Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPackets - Council Packets (1921)2 Increasing the variance so that OVCN can add another 1500+ people to enter our neighborhood with three separate service times on Sunday is so overwhelming to the safety and planned burden our streets were meant to handle. Not only would it increase traffic on Sunday it would open the opportunity for any day of the week to see increased numbers of vehicle traffic. Beyond the traffic coming in we would incur unforeseen watershed issues that would occur in any of our properties that have washes running thru them due to the oversized buildings that are proposed. When it rains on those large roof structures during heavy rain periods, that water runs right to Shadow Mountain estates and Campo Bello. It would be devastating to us to incur that kind of watershed. Even with a plan proposed by the applicant during construction it could be disastrous to us. Our neighborhood of Campo Bello is horse property land, please consider the safety of our property owners and the horses. Pedestrians of course along with our children and pets have to be at the top of the list for safety concerns with any additional increase traffic burden that would most definitely occur if approved. Lastly, lets address the OVPath Forward survey and the voice of the people that took the time to answer what is important to the citizens living in our community. Citizens clearly stated they do not want blocking of our mountain views. Citizens do not want more increased traffic or traffic lights. Citizens do not want unsafe roads due to heavy traffic. Reversing the decision on the height variance request would go against what you as the Town of Oro Valley asked your citizens. Please deny request. Jerry and Joanne Michaelsen Joanne Michaelsen 2 The Town Council has an opportunity to preserve this historic area of Oro Valley and we are asking that you reject any and all expansion of the OVCN. Thank you for your time and consideration. Charles & Trindy LeForge 2 At OVCN, we believe church isn’t just a place to go—it’s a community that meets you right where you are. ENGAGE – We meet people where they are, no matter their story or background, by investing in real relationships and inviting them into the hope of Jesus through baptism and church membership. EQUIP – We equip passionate followers of Jesus through worship, small groups, and authentic community. Together, we grow in faith, encourage one another, and follow the discipleship model Jesus gave us. EMPOWER – We empower followers to impact the world through local and global missions. Whether in our neighborhood or across the globe, we share the love of Jesus by meeting both spiritual and practical needs. At OVCN, you belong. Let’s make an impact together! Their actions are not consistent with meeting the needs of their community. Here is a sampling of what they have been doing in their own neighborhood: Photos of a known church member destroying a C/BV Group pink sign -Audio from a sermon… “Are we going to know that victory is ours and we’re taking it all” “I think I’ve told you before, I want to cause some problems” -Professional sound recordings with excessive decibel readings -Parking violations on Calle Concordia during events 2 years of false claims of an agreement with Amphi School District for a bridge to their parking lot for overflow parking. Amphi confirmed no agreement, i.e. THE CHURCH LIED! -Founding member promised a greenbelt of separation – did not happen -No meaningful dialogue with neighbors i.e. “This is what we are going to do” 3 -Letters to neighbors with misspelled names (repeatedly) Sending more letters saying “you did not respond” when in fact several of the C/BV Group had attended said previous meeting in the office at OVCN -Multiple instances of vandalism, theft, trespassing and destruction of property with police reports filed So at the end of the day, we all know that this expansion and the relationship of the church with for- profit organizations like Fellowship of Christian Athletes is not at all about values, but about economic growth. As such, we implore you to not approve any rezoning of the property or other plans for expansion. Their interaction with their own community in the Calle Concordia/Buena Vista corridor is completely contrary to their Christian values. We support the Planning & Zoning Commission's rejection of the OVCN height request and hope that you do not reverse their decision The Berman Family 2 Location, as has been stated multiple times over the last 5 years, matters and dovetails with compatibility. The proposed facility is not compatible with the rural residential neighborhood for a multitude of reason which have also been stated over the past years. The building height request is just one aspect of the total project that will impact the neighborhood and the town. I support the P/Z Commission's rejection of the OVCN height request and hope that you will not reverse their decision. Thank you, Doug Dalby 1 Packer, Kyle From:Anne Britt <> Sent:Tuesday, February 18, 2025 12:16 PM To:Town Council Subject:OVCN WARNING: External Sender. Read Carefully. Report phishing. I live on Calle Buena Vista and I have followed the developing plans for the church. The area where the hur h is located is surrounded by suburban ranch properƟes and others which are over one acre. The church has grown substanƟally over the years. Originally a neighborhood church, it is now so big that any addiƟons to the property will be so big and affect those homes in the neighborhood causing increased traffic and obstrucƟng views of the mountains if the 40 foot building is permiƩed. The pastor has been portraying the neighbors who are objecƟng to their plans as “the enemy” and that we are going against God’s will. These statements do not seem very ChrisƟan. Please carefully consider what these plans will do to our neighborhood. 3,000 is the projected membership for the church if this project is approved. Sincerely, Anne BriƩ Oro Valley. Sent from my iPad 1 Packer, Kyle From:Karen Riker Harned <> Sent:Tuesday, February 18, 2025 11:26 AM To:Town Council Subject:Ovcn height request WARNING: External Sender. Read Carefully. Report phishing. Dear Oro Valley Town Council, I , Karen Riker Harned , have lived at since 1979 when height limits were closer to 16 feet to protect the wonderful views. I support the Planning and Zoning Commission’s RejecƟon of the Ovcn height request! I ask you to please honor that rejecƟon and do the same! Thank you so much for your hard work ! Sincerely, Karen Riker Harned Sent from my iPhone 2 2 community for over 30 years, spanning multiple generations of my family, I stand in strong opposition to this request and respectfully urge you to uphold the unanimous rejection of the proposal by the Oro Valley Planning & Zoning Commission. My family, along with many others in this neighborhood, have deep roots in the community. We have lived here for decades, finding peace in its natural beauty, historical significance, and the sense of belonging it offers. This neighborhood is not just a place to live—it is a sanctuary that has enriched our lives and those of countless others who have called it home. Many residents hope to remain here for years to come, preserving the integrity and character of the area that makes it so special. While we recognize and respect the need for growth in Oro Valley, we firmly believe that the request for a height variance represents a turning point that could irreparably harm the neighborhood we cherish. This variance is not just a matter of height; it is part of a broader, more concerning plan for the church's expansion. It is a request that masks the true intentions of an ongoing, unreasonable growth agenda that will alter the very fabric of our community. The proposed height increase, which the church has indicated will facilitate an increase in sanctuary capacity, is far more than a simple architectural change. It is directly tied to an inevitable rise in the number of people, traffic, noise, and most concerning of all, safety risks. As a parent, I am deeply invested in ensuring that our neighborhood remains safe for all residents, and I cannot, in good conscience, support a decision that may compromise the safety of our children, families, and elders. The potential increase in traffic and congestion will significantly exacerbate these risks, making the area less secure for everyone. Granting this variance would set a precedent for further growth and changes that cannot be undone. OVCN has made it clear that they have plans for continued expansion. Each step of this process will only bring more disruption and strain to the community, and we will be left with consequences that cannot be reversed. Our neighborhood would no longer resemble the peaceful, welcoming place that we have worked so hard to preserve for generations. I urge you to consider the long-term impact that approving this request would have on the safety and quality of life for all of us. We ask that you protect the integrity of this special place that we call home and safeguard the well-being of the families who have lived here for so long. Thank you for your time and thoughtful consideration of our concerns. I trust that you will make a decision that reflects the values of our community and upholds the best interests of all Oro Valley residents. Sincerely, Devin Smith 1 Packer, Kyle From:M Belford <> Sent:Monday, February 17, 2025 3:53 PM To:Town Council Subject:No to OVCN WARNING: External Sender. Read Carefully. Report phishing. Please conƟnue to listen the neighbors and residence of Oro Valley. The Oro Valley Church of the Nazarene is in a locaƟon that’s not compaƟble for the number of people they want going in and out. It’s a safety issue. The roads are being damaged by it. Also when they expand the parking lot, increasing the hard surface, the flooding issues will increase for residences on the south and Southwest side. Please prevent further damage to this area on Calla Concordia and Buena Vista. Thank you, Mary Belford 85737 Sent from my iPhone 1 Packer, Kyle From:John Peard Sent:Monday, February 17, 2025 3:29 PM To:Town Council Subject:OVCN WARNING: External Sender. Read Carefully. Report phishing. Thanks for reading this e mail. Please please do not approve the request to expand the church. I have lived in Show Mountain Estates for 37 years in perfect bliss. We have enjoyed the peaceful seƫng of the neighborhood. I do not want this to be spoiled. Thanks so much for your help and support. John Peard. Sent from my iPhone 1 Packer, Kyle From:Diane Dalby <> Sent:Monday, February 17, 2025 2:57 PM To:Town Council Subject:OVCN WARNING: External Sender. Read Carefully. Report phishing. My husband and I are very happy with the Planning and Zoning’s rejecƟon of OVCN’s height request. The Church does not believe they need to play by the same rules the rest of us follow. Several neighbors have been denied height requests. Rules were intact before they started this journey. This is NOT the neighborhood for their plans. Diane Dalby Calle Buena Vista Sent from my iPhone ӝӞӟӠӡӢ ׆ׇ 1 Packer, Kyle From:elizabeth packard Sent:Monday, February 17, 2025 2:49 PM To:Town Council Subject:OVCN activities WARNING: External Sender. Read Carefully. Report phishing. Sent from my iPhone To the members of the Oro Valley town council: I do not live in the neighborhood of the OV Church of the Nazarene but my daughter, her husband and two young children live on Calle Concordia near the cross street of Buena Vista and I’m aware of the concerns of those in that neighborhood. When I visit my family on Sundays the traffic is very heavy and the parking on Calle Concordia and Buena Vista is dense. One expects to have those situaƟons near a large church on a Sunday, but the proposal to build a high capacity gym which would be used at Ɵmes other than Sunday is a burden of traffic, parking, intrusive sound and lighƟng mounted on large poles is a burden that neighborhood should not have to contend with. Residents purchased their homes in that rural area, many with horse properƟes and a country ambiance knowing that churches will have services on Sunday but were not expecƟng the sort of development that the OVCN has proposed. As a frequent visitor to that neighborhood and as a resident of Oro Valley I would like to know that the OV town council will support the neighborhood’s concerns and that we in other neighborhoods would also be protected from the incursions of a business, a church or other organizaƟon that might plan to expand leading to similar serious concerns. A number of my neighbors in OV also signed the peƟƟon as they could relate to the concerns of the neighbors of OVCN and would expect that the town council would support their desire to protect their homes and property also. I support the Planning & Zoning Commission’s rejecƟon of the OVCN height request and hope that you do not reverse that decision. Elizabeth Packard 1 Packer, Kyle From:Kevin O'Neil <> Sent:Monday, February 17, 2025 2:39 PM To:Town Council Cc:Aussie Falcon Subject:Upholding the Planning & Zoning Commission’s Decision on OVCN Height Request WARNING: External Sender. Read Carefully. Report phishing. Dear Members of the Oro Valley Town Council, I am wriƟng to strongly urge you to uphold the unanimous decision of the Planning & Zoning Commission in rejecƟng the Oro Valley Church of the Nazarene’s (OVCN) height request. We support the Planning & Zoning Commission’s rejecƟon of the OVCN height request and hope that you do not reverse their decision. This appeal is just the latest in a long string of aƩempts by OVCN to sneakily circumvent zoning regulaƟons and force through an expansion that the community has repeatedly pushed back against. Over the years, the church has used myriad tacƟcs to steadily increase its footprint, frustraƟng reƟred homeowners who have invested their life savings in their properƟes and moved here expecƟng stability, not a never-ending baƩle against an insƟtuƟon that refuses to respect its surroundings. Their persistence in pursuing outsized development has also wasted the Ɵme and bandwidth of the Planning & Zoning Commission and the Town Council, forcing them to repeatedly address the same core issue: the church’s unwillingness to work within the established rules that apply to everyone else. Adding insult to injury, Pastor Coulter has acƟvely fostered division by referring to concerned neighbors as “enemies” in his sermons. It is both disturbing and deeply inappropriate for a religious leader to demonize residents who simply want to protect their homes, quality of life, and community standards. Labeling people as adversaries for advocaƟng fair zoning regulaƟons contradicts the very principles of goodwill and respect that OVCN claims to uphold. The unanimous 7-0 vote by the Planning & Zoning Commission was a clear message: this proposal is not in the best interest of Oro Valley residents. The Town Council now has an opportunity to reinforce that message by rejecƟng OVCN’s appeal. Doing so will demonstrate a commitment to transparency, responsible development, and the protecƟon of residents from an organizaƟon that has shown liƩle regard for the very community it claims to serve. Thank you for your Ɵme and consideraƟon. I trust you will stand with the residents of Oro Valley in preserving the integrity of our neighborhoods. Sincerely, Kevin & Stephanie O’Neil 1 Packer, Kyle From:Nancy Beaufait <> Sent:Monday, February 17, 2025 1:00 PM To:Town Council Subject:OVCN height variance WARNING: External Sender. Read Carefully. Report phishing. We support the Planning and Zoning Commission’s rejecƟon of the OVCN height variance request and hope you do not reverse their decision. Nancy and Richard Beaufait 2 Fe structure which was proportional to its surroundings, single family homes on 1 to 5 acres. I heard no complaints from the neighbors then, many of whom still live in the neighborhood. The proposed latest expansion of the church, however, to include a 75 ,000 square foot building with a requested 40 foot building height on part of it has garnered nearly 100 percent objection from all those who would be the most directly impacted. I had occasion to attend a meeting several months ago at OVCN, during which Pastor Coulter was pitching this new expansion project to members of his congregation. He was attempting to get the attendees enthused about his goal to raise $45,000,000 for the project. The pastor explained that the church, which started out with a membership of 500 people, has now expanded to 1,500, but that's just the beginning. Within the next few years, he said, the congregation will expand to 3,500. The new, larger congre gation will be accommodated by holding 3 services each Sunday with 1,500 people attending each one of them. Before the Town Council at this time is an appeal of a request to raise the building height to 40 feet, which was unanimously denied by the P&Z Commission. To the neighbors, the increased building height, which will certainly obstruct viewsheds, is great cause for concern, but there are other even larger concerns, which the neighbors have been registering since the church began the Oro Valley process to accomplish its objectives. Those concerns include, but are not limited to, excessive traffic, inadequate parking, loss of viewsheds, noise and the impacts on the environment. We respectfully request that the Council take up these issues now and assure that, in all respects (no variances), the Town's codes are met to the letter. Further, I request that the Town Council members carefully review the Land Use Code as it pertains to a project's compatibility with its surroundings. An interpretation that a further expansion of OVCN would be compatible with the neighborhood would be a mistake, in my opinion. OVCN has made no secret that, in addition to this latest plan, there are further plans to expand on its own property and to take over other adjacent properties as well. It is time to stop the OVCN spread and preserve one of the last remaining low density neighborhoods in Oro Valley which includes Linda Vista Citrus Tracts, Campo Bello and Shadow Mountain Estates. Thank you. Linda Frew, 1 Packer, Kyle From:Jeremy Stein Sent:Wednesday, February 19, 2025 9:25 AM To:Town Council Subject:OVCN initiative WARNING: External Sender. Read Carefully. Report phishing. Town Council members, As a resident near the OVCN I plead with you to support the Planning and Zoning Commission’s rejecƟon of the OVCN height request and hope that you do not reverse their decision. The area is already congested with people parking on the side streets causing a safety concern for everyone. The blatant disregard the church has shown for the concerns of their neighbors is disturbing and only worries me more for the future. Thank you for your Ɵme! Jeremy Stein 2 Lastly, I am concerned about the impact on property values in the surrounding area. A large-scale addition will alter the aesthetics of the neighborhood and make nearby homes less desirable to prospective buyers. I urge the Oro Valley City Council to support the Planning and Zoning Commission's rejection of the OVCN height request and hope that you do not reserve their decision. Thank you for your time and consideration. Sincerely, Ken and Amy McGlamery Amy L. McGlamery