors Fall 2013 Finalize formal schedule Fall 2013 General Plan public kick-off and start of community engagement Fall 2013 Draft elements 2013–2014 Committee review 2014–2015 Develop final draft 2015 Public review of draft General Plan 2015 Inter-agency review 2015 Draft Implementation Plan 2015 Planning & Zoning Commission study sessions and public hearing 2015 Town Council public hearing and adoption 2015 Ratification election 2016 1 YOUR VOICE, OUR FUTURE GENERAL PLAN 2022 UPDATE BRIEF SUMMARY TOTAL ACTION ITEMS 2016-2021 SUMMARY Community actions (pg. 2) 123 Completed or Maintained Items 256 Environment actions (pg. 7) 116 Remaining items being worked on over the past year (in progress) 37 Development actions (pg. 10) 71 Remaining items recommended for a future SLP (future items) 17 Total 310 Total 310 2022 UPDATE ON THE 54 REMAINING TASKS ACCOMPLISHMENTS SINCE 2016 Completed items +11 Total Accomplished (completed or maintained) 269 87% Maintained items +2 Remaining Items: In Progress 25 In Progress 25 8% Future items 16 Future items 16 5% General Plan 2016-2026 Strategic Leadership Plans Town Department Work Plans Staff Resources/ Annual Budget Purpose The Your Voice, Our Future General Plan was ratified by the voters in November 2016. The General Plan consists of the community ’s vision and goals for the Town and is used as a guide in long range decision- making. The General Plan is a long-range 10-year policy document designed to guide the Town through 2026. Implementing the General Plan The community ’s vision and guiding principles provided the foundation for the goals, policies, and actions in the General Plan. The 310 actions were established to fulfill the goals and policies and are intended to be somewhat flexible as priorities and resources shift. The actions are prioritized every two years through the Town Council’s Strategic Leadership Plan. These priorities are translated to individual Town Department Work Plans for implementation. As a commitment to the Town Council and Oro Valley residents, the following information provides an update on the remaining 54 items to complete from the General Plan. TOTAL TASKS CURRENTLY IN PROGRESS REMAINING TASKS TO EVALUATE OR COMPLETE IN THE FUTURE Key Points: • 95% of the action items are either complete, maintained or actively being worked on. • There are four more years to prioritize and direct resources towards completing or evaluating the remaining 16 items. 2 COMMUNITY ACTIONS SUMMARY FROM PREVIOUS YEARS (123 TASKS TOTAL) 2022 UPDATE ON THE 21 REMAINING TASKS ACCOMPLISHMENTS SINCE 2016 (87%) TASKS TO COMPLETE (13%) Completed 39 Completed +3 Total tasks completed 42 Total tasks currently in progress 13 Maintained 63 Maintained +2 In Progress 18 In Progress 13 Total tasks maintained through ongoing operations 65 Remaining tasks to evaluate or complete in the future 3 Future items 3 Future items 3 ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT- REMAINING TASKS NO. TASK TIME DEPT. STATUS ASSOCIATED PROJECTS/PROGRAMS SLP 2021 2022 6 Create private and public sector partnerships and programs for use, beautification, art displays or publicity on underutilized or vacant employment and retail centers. Medium CED In Progress In Progress • Revised Master Development Plan for the Oro Marketplace – includes a community gathering space in the center. • Entrepreneurial Needs Study – completed in November 2021. 1B 1C 7 Develop strategies that promote a range of retail options, including regional-serving, neighborhood-serving and pedestrian-oriented, at appropriate locations. Medium CED In Progress In Progress • Comprehensive Economic Development Strategy (CEDS) – Adopted by Town Council in 2019. • Retail Study – Elements of the retail study were incorporated into the housing study to meet the SLP objective. The scope of work for the retail study will be completed after the housing study is done to minimize overlap between the two. • Housing Study – The scope for the housing study was finalized in October 2022 after receiving feedback from the Planning and Zoning Commission and Town Council. The study will be conducted in two phases: 1) data gathering to be completed by the end of February and 2) a statistically valid survey to fill in any data gaps and gather anecdotal opinions. Staff anticipates presenting the findings and recommendations to the Planning and Zoning Commission and Town Council 1B 1C 3 next Fall with other elements of the 2026 General Plan Background Report. • Business Summit – A summit was held in January 2022 to understand the challenges and opportunities associated with operating a thriving business. This event will be annual with the next one planned for January 2023. 9 Develop partnerships with local organizations and businesses in order to: A. Identify needs for businesses which provide quality, accessible childcare, preschool, special needs and adult/elder care options. Medium CED In Progress Maintained • Business Summit - A summit was held in January 2022 to understand the challenges and opportunities associated with operating a thriving business. This event will be annual with the next one planned for January 2023. • Business Retention and Expansion Program – routine discussions with OV businesses to understand needs. In January 2022, elements of OVSafeSteps were incorporated to create OVNextSteps. 1A 1B B. Support and promote the success of working families. Medium CED In Progress Maintained COMPLETE COMMUNITY- REMAINING TASKS 10 Develop a plan for designating areas in Oro Valley that serve as the community’s gathering places and are envisioned to: B. Include such amenities as sidewalk cafes, outdoor seating and desert landscaping. Short CED In Progress Complete • Revised Master Development Plan for the Oro Marketplace – includes a community gathering space in the center. Approved by Town Council in November 2022. 1C C. Emphasize the pedestrian experience. Short CED, P&R, PW In Progress In Progress • Existing code requirements -All new public roadway projects require a multi-use path. All private developments must have pedestrian connectivity from roadways to entry points and courtyards/recreation areas. Recent examples include the pedestrian/bicycle trail near Greenock and the loop connection near the Oro Valley Hospital. 4 • Update to the Town’s Design Principles and Standards – Anticipated for consideration by the Town Council by June 2023. 5A 11 Update existing Town programs, plans and regulations to create or expand Oro Valley’s community gathering places, such as: A. Development and zoning regulations to include new designations, such as mixed- use zoning. Medium CED Future Item Future Item • Existing code requirements - The neighborhood commercial (C-N) zoning district has standards for residential and commercial developments. • Evaluation and possible creation of a mixed-use zoning district is recommended for a future strategic plan to direct further resources needed to complete this task. 12 Develop public/private partnerships in order to create synergy and achieve common goals and desired improvements for Oro Valley’s community gathering places. Medium CED, P&R, TM, I&T In Progress In Progress • Parks and Recreation Master Plan – Completed in May 2021. • IGA with Amphitheater Unified School District – Anticipated completion date June 2023. • Revised Master Development Plan for the Oro Marketplace – includes a community gathering space in the center. Approved by Town Council in November 2022. 1C 2A 13 Creating development review strategies for commercial and retail areas that encourage public spaces. Medium CED In Progress In Progress • Existing code requirement - The code requires public spaces (courtyards) for all non-residential projects. • Revised Master Development Plan for the Oro Valley Marketplace – includes a community gathering space in the center. Approved by Town Council in November 2022. • Update to the Town’s Design Principles and Standards – Anticipated for consideration by the Town Council by June 2023. 1B 5A 16 Create a program that promotes accessible, convenient and age- friendly design of public and private facilities, services and programs. Medium CED, PW In Progress Complete • Opportunities to create or expand multigenerational programs and facilities were explored and are now being implemented – examples include special events, art and health and wellness programs. 2B 27 Explore options for creating a Town Senior Advisory Council to Long TM, I&T, In Progress Complete • Senior Task Force – A temporary senior task force was created by the Parks and Recreation Department to 2B 5 direct priorities for senior services in the community. P&R help identify programming access needs (per the FY21/22-22/23 SLP). Additional task forces may be utilized in the future as needed. 30 Continue support of the Town's Public Art Program by: A. Developing an inventory and maintenance program, including training for staff on correct maintenance procedures Medium CED In Progress In Progress • Public and private art database for internal use anticipated for completion by December 2021. • Coordination with the Southern Arizona Arts and Cultural Alliance (SAACA) to assess public art maintenance needs - Anticipated completion by end of October 2022 1D 37 Develop cooperative agreements with public school districts, private and charter schools to share school facilities for arts, recreation and education purposes. Short P&R, TM In Progress In Progress • IGA with Amphitheater Unified School District – Anticipated completion date June 2023 2A 39 Evaluate and address the Town’s community park system conditions and needs by: B. Developing and integrating strategies that address park shortages, preservation needs and safety upgrades into the Parks Master Plan. Medium P&R In Progress In Progress • Recommendations to prioritize larger neighborhood area parks and amenities – Best practices to prioritize larger neighborhood park areas and enhanced amenities were presented to the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board (PRAB) and the Planning and Zoning Commission at the end of the summer 2022. Staff is currently drafting a proposed code amendment to incorporate these findings and feedback from the board and commission. Anticipated completion date is April 2023. 5A 44 Develop a strategy to acquire property for larger recreational and community use of sufficient size and location that access can be shared equitably by multiple neighborhoods and all residents. Long CED, PW, F, P&R, TM In Progress In Progress • Recommendations to prioritize larger neighborhood area parks and amenities – See details in #39. Anticipated completion date April 2023. 5A 45 Review opportunities to repurpose land for small and neighborhood parks by acquiring land or partnering Long CED, F, P&R, TM In Progress In Progress • Recommendations to prioritize larger neighborhood area parks and amenities – See details in #39. Anticipated completion date April 2023. 5A 6 with local stakeholders and agencies. • Analysis of private and public golf courses – Vistoso golf and El Conquistador golf course were evaluated for potential repurposing in 2020/2021. 46 Plan for future trail needs in the community by developing and adopting a trails plan that: A. Establishes long-term strategies for trail development, linkages, management and upkeep in cooperation with other local jurisdictions Medium CED, P&R Future Item Future Item • An updated trails plan is recommended for a future strategic plan to direct further resources needed to complete this task. B. Integrates with the Parks Master Plan and is periodically updated. Medium CED, P&R Future Item Future Item 47 Create procedures, including public and private contributions, for integrating signs into parks, trailheads, trails and linear bicycle paths and near natural areas that: B. Inform users of site information and regulations. Medium CED, P&R In Progress In Progress • Existing code requirement - Requires signs in all private parks and for public trails on private properties. Signs include information and rules/regulations. Trailheads and trails have signage that include the name of the location and wayfinding directional arrows. New trails added through development are required to provide wayfinding directional signage • Update to the Town’s Design Principles and Standards – Anticipated for consideration by the Town Council by June 2023. 5A PUBLIC FACILITES AND SERVICES –REMAINING TASKS 50 Develop a plan for long-term municipal facilities that considers overall community needs and growth and that addresses parking, facility expansion, satellite offices, central offices, maintenance and fueling facilities and operations. Medium PW, TM, I&T In Progress In Progress • Town-wide space and facilities needs study– The study was reconfigured and finished to facility elements for possible development of the Town’s Rooney Ranch parcel. The Town entered into an agreement with Gensler and Associated to conduct the Rooney Ranch Master Plan project, which will be presented to Council in early 2023. 4C 7 SONORAN DESERT RESOURCE- REMAINING TASKS NO. TASK TIME DEPT. STATUS ASSOCIATED PROJECTS/PROGRAMS SLP 2021 2022 72 Maintain and improve night sky visibility by: A. Updating regulations to incorporate new technologies and best practices that minimize light pollution. Short CED, PW In Progress In Progress • Lighting Code Amendment – A regional approach to update lighting is in progress. Once complete, updates to the Town’s lighting code will be recommended. 1A B. Adhering to regional dark-skies initiatives. Ongoing CED, PW In Progress In Progress 74 Develop and implement the Town’s Tree Master Plan, which considers the benefits of trees in relation to overall community welfare, while making plans for infrastructure, facilities, new development and the conservation of Oro Valley's scenic views. Medium CED, PW, P&R Future Item Future Item • This action is recommended for a future strategic plan to direct further resources needed to complete this task. 77 Develop measures that encourage private property owners to assist in invasive species removal. Short CED Future Item Future Item • Invasive plant species are identified and removed during the development process. The Zoning Code also includes a list of prohibited species (Addendum E) ENVIRONMENT ACTIONS SUMMARY FROM PREVIOUS YEARS (116 TASKS TOTAL) 2022 UPDATE ON THE 13 REMAINING TASKS TOTAL ACCOMPLISHMENTS SINCE 2016 (91%) TASKS TO COMPLETE (9%) Completed 46 Completed +2 Total tasks completed 48 Total tasks currently in progress 4 Maintained 57 Maintained 0 In Progress 6 In Progress 4 Total tasks maintained through ongoing operations 57 Remaining tasks to evaluate or complete in the future 7 Future Items 7 Future Items 7 8 available to the public. Additional measures are recommended for a future strategic plan to direct further resources needed to complete this task. WATER CONSERVATION- REMAINING TASKS 82 Reduce dependence on, use and diminishing of the groundwater supply by: A. Exploring the expanded use of stormwater harvesting and recharge areas. Medium WU Future Item Future Item • This action is recommended for a future strategic plan to direct further resources needed to complete this task. 83 Expand infrastructure and facilities that provide for a diverse water supply portfolio, including Central Arizona Project water and the use of reclaimed water for irrigation and other purposes. Long WU In Progress In Progress • NWRRDS Expansion - The Water Utility is expanding, and the Northwest Recharge and Recovery Delivery System (NWRRDS) allowing for the delivery of additional CAP entitlements for use in the community. The partnered portion of the NWRRDS has been postponed until the bidding environment improves. However, work continues to move forward with the independent portions for the project. Additionally, the Water Utility is assessing the feasibility of expanding the reclaimed water system to support turf irrigation currently being irrigated by groundwater. CULTURAL RESOURCE- REMAINING TASKS 101 Preserve and share significant cultural resources of Oro Valley with the community by: A. Identifying significant cultural resources, including people, events, places and activities in an inventory that is periodically updated. Medium CED, P&R In Progress Complete • Review of the Preservation Plan –The Historic Preservation Commission (HPC) reviewed the plan in 2022. 9 B. Collecting oral histories from key persons related to Oro Valley history. Medium CED, P&R In Progress In Progress • Key people have been identified and some oral histories have been collected. C. Creating and executing a plan for the placement of interpretive elements related to cultural resource sites in existing and planned Town facilities and properties with the assistance of outside funding. Medium CED, PW, P&R Future Item Future Item • This action is recommended for a future strategic plan to direct further resources needed to complete this task. CLEAN ENVIRONMENT- REMAINING TASKS 110 Promote sustainable practices in the private sector by: Medium CED, WU Future Item Future Item • This action is recommended for a future strategic plan to direct further resources needed to complete this task. C. Partnering with local businesses to create incentives for the education, purchase and/or installation of resource conservation products. 113 Promote energy efficiency by: A. Reviewing, identifying and addressing Town policies and ordinances that enhance renewable energy production, efficiency and conservation. Medium CED, PW Future Item Future Item • This action is recommended for a future strategic plan to direct further resources needed to complete this task. B. Conducting an assessment of emerging renewable technologies for potential application in the community. Medium CED, PW Future Item Future Item • This action is recommended for a future strategic plan to direct further resources needed to complete this task. 120 Pursue sustainability and environmental conservation in development by: Medium CED In Progress Complete • Parking code update – Allowing additional rainwater harvesting within parking areas. Encourages solar parking by removing conflicting code requirements. Approved by Town Council in January 2022. 1A B. Including sustainable and environmental development practices in Town development review. 10 DEVELOPMENT ACTIONS SUMMARY FROM PREVIOUS YEAR (71 TASKS TOTAL) 2021 UPDATE ON THE 20 REMAINING TASKS TOTAL ACCOMPLISHMENTS SINCE 2016 (79%) TASKS TO COMPLETE (21%) Completed 18 Completed +6 Total tasks completed 24 Total tasks currently in progress 8 Maintained 33 Maintained 0 In Progress 13 In Progress 8 Total tasks maintained through ongoing operations 33 Remaining tasks to evaluate or complete in the future 6 Future items 7 Future Items 6 LAND USE AND DESIGN- REMAINING TASKS NO. TASK TIME DEPT. STATUS ASSOCIATED PROJECTS/PROGRAMS SLP 2021 2022 125 Maintain the unique character of Oro Valley by studying and updating: A. Site design standards. Medium CED In Progress In Progress • Update to the Town’s Design Principles and Standards – Anticipated for consideration by the Town Council by June 2023. 5A B. Land use regulations that define and incorporate effective compatibility standards. Medium CED In Progress In Progress C. Regulations that enable a variety of architectural colors and textures, especially for commercial, that integrate with the community and don’t emphasize sameness. Medium CED In Progress In Progress 128 Develop detailed planning for designated neighborhood-scale growth areas at prominent intersections. Long CED Future Item Future Item • This action is recommended for a future strategic plan to direct further resources needed to complete this task. 129 Create development standards, policies and provisions and make available in appropriate locations for: Long CED Future Item Future Item • This action is recommended for a future strategic plan to direct 11 A. Form-based code. further resources needed to complete this task. B. Transit-oriented development. Long CED Future Item Future Item C. Mixed-use zoning. Long CED Future Item Future Item 130 Update development regulations of Master Planned communities to: A. Incorporate land uses consistent with surrounding development and residential acceptance. Medium CED Future Item Complete • Requiring Master Development Plans was part of a larger code amendment to the Development Review Process approved by Town Council in October 2022. 1C 134 Hold periodic “energy summits” by bringing together providers, key landowners, businesses and Town staff to identify and resolve issues and discuss plans for future growth. Long CED, TM In Progress Complete • Utility service capacity project – The utility service capacity for all commercial and tech park properties is available on the ChooseOroValley.gov website. • Fiber Optics Plan – provided to Town Council in 2022. • TEP Summit –discussed capacity to serve Innovation Park in October 2022. • Water budget for economic development projects – ongoing discussions between CED and the Water Utility to discuss long-term water needs to support economic development. 1B 135 Respond to and plan for the present and future housing needs of the community, while considering changes in demographics and overall growth by: A. Conducting a housing inventory. B. Developing a housing plan, that addresses the needs of a diverse community. Medium Medium CED CED In Progress In Progress In Progress In Progress • Elements of a housing study were inventoried and analyzed through a Market Study (2017) and Apartment Study (2020). • Housing Study – The scope for the housing study was finalized in October 2022 after receiving 5A 12 C. Developing zoning strategies that implement the housing plan. Medium CED In Progress In Progress feedback from the Planning and Zoning Commission and Town Council. The study will be conducted in two phases: 1) data gathering to be completed by the end of February and 2) a statistically valid survey to fill in any data gaps and gather anecdotal opinions. Staff anticipates presenting the findings and recommendations to the Planning and Zoning Commission and Town Council next Fall with other elements of the 2026 General Plan Background Report. INFRASTRUCTURE- REMAINING TASKS 137 Develop a plan for new development and infrastructure that: A. Identifies funding methods and techniques. Medium PW, F, I&T In Progress In Progress • RTA Next – The Town continues to participate and support the RTA Next. Staff recommended projects to the RTA and the associated Citizen Advisory Committee. Currently, staff is working with the RTA to reduce the list of regional projects to meet the expected budget allocations. • Stormwater improvements - actively seek and receive exterior funding from Pima County Regional Flood Control and federal grants. 4A 141 Coordinate infrastructure expansion and future utility services in Innovation Park and other key employment and commerce sites. Ongoing CED In Progress In Progress • Fiber Optics Plan – provided to Town Council in 2022. • TEP Summit –discussed capacity to serve Innovation Park in October 2022. 1B 4C 13 • Water budget for economic development projects – ongoing discussions between CED and the Water Utility to discuss long-term water needs to support economic development. 142 Increase opportunities for telecommunications and broadband services in the community by: A. Identifying community needs and suitable providers. Long CED, I&T, TM In Progress Completed • Fiber Optics Plan – A letter of support was provided to Pima County for the State Middle Mile grant. The Town Fiber Optic Plan has been provided to Town Council. 4C B. Assessing suitable locations and the impact on current infrastructure. Long CED, I&T, TM In Progress Completed TRANSPORTATION/CIRCULATION- REMINAING TASKS 146 Re-examine Zoning Code parking ratios as part of overall transportation planning in areas where transportation options other than the automobile are available. Medium CED, PW In Progress Completed • Parking Code Amendment – Approved by Town Council in January 2022. 1A 147 Create a complete streets design manual that considers means to calm traffic, traffic safety, neighborhood aesthetics, stormwater management, access management, public health, safety and community vitality. Short CED, PW Future Item Future Item • Update to the Town Subdivision Street Standards - recommended for a future strategic plan item to direct further resources needed to complete this task. 148 Complete long-range planning for the roadway network that addresses: • RTA Next – The Town continues to participate and support the RTA Next. Staff recommended projects to the RTA and the associated Citizen Advisory Committee. Currently, staff is working with the RTA to reduce the list of regional projects to meet the expected budget allocations. 4A B. Future transportation needs, access and development on major roadways. Medium CED, PW In Progress In Progress 14 150 Coordinate with the state to develop detailed planning for Oracle Road that identifies partnerships, funding options and agreements in order to allow for: A. Diverse development. Medium CED, PW In Progress Complete • Zoning amendment to revise the scenic corridor standards for consistency – approved in 2020. • Revised Master Development Plan for the Oro Valley Marketplace –Approved by Town Council in November 2022. 1C 151 Re-evaluate roadway design standards, especially for arterial and collector roads, to include methods for: A. Reducing fuel consumption, congestion and the number of vehicles starts and stops. Medium PW, OVPD Future Item Future Item • Update to the Town Subdivision Street Standards - recommended for a future strategic plan item to direct further resources needed to complete this task. Department abbreviations: CED- Community and Economic Development Department F- Finance GRFD- Golder Ranch Fire District I&T- Innovation and Technology OVPD- Oro Valley Police Department P&R- Parks and Recreation PW- Public Works TM- Town Manager’s Office WU- Water Utility General Plan Legal Requirements Key Process Requirements 1. Community Engagement Plan Adoption 2. Consistent and ongoing communication with Town Council and affected agencies 3. 60-day review period 4. Two public hearings with the Planning and Zoning Commission 5. Public hearing with Town Council for adoption 6. Voter ratification during next available election after TC adoption Process related requirements State Law Compliance for 2026 1. Adopt a public participation plan ARS 9-461.06. C. 1. The governing body shall adopt written procedures to provide effective, early and continuous public participation in the development and major amendment of general plans from all geographic, ethnic and economic areas of the municipality. The procedures shall provide for: (a) The broad dissemination of proposals and alternatives. (b) The opportunity for written comments. (c) Public hearings after effective notice. (d) Open discussions, communications programs and information services. (e) Consideration of public comments. Adoption of the Community Engagement Plan 2. Ongoing communication with Town Council and affected agencies. ARS 9-461.06. C.2 Consult with, advise and provide an opportunity for official comment by public officials and agencies, the county, school districts, associations of governments, public land management agencies, the military airport if the municipality has territory in the vicinity of a military airport or ancillary military facility as defined in section 28-8461, other appropriate government jurisdictions, public utility companies, civic, educational, professional and other organizations, property owners and citizens generally to secure maximum coordination of plans and to indicate properly located sites for all public purposes on the general plan. ARS 9-461.05.A Each planning agency shall prepare, and the governing body of each municipality shall adopt a comprehensive, long-range general plan for the development of the municipality. The planning agency shall coordinate the production of its general plan with the creation of the state land departme nt conceptual land use plans under title 37, chapter 2, article 5.1 and shall cooperate with the state land department regarding integrating the conceptual state land use plans into the municipality's general land use plan. The general plan shall include provisions that identify changes or modifications to the plan that constitute amendments and major amendments. The plan shall be adopted and readopted in the manner prescribed by section 9-461.06. Regular check-ins scheduled with board/commissions and Town Council 3. 60-Day review period by Town Council, Planning and Zoning Commission and specific outside agencies ARS 9-461.06. D. At least sixty days before the general plan or an element or major amendment of a general plan is noticed pursuant to subsection E of this section, the planning agency shall transmit the proposal to the planning commission, if any, and the governing body and shall submit a copy for review and further comment to: 1. The planning agency of the county in which the municipality is located. 2. Each county or municipality that is contiguous to the corporate limits of the municipality or its area of extraterritorial jurisdiction. 3. The regional planning agency within which the municipality is located. 4. The Arizona commerce authority or any other state agency that is subsequently designated as the general planning agency for this state. 5. The department of water resources for review and comment on the water resources element, if a water resources element is required. 6. If the general plan or an element or amendment of the general plan is applicable to territory in the vicinity of a military airport or ancillary military facility as defined in section 28-8461, the military airport. 7. If the general plan or an element or major amendment of the general plan is applicable to property in the high noise or accident potential zone of a military airport or ancillary military facility as defined in section 28 - 8461, the attorney general. For the purposes of this paragraph, "major amendment" means a substantial alteration of the municipality's land use mixture or balance as established in the municipality's existing general plan land use element. 8. Any person or entity that requests in writing to receive a review copy of the proposal Provide 60-day review period to: - Town Council - Planning and Zoning Commission - Pima County - Pinal County - Town of Marana - City of Tucson - Pima Association of Governments (PAG) - Arizona Commerce Authority - Arizona Department of Water Resources 4. Two public hearings required with the Planning and Zoning Commission re: recommendation for adoption ARS 9-461.06. E. If the municipality has a planning commission, after considering any recommendations from the review required under subsection D of this section the planning commission shall hold at least one public hearing before approving a general plan or any amendment to such plan. When the general plan or any major amendment is being adopted, planning commissions in municipalities having populations over twenty-five thousand persons shall hold two or more public hearings at different locations within the municipality to promote citizen participation. Notice of the time and place of a hearing and availability of studies and summaries related to the hearing shall be given at least fifteen and not more than thirty calendar days before the hearing by: 1. Publication at least once in a newspaper of general circulation published or circulated in the municipality, or if there is none, the notice shall be posted in at least ten public places in the municipality. 2. Such other manner in addition to publication as the municipality may deem necessary or desirable. ARS 9-461.06. F. Action by the planning commission on the general plan or any amendment to the plan shall be transmitted to the governing body of the municipality. Two public hearings to the Planning and Zoning Commission - One must be offsite - Notice in paper and at least 10 public places - Recommendation required during 2nd hearing to be transmitted to Council 5. Public hearing required for Town Council adoption. ARS 9-461.06. G. Before adopting the general plan, or any amendment to it, the governing body shall hold at least one public hearing. Notice of the time and place of the hearing shall be given in the time and manner provided for the giving of notice of the hearing by the planning commission as specified in subsection E of this section. ARS 9-461.06. H. The adoption or readoption of the general plan or any amendment to such plan shall be by resolution of the governing body of the municipality, after notice as provided for in subsection E of this section. The adoption or readoption of or a major amendment to the general plan shall be approved by affirmative vote of at least two- thirds of the members of the governing body of the municipality. All major amendments to the general plan proposed for adoption by the governing body of a municipality shall be presented at a single public hearing during the calendar year the proposal is made. The general plan, or any amendment to the plan, shall be endorsed in the manner provided by the governing body to show that it has been adopted by the governing body. If the municipality includes property in the high noise or accident potential zone of a military airport or ancillary military facility as defined in section 28-8461, the governing body of the municipality shall send notice of the approval, adoption or readoption of the general plan or major amendment to the general plan to the attorney general by certified mail, return receipt requested, within three business days after the approval, adoption or readoption. If the attorney general determines the approval, adoption or readoption of the general plan or major amendment to the general plan is not in compliance with section 28-8481, subsection J, the attorney general shall notify the municipality by certified mail, return receipt requested, of the determination of noncompliance. The municipality shall receive the notice from the attorney general within twenty-five days after the notice from the municipality to the attorney general is mailed pursuant to this subsection. The effective date of any approval, adoption or readoption of, or major amendment to, the general plan shall be thirty days after the governing body's receipt of the attorney general's determination of noncompliance. Within thirty days after the receipt of a determination of noncompliance by the attorney general as prescribed by this section, the governing body of the municipality shall reconsider any approval, adoption or readoption of, or major amendment to, the general plan that impacts property in the high noise or accident potential zone of a military airport or ancillary military facility as defined in section 28-8461. If the governing body reaffirms a prior action subject to an attorney general's determination of noncompliance pursuant to this section, the attorney general may institute a civil action pursuant to section 28-8481, subsection L. If the governing body timely sends notice pursuant to this subsection and the attorney general fails to timely notify the governing body of a determination of noncompliance, the general plan or major amendment to the general plan shall be deemed to comply with section 28-8481, subsection J. If the motion to adopt or readopt a general plan or an amendment to the general plan fails to pass, the governing body may reconsider the motion in any manner allowed by the governing body's rules of procedure, but any subsequent motion for the adoption or readoption of the general plan or a major amendment to the general plan must be approved by an affirmative vote of at least two-thirds of the members of the governing body. One public hearing with Town Council - Notice in paper and at least 10 public places - Must be adopted by 2/3 of the vote through a resolution For the purposes of this subsection, "major amendment" means a substantial alteration of the municipality's land use mixture or balance as established in the municipality's existing general plan land use element. The municipality's general plan shall define the criteria to determine if a proposed amendment to the general plan effects a substantial alteration of the municipality's land use mixture or balance as established in the municipality's existing general plan land use element. ARS 9-461.06. I. – Not applicable If the municipality does not have a planning commission, the only procedural steps required for the adoption of the general plan, or any amendment to such plan, shall be those provided in this article for action by the governing body. ARS 9-461.06. O. A person, after having participated in the public hearing pursuant to subsection H of this section, may file a petition for special action in superior court to review the governing body's decision that does not comply with the mandatory requirement prescribed in section 9-461.05, subsection C, paragraph 1 [Land Use Element], subdivision (g) within thirty days after the governing body has rendered its decision. The court may affirm, reverse or remand to the governing body, in whole or in part, the decision reviewed for further action that is necessary to comply with the mandatory requirements prescribed in section 9-461.05, subsection C, paragraph 1, subdivision (g). 6. Voter ratification – must be on ballot for the next regularly scheduled election after TC adoption ARS 9-461.06. M. The governing body of a city or town having a population of more than two thousand five hundred persons but less than ten thousand persons and whose population growth rate exceeded an average of two per cent per year for the ten year period before the most recent United States decennial census, and any city or town having a population of ten thousand or more persons, shall submit each new general plan adopted pursuant to subsection K of this section to the voters for ratification at the next regularly scheduled municipal election or at a special election scheduled at least one hundred twenty days after the governing body adopted the plan pursuant to section 16-204. The governing body shall include a general description of the plan and its elements in the municipal election pamphlet and shall provide public copies of the plan in at least two locations that are easily accessible to the public and may include posting on the municipality's official internet w ebsite. If a majority of the qualified electors voting on the proposition approves the new plan, it shall become effective as provided by law. If a majority of the qualified electors voting on the proposition fails to approve the new plan, the current plan remains in effect until a new plan is approved by the voters pursuant to this subsection. The governing body shall either resubmit the proposed new plan, or revise the new plan as provided by this section, for subsequent submission to the voters at the next regularly scheduled municipal election or at a special election scheduled at least one hundred twenty days after the governing body readopted the new or revised new plan. All subsequent adoptions and submissions of the new plan or revised plans must comply with the procedures prescribed by this section until the plan is ratified TC adoption at least 120 days prior to election Post ratification and implementation ARS 9-461.06. J. A copy of the adopted general plan of a municipality shall be sent to the planning agency of the county within which the municipality is located, and such plan or any portion of the plan may be adopted as a part of the county general plan. ARS 9-461.06. K. A general plan, with any amendments, is effective for up to ten years from the date the plan was initially adopted and ratified pursuant to subsection M of this section, or until the plan is readopted pursuant to this subsection and ratified pursuant to subsection M of this section or a new plan is adopted pursuant to this subsection and ratified pursuant to subsection M of this section, and becomes effective. On or before the tenth anniversary of the plan's most recent adoption, the governing body of the municipality shall either readopt the existing plan for an additional term of up to ten years or shall adopt a new general plan as provided by this article. ARS 9-461.06. L. Except for general plans that are required to be submitted to the voters for ratification pursuant to subsection M of this section, the adoption or readoption of a general plan, and any amendment to a general plan, shall not be enacted as an emergency measure and is subject to referendum as provided by article IV, part 1, section 1, subsection (8), Constitution of Arizona, and title 19, chapter 1, article 4. ARS 9-461.06. N. In applying an open space element or a growth element of a general plan a municipality shall not designate private land or state trust land as open space, recreation, conservation or agriculture unless the municipality receives the written consent of the landowner or provides an alternative, economically viable designation in the general plan or zoning ordinance, allowing at least one residential dwelling per acre. If the landowner is the prevailing party in any action brought to enforce this subsection, a court shall award fees and other expenses to the landowner. A municipality may designate land as open space without complying with the requirements of this subsection if the land was zoned as open space and used as a golf course pursuant to a zoning ordinance adopted pursuant to article 6.1 of this chapter before May 1, 2000 and the designation does not impose additional conditions, limitations or restrictions on the golf course, unless the land is state trust land that was not planned and zoned as open space pursuant to title 37, chapter 2, article 5.1 - Provide copy to county planning agency - Effective for 10 years from ratification State Law Link: https://www.azleg.gov/ars/9/00461-06.htm General Plan Elements – based on population • Oro Valley Population: 47,070 (2020 Census) • Projected 2026 Population (per Arizona Commerce Authority) : 49,748 Required elements State Law General guidance ARS 9-461.05. B. The general plan shall be so prepared that all or individual elements of the plan may be adopted by the governing body and that the plan may be made applicable to all or part of the territory of the municipality. ARS 9-461.05. C. The general plan shall consist of a statement of community goals and development policies. The plan shall include maps, any necessary diagrams and text setting forth objectives, principles, standards and plan proposals. ARS 9-461.05. H. The policies and strategies to be developed under these elements shall be designed to have community -wide applicability and this section does not authorize the imposition of dedications, exactions, fees or other requirements that are not otherwise authorized by law. Required elements for all jurisdictions 1. Land Use Element ARS 9-461.05. C.1 (a) Designates the proposed general distribution and location and extent of such uses of the land for housing, business, industry, agriculture, recreation, education, public buildings and grounds, open space and other categories of public and private uses of land as may be appropriate to the municipality. (b) Includes a statement of the standards of population density and building intensity recommended for the various land use categories covered by the plan. (c) Identifies specific programs and policies that the municipality may use to promote infill or compact form development activity and locations where those development patterns should be encouraged. (d) Includes consideration of air quality and access to incident solar energy for all general categories of land use. (e) Includes policies that address maintaining a broad variety of land uses, including the range of uses existing in the municipality when the plan is adopted, readopted or amended. (f) For cities and towns with territory in the vicinity of a military airport or ancillary military facility as defined in section 28-8461, includes consideration of military airport or ancillary military facility operations. If a city or town includes land in a high noise or accident potential zone as defined in section 28-8461, the city or town shall identify the boundaries of the high noise or accident potential zone in its general plan for purposes of planning land uses in the high noise or accident potential zone that are compatible with the operation o f the military airport or ancillary military facility pursuant to section 28-8481, subsection J. (g) Includes sources of aggregates from maps that are available from state agencies, information from the Arizona geological survey on how to locate existing mines, consideration of existing mining operations and suitable geologic resources, policies to preserve c urrently identified aggregates sufficient for future development and policies to avoid incompatible land uses, except that this subdivision shall not be construed to affect any permitted underground storage facility or limit any person's right to obtain a permit f or an underground storage facility pursuant to title 45, chapter 3.1. 2. Circulation Element ARS 9-461.06. C.2. A circulation element consisting of the general location and extent of existing and proposed freeways, arterial and collector streets, bicycle routes and any other modes of transportation as may be appropriate, all correlated with the land use element of the plan. Required elements for jurisdictions with 10,000 to 49,999 people 3. Open Space element ARS 9-461.06. D.1. (a) A comprehensive inventory of open space areas, recreational resources and designations of access points to open space areas and resources. (b) An analysis of forecasted needs, policies for managing and protecting open space areas and resources and implementation strategies to acquire additional open space areas and further establish recreational resources. (c) Policies and implementation strategies designed to promote a regional system of integrated open space and recreational resources and a consideration of any existing regional open space plans. 4. Growth area element ARS 9-461.05.D.2. A growth area element, specifically identifying those areas, if any, that are particularly suitable for planned multimodal tr ansportation and infrastructure expansion and improvements designed to support a planned concentration of a variety of uses, such as residential, office, commercial, tourism and industrial uses. This element shall include policies and implementation strategies that are designed to: (a) Make automobile, transit and other multimodal circulation more efficient, make infrastructure expansion more economical and provide for a rational pattern of land development. (b) Conserve significant natural resources and open space areas in the growth area and co ordinate their location to similar areas outside the growth area's boundaries. (c) Promote the public and private construction of timely and financially sound infrastructure expansion through the use of infrastructure funding and financing planning that is coordinated with development activity. 5. Environmental Planning element ARS 9-461.05. D.3 An environmental planning element that contains analyses, policies and strategies to address anticipated effects, if any, of plan elements on air quality, water quality and natural resources associated with proposed development under the general plan. The policies and strategies to be developed under this element shall be designed to have community-wide applicability and shall not require the production of an additional environmental impact statement or similar analysis beyond the requirements of state and federal law. 6. Cost of development element ARS 9-461.05. D.4. A cost of development element that identifies policies and strategies that the municipality will use to require development to pay its fair share toward the cost of additional public service needs generated by new development, with appropriate exceptions when in the public interest. This element shall include: (a) A component that identifies various mechanisms that are allowed by law and that can be used to fund and finance additional public services necessary to serve the development, including bonding, special taxing districts, development fees, in lieu fees, fac ility construction, dedications and service privatization. (b) A component that identifies policies to ensure that any mechanisms that are adopted by the municipality under this element result in a beneficial use to the development, bear a reasonable relationship to the burden imposed on the municipality to provide additional necessary public services to the development and otherwise are imposed according to law. 7. Water resources element ARS 9-461.05. D.5. A water resources element that addresses: (a) The known legally and physically available surface water, groundwater and effluent supplies. (b) The demand for water that will result from future growth projected in the general plan, added to existing uses. (c) An analysis of how the demand for water that will result from future growth projected in the general plan will be served by the water supplies identified in subdivision (a) of this paragraph or a plan to obtain additional necessary water supplies. ARS 9-461.05. G. The water resources element of the general plan does not require: 1. New independent hydrogeologic studies. 2. The city or town to be a water service provider. Required elements for jurisdictions with 50,000+ people 8. Conservation element ARS 9-461.05. E.1 A conservation element for the conservation, development and utilization of natural resources, including forests, soils, rivers and other waters, harbors, fisheries, wildlife, minerals and other natural resources. The conservation element may also cover: (a) The reclamation of land. (b) Flood control. (c) Prevention and control of the pollution of streams and other waters. (d) Regulation of the use of land in stream channels and other areas required for the accomplishment of the conservation plan. (e) Prevention, control and correction of the erosion of soils, beaches and shores. (f) Protection of watersheds. 9. Recreation element ARS 9-461.05. E.2 A recreation element showing a comprehensive system of areas and public sites for recreation, including the following and, if practicable, their locations and proposed development: (a) Natural reservations. (b) Parks. (c) Parkways and scenic drives. (d) Beaches. (e) Playgrounds and playfields. (f) Open space. (g) Bicycle routes. (h) Other recreation areas. 10. Additional circulation requirements ARS 9-461.05. E.3 The circulation element provided for in subsection C, paragraph 2 of this section shall also include for cities with a population of fifty thousand persons or more and may include for cities with a population of less than fifty thousand persons recommendations concerning parking facilities, building setback requirements and the delineations of such systems on the land, a system of street naming and house and building numbering and other matters as may be related to the improvement of circulation of traffic. The circulation element may also include: (a) A transportation element showing a comprehensive transportation system, including locations of rights-of-way, terminals, viaducts and grade separations. This element of the plan may also include port, harbor, aviation and related facilities. (b) A transit element showing a proposed system of rail or transit lines or other mode of transportation as may be appropriate. 11. Public services and facilities element ARS 9-461.05. E.4 A public services and facilities element showing general plans for police, fire, emergency services, sewage, refuse disposal, drainage, local utilities, rights-of-way, easements and facilities for them. 12. Public buildings element ARS 9-461.05. E.5 A public buildings element showing locations of civic and community centers, public schools, libraries, police and fire stations and other public buildings 13. Housing element ARS 9-461.05. E.6 A housing element consisting of standards and programs for the elimination of substandard dwelling conditions, for the improvement of housing quality, variety and affordability and for provision of adequate sites for housing. This element shall contain an ide ntification and analysis of existing and forecasted housing needs. This element shall be designed to make equal provision for the housing needs of all segments of the community regardless of race, color, creed or economic level. 14. Conservation, rehabilitation and redevelopment element ARS 9-461.05. E.7 A conservation, rehabilitation and redevelopment element consisting of plans and programs for: (a) The elimination of slums and blighted areas. (b) Community redevelopment, including housing sites, business and industrial sites and public building sites. (c) Other purposes authorized by law. 15. Safety element ARS 9-461.05. E.8 A safety element for the protection of the community from natural and artificial hazards, including features necessary for such protection as evacuation routes, peak load water supply requirements, minimum road widths according to function, clearances around structures and geologic hazard mapping in areas of known geologic hazards. 16. Bicycle element ARS 9-461.05. E.9 A bicycling element consisting of proposed bicycle facilities such as bicycle routes, bicycle parking areas and designated bicycle street crossing areas. 17. Energy element ARS 9-461.05. E.10 (a) A component that identifies policies that encourage and provide incentives for efficient use of energy. (b) An assessment that identifies policies and practices that provide for greater uses of renewable energy sources. 18. Neighborhood preservation and revitalization element ARS 9-461.05. E.11 A component that identifies city programs that promote home ownership, that provide assistance for improving the appearance of neighborhoods and that promote maintenance of both commercial and residential buildings in neighborhoods. (b) A component that identifies city programs that provide for the safety and security of neighborhoods. State law link: https://www.azleg.gov/ars/9/00461-05.htm