Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutOV139328 2970423 ORO VALLEY TC IALL F-647 T-462 P-002, AUG 17 '93 16:38 TOWN OF ORO VALLEY APPLICATION FOR PERMANENT SIGN MODIFICATION DATE: August 19, 1993 OV CASE NO. : C.. 13-ci'" ' Z$' (office use only) PROJECT NAME: GREAT AMERICAN BANK PROPOSED SIGN LOCATION: 10661 NORTH ORACLE ROAD SPECIFIC MODIFICATION TO ARTICLE 12--5 OF THE ORO VALLEY ZONING CODE REQUESTED 65 sq. ft. SIZE SIZE REQUESTED: TWO 30 SQ. FT. WALL SIGNS ONE 5 SQ. FT. ATM SIGN IRON LOCATIONREQUESTED: SIGN #1 AND 2 ON THE EAST ELEVATION SIGN #3 ON THE NORTH ELEVATION OTHER liDDIFICATIaN North elevation is allowed 172 sq.ft. of sign area- Fry's is 120 sq.ft. as permitted. Requesting 30 sq.ft. more for a total of 150 sq.ft. (22 sq.ft. shy of what is allowed by Code. ) Signs on the east elevation comes to 35 sq.ft. Total for Fry's is 356 sq.ft. plus the Bank's sq.ft. comes to 391 sq.ft. where 487.5 sq.ft. is allowed by Code. APPLICANT: BOOTZ & DUKE SIGN CO. _ ADDRESS: 4028 W. WHITTON AVE - PHOENIX PHONE NO. : 272-9356 PROP CWNER: FRY'S FOOD STORES ADDRESS: P.O. BOX 6016 PHONE NO. : 352-7585 REQUIRED APPLICATION FEE - $150.00 PAID 2.� C13 IJo C •CX�► (date) SICINATUPE: DATE: APPLICATION MUST BE RECEIVED 30 CALENDAR DAYS IN ADVANCE OF THE DEVELOPMENT REVIEW BOARD MEETING DATE. NOTE: A certified list of all property owners within 300 feet, made within 60 da s of submittal, trust be supplied at the time of application along with 10 ...ies each of the site plan and sketch plan for the proposed sign. At the meting, a colored rendering of the sign must be presented for review. 6V t3- q'S- 2.g' BOOTZ j &DUKE SINCE 1964 E5,1k!0,464! GREAT AMERICAN BANK SIGN SPECIFICATIONS - ORO VALLEY AUGUST 24, 1993 EAST ELEVATION - SEE DRAWINGS 1 , 2, 3, and 4: 1 - Set of 16" capital letters ( lower case letters to be proportionate ) to read "Great American Bank" . The letters are to be reverse pan channel , patina treated copper which will be backlit. Illumination shall be white, 15 mil , 30 mili-amp neon, PK housings through the wall . All neon to have weather proof PK boots. 1 - 18" logo located on both the east and north exterior elevations, shall consist of a backlit patina copper rectangular "Rim" ( 12 inch width) around the freeform "Gulls" to delineate the shape of the Logo with backlit patina copper "Gulls" in the middle. The Gulls will have the same portions as originally specified. The space between the Rim and Gulls will be open and will actually be the wall surface. 1 - 13" tall x 5 ' long x 8" deep metal sign cabinet mounted above the ATM at 84" A.F.F. The front removable plex panel shall be ivory with vinyl network symbols indicating VISA, CIRRUS, MASTERCARD, and STAR SYSTEM. A removable bottom panel shall be white plex to allow light from the sign cabinet to illuminate the ATM. The metal shall be 22 gauge and reinforced as necessary to avoid warpage, etc. The sign cabinet shall be painted to match the building. Illumination shall be one F60T12CW/HO fluorescent lamp. Bootz & Duke Sign Co. 4028 West Whitton Ave. s Phoenix, Arizona 85019 Phone (602) 272-9356 Serving Arizona Since 1964 Fax (602) 272-4608 Great American Bank Sign Specifications - Oro Valley August 24, 1993 Page 2 NORTH ELEVATION - SEE DRAWINGS 5 and 6: Same as East Elevation except for the deletion of the ATM sign cabinet. NOTE: LOGO, Great American Bank at either elevation is not to exceed 40 square feet, per the City of Oro Valley. All exterior signage to be approved by the City of Oro Valley prior to fabrication. The sign contractor shall provide all electrical service for the three exterior signs from the Bank ' s electrical panel . The electrical run for the East Elevation is 44 feet while the run for the North Elevation is 70 feet. The sign contractor is also to supply, install , hook-up, set, and label an Intermatic SPST (or equivalent) time clock to be mounted next to the Bank' s electrical panel . NOTICE OF HEARING ORO VALLEY DEVELOPMENT REVIEW BOARD In accordance with Section 12-206 of the Oro Valley Zoning Code Revised, notice is hereby given that a hearing will be held on a request for a modification to the Oro Valley Sign Code Regulations. RE • OV13-93-28 Great American Bank Request for Modification to the Oro Valley Sign Code With Respect to Color Southwest Corner of Oracle Road and North First Avenue The applicant requests approval of a modification to the Oro Valley Sign Code to permit a multi-colored sign above the bank's outside banking machine to be located on the east facade of the new Fry's Grocery Store. The Oro Valley Sign Code restricts colors to brawn, beige, sand, and rust, and in accordance with the Oracle Road Center PAD, black and white are also permitted. DATE • Tuesday, September 14, 1993 PLACE • Oro Valley Town Hall 11000 N. La Canada Drive Members of the public are invited to attend this meeting and will be given an opportunity to speak. REQ Steve Hagedorn PUB: The Daily Territorial Planning and Zoning Director September 8 , 1993 AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLIC/ \I STATE OF ARIZONA) :ss. COUNTY OF PIMA f.....:'t l,.�'t t{i. 0 l c.i 11 I I"i being first NOTICE OF HEARING duly sworn, deposes and says that (he) (she) is the Legal Advertising Manager ORO VALLEY DEVELOPMENT REVIEW BOARD In accordance with Section 12-206 of the oro Valley Zoning �`� �'' of THE DAILY TERRITORIAL, a daily newspaper printed and published in the Code Revised, notice is hereby V given that a hearing will be held on a request for a modification to,♦"1`� �`�� the Oro Valley Sign Code Reg- . A% County of Pima, State of Arizona, and of general circulation in the City of Tucson, Rations. 43 0cS) RE Amen-OV13-93-28 Great Ame - can Bank Request for Modifica- tion to the Oro Valley Sign Code County of Pima, State of Arizona and elsewhere, and the hereto attached With Respect to Color Southwest Corner of Oracle Road and North First Avenue The applicant requests approval of a modification to the Oro Val- ley Sign Code to permit a multi- colored sign above the bank's !DV:1 :3_. i3." jy:` outside banking machine to be '"" located on the east facade of the new Fry's Grocery Store. The Oro Valley Sign Code restricts colors to brown,beige,sand,and rust, and in accordance with the Oracle Road Center PAD, black and white are also permitted. DATE : Tuesday, September 14,1993 was printed and published correctly in the regular and entire issue of said THE PLACE : Oro Valley Town Hall 11000 N. La Canada Drive Members of the public are invited to attend this meeting and will be DAILY TERRITORIAL for :l issues; that the first was made given an opportunity to speak. Steve Hagedorn Steve Hagedorn Planning and Zoning Director Pub: The Daily Territorial on the day of Sc'p' C'Ill b Ct l'' 19. September 8, 1993 Reg: Town of Oro Valley pngreat 9l8/93 as and the last publication thereof was made on the ' '�''` day of Se F,t e'ml-;e,l: 1 ;that said publication was made on each of the following dates,to-wit: Request of TOWN CIF' 1."I l: I:::l t1 A L..L._I- Dail Territorial By Subscribed an worn to before me this ' -I day of "S�'prr�l' l- 19 Notary Public in and for the County of Pima,State of Arizona My Commission Expires: 2_ I l tz. �� 1 L QC) o�PLEY A19/<, o n ORO VALLEY PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT II 44 4:4 ��f;; DEVELOPMENT REVIEW BOARD % DED MEETING DATE: September 14, 1993 TO: DEVELOPMENT REVIEW BOARD FROM: Linda Frew, Planner I SUBJECT: OV13-93-28 GREAT AMERICAN BANK REQUEST FOR MODIFICATION TO ORO VALLEY SIGN CODES WITH RESPECT TO COLOR AND TYPE OF ILLUMINATION (Fry's) AND GREAT AMERICAN BANK REQUEST FOR APPROVAL OF TWO NEW PERMANENT WALL SIGNS TO BE LOCATED ON THE EAST AND NORTH FACADES OF FRY'S ITEM NO. 1. - Request for Modification of Code with Respect to Color and Type of Illumination Great American Bank plans to have a banking machine located along the east facade of the Fry's store. On behalf of the applicant, Bootz and Duke Sign Company has presented a proposal to install an internally illuminated cabinet-type sign over the teller machine, approximately 5 square feet in size. This sign is to include the logos, in multi-colors, of the banking cards which will be accepted at this machine. The colors, as depicted on a colored sketch of the sign which will be displayed at the meeting, include red, gold, and blue, etc. on a white background. The applicant maintains that, in addition to displaying information as to the cards honored at this machine, the internally illuminated sign is also required for security purposes. This sign will require the DRB's approval of two modifications: 1. While internal illumination is permitted under the Rooney Ranch PAD sign guidelines, such illumination is restricted to only "individual can letters with translucent sides or faces". The use of internally illuminated cabinet type signs, such as the one proposed, is expressly prohibited. 2. The PAD document permits any color specified in the Oro Valley Sign Code (beige, brown, sand and rust) plus black and white. The proposed sign includes non- conforming colors, such as red, blue, gold, etc. This item has been scheduled for public hearing this evening. f:\data\wp\ovcases\13-93-28\banksign.rpt Recommendation: Staff recognizes the need for lighting at this location as it is vital to provide safety and security to the patrons of the ATM. However,we feel this can be provided for adequately through some other means. With regard to the proposed colors of the sign, it should be noted that a consistent sign theme is required throughout any commercial project (Sec. 12-406). The approval of the patina copper, halo-illuminated Fry's signs some time ago"locked in"the theme for this entire commercial complex. The proposed sign over the teller machine is clearly inconsistent with that theme. ITEM NO. 2 Request for Approval of Two Permanent Wall Signs The business identification signs proposed by Great American for the east and north facades of the Fry's building conform to the Oro Valley Sign Code and to the Oracle Road Center PAD sign guidelines. The signs, like the Fry's signs to appear on the same walls, will be of patina copper finish with halo illumination. Each sign is approximately 25.5 square feet in size, well within the size limitations prescribed by the Oro Valley Sign Code. The sign package for the Fry's wall signs, which was originally denied by the DRB, was approved by the Council upon appeal of the DRB decision on March 17, 1993. The sign package presented on that date included a depiction of a "bank" sign, and the entire package was conceptually approved at that time. The sign package presented this evening by the user, Great American Bank, conforms to the concept plan approved in March and serves to formalize that signage for the specific user. Recommendation: Since the two proposed bank signs conform to the Oro Valley Sign Code, the Oracle Road Center PAD and meet the standard for consistency of design throughout the complex, Staff would support approval of Item No. 2, Great American's request for approval of two permanent wall signs to be erected on the Fry's store walls, as submitted. Attachments: 1. Letter of explanation from Bootz & Duke Sign Co. (8-24-93) 2. Sketch of proposed sign to be located over the teller machine 3. Sketches of the wall signs proposed for north and east faces of Fry's 4. Excerpt from Oro Valley Zoning Code Revised, Secs. 12-402 and 12-406 5. Excerpt from Oracle Road Center PAD - sign guidelines -Excerpt from -Coufici1-minutes-of'3=t7-93 f:\data\wp\ovcases\13-93-28\banksign.rpt 2 SUP — 1 O — 9 3 W E L 1 - 1 E. D O O T Z g. DUKE SIGN CO - P _ 0 1 OVIS c L3Q0TZ &DUKE Ilihs.t NO. EFOA*40.44 FAX (602 272--4608 Statewide Sales & Service —free estimates — DATE: "7 BILL GIB SON 4028 W.Whitton Ave. SQ Phoenix, AZ 85019 Sates Manager Phone 272-9356 TIME: TRANSMITTING TO: 572 ' FAX NUMBER: a7 ; fl7, 4 PROM: AVA&,,,/ NUMBER OF PAGES INCLUDING THIS PAGE: .q SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS: M /57e, -r,9f 0 euver5#7.7ep/ei Ae-ee, a.ree, /7eiv iv /7" 7-22 77/1 ' 6,,e#0 ,effiefez. we.„/ffr__:e_:,..„/Aep2,_7IE_.<_,-, '70,r 777e ge.,*42Aveer" degr69.40S 70.4e4e..y3p-6,0 09,42‘ez, eft' lc ..^ "% i r Atre,"/l zore, 040 .#,47 ., /49/18 1/0611/10e" e J i Bootz & Duke Sign Co. • 4028 West Whitton Ave. • Phoenix, Arizona 85019 • Phone (602) 272-9356 Serving Arizona Since 1964 Fax (602) 272-4608 SUP - 1 — '33 WED 1 : 1 6. DIDOTZ & DUKE SIGH CO _ P _ 0 r ` r 10 20; ' ' , a u D Otl. II 11 lip , i ' ...iii , fl... it Eli,. II I V, • 'i. Nie ti.,-.-' :•.). L:43" • c;., , c 105 4„, A III ! Il s 4 . 1 •1 i it : �:- . III II ems' T` tf~wiia' t71riI HI tit' , ?oil ii.,.,: :' 4ii.;•. ii , , • II 1 ,i li : : I to, .: : : jilt , . . ii t .N vivo ir. I If i• 1 f i , • M f ; ,, 'g . 111 ,: " 14 . N I i 1 /y . 1 , .. .. , , . 1 I w 1 1., 11E•i, , . , Iii, . , , I. 1 N •W, i ' il ''' II 1' 1 l ".1:I' 1 1 '.!1 1 I r ,, I , . ,1'1 �I , I , i t ' I./ ill ' Ilin ill I i ii; • i1111111 I� ' n Pt, I I � �� 'fi Pr.VliatP.A.' i 1:11111 • i i II rj •� I ..rig n !rill , r... .:. '1 — — *e as kW K `J iL3.3i - FAT@ FOOD A {MI/ ....._ Aitli17--LTr ---,.._i E i nt------t- ----, --, , , ; 1 , _ 1a c„ _ , E yL" Po pm, Co P gm -Nord a rs.w r. - - b -N oTr: lifts 6(tic. Til 5( LA. V NErit4 14- J 49 1 rf+k-v It.zvH, ta OW v t.t_ a Loo : L;)E .L' ... t 4 F, D D) F 0 0 .. D) 0 i: Libc, N gi -1---_ - W 9 k SI elt4 ® 1211 .r--El FE 1 v „ _, . . _ _____ ......_ 7C .. a FRY S FOOD 8, DD, ,G .,,.. _o_Om American Bank LI / _ a i ;4 ....... P 1 c :_ . 1 __ / _ T1,, ImItGreatAmerican Bank/ -te° . / t MERRY* / I t Eg N ate': P7= a 5 OPEN SIGNS ARTICLE 12-4 - PEOUTPEMENTS Sec. 12-401 Design and Construction A. Building Code All signs shall be designed and constructed in conformity with the Building Codes of the Town of Oro Valley or, in the absence in the Town's Code of a provision for some specific or peculiar design requirement, then with the provisions of Chapter 4 of the late t eri i tion of the Uniform Sign Code published by the International Conference of Building Officials, ICBO. In the event there is a conflict between the Zbwn's and ICBO's Codes, the provisions of the Town shall prevail. B. Permanent Sign Mat-Prials All permanent signs shall be constructed using structural members of materials subject to approval of the Zoning Administrator and/or Tbwn Engineer. Non-structural trim may be of wood, metal, approved plastics or any combination thereof. C. Materials for Temporary Signs Materials proposed to be used in constructing temporary signs shall be at the discretion of the fabricator but shall be stated in the application for the Sign Permit. Adequacy of the materials proposed from the standpoints of stability and safety and of composition and color shall be subject to approval by the Zoning Administrator and/or Town Engineer. Sec. 12-402 Lighting and Movement Illumination 1. Signs may be illuminated or non-illuminated. 2. All illumination, with the exception of illumination of traffic directional signs as defined in Sec. 12-501F, shall be reverse pan channel illumination, which gives a halo effect. (Rev. 2/93) 3. Traffic directional signs may be lighted internally or by indirect lighting. B. Prohibited Lighting The following types/sources of light are prohibited as a means to illuminate or attract attention to any sign or means: 1. Exposed neon or similar tube-type light sources. 2. Open light bulbs. Rev. (0)93-3, 2/17/93 12-14 REQUITER IS B. Inspection Markings 1. All signs shall be marked with the permit number. This marking shall be permanently placed by the fabricator of the sign. The permit number shall be assigned and recorded on the permit at the time the permit is issued. The permit number shall be shown on the face of the sign preferably in the lower right-hand corner and shall be in number between 2 and 1/2 and 4 inches high. C. Maintenance Each sign shall be so maintained at all times as to constitute neither danger nor hazard to public safety nor an eyesore. Sec. 12-406 Sign Colors and Logos (Rev. 2/93) A. The following desert tone colors shall be required for all permanent and temporary signage: brown, beige, sand or rust. (unpainted metal letters and symbols, i.e. brass, bronze, copper, steel and brushed aluminum may also be used. These metA1 s may have an oxidized (patina) finish. B. Sign colors for permanent signs shall utilize complementary and consistent color schemes subject to approval by the Development Review Board. Earth tone colors are required. C. Temporary signs shall utilize earth tone colors subject to approval by the Planning and Zoning Director. D. A logo shall be considered as a sign, or part of a sign, and shall conform to all of the development s of permanent and temporary signs. E. The same color shall be used for all signs within a complex or development. F. A variance to this section shall be subject to Development Review Board approval after a duly noticed public hearing, in accordance with Sec. 12-206B. • Rev. (0)93-3, 2/17/93 12-16 Tsgm-r sscs:.? 1 ..5k1,4) z-ihs 1 LEY qA ORO VALLEY PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT Sfo V//' ; : DEVELOPMENT REVIEW BOARD °UNDED a� MEETING DATE: October 12, 1993 TO: DEVELOPMENT REVIEW BOARD FROM: Linda Frew, Planner I SUBJECT: OV13-93-28 Great American Bank Permanent Signs for Fry's Grocery Store Wall Sign and Automatic Teller Machine (ATM) Sign Wall Signs At the September 14th DRB meeting, the DRB approved a sign package for Great American Bank's permanent walls signs, as submitted. That submittal showed the location of the Great American Bank sign for the 1st Avenue side of the building being placed directly below the Fry's sign. At that September 14th meeting, Mr Bill Gibson of Bootz and Duke Sign Company requested that this 1st Avenue sign be relocated "in-line" with the Fry's Sign on that wall due to technical mounting problems with locating it below the Fry's sign. The DRB was reluctant to approve this relocation without first having staff review the original Council minutes from the meeting that the Fry's Signs were approved to verify if this relocation would be in harmony with that approval. Staff has since researched this issue (see attached Council Minutes from 3/17/93) and find that the only issues that the Council focused on at that meeting were sign material (copper letters), sign color (all sign to be patina copper finish), lighting (all sings to use "halo" backlit illumination) and letter size (Fry's sign limited to 4" tall letters on Oracle Road facing wall and 3' tall letters on the N. 1st Avenue facing wall, all secondary signage limited to 2' tall letters). This proposed Great American bank signage meets all of these criteria. It is staffs opinion that the location of the bank sign on the N. 1st Avenue facing wall was not material to the original Council approval provided all of the other conditions of their approval are met. Staff recommends approval of the relocation of the Great American Bank sign to an "in-line" configuration with the Fry's sign on the N. 1st Avenue facing wall. ATM Sign The DRB denied a request for modification to the Oro Valley Sign Code with respect to a sign which was proposed for placement over the ATM machine on the east facade of Fry's. The requests to modify the colors and the type of illumination proposed for the box-type sign were denied. The Bootz and Duke Sign Company has now resubmitted a plan for this sign. Mr. Gibson proposes that it be approximately 5 square feet in size and, while the sign is still a "box", it will be non-illuminated. As to the colors proposed, the background of the sign will match the stucco color of the building and the credit card logos will be in black and white only (the Oro Valley Center PAD permits black and white). It should be noted that security lighting will still be required at the ATM location,but saic mina will have no connection w____ _le sig was originally proposed. The revised plan for the ATM sign conforms with the Oro Valley Center PAD, however it is still in conflict with Section 12-406 E of the Oro Valley Sign Code which requires that all signs within a complex be the same color. As such, staff recommends denial. Attachments: 1. Revised drawing of Great American wall sign 2. Revised drawing of ATM sign 3. Town Council Minutes, 3/17/93 13-93-28\psdrb2.rpt \�.am.. \ r n � LIQUOR MT@ GOOD PEU@/ \ \ i i I I r.- - ran r ii 1 ( r ii &1S` &LE W /OA/ yZ" 4T,N4 co PP01--fe I►k\ - N EDN IAA{-v /c-[.v im,T-- (--;____ , On i s t t,-- To s(14 Fac Nvr, 0 • gA-cr6e0o/vo L,rE F-r►^ 13ogfAT %t onic€-_-4ULL t' 67_O ,,,, --------....\"............. Na/V N r4L-C) it.t_v VI, , 0 1 OP at TO 1A14-44 ^nT r 0 -- \ i O . /L- ,2,,,o 4 I _ HAW P 0 -1---- } } 0 ._.../) —I Y'.'. [ n 1 li svAN O )20 ..----------> — --- EE EH ET! I • -0 R-47'@ F Q©D a DMA , v_ Great American Bank . ------- / • il , / ../ 1 - -i _....- / \ f.„ te"..... l , . / \ I r_.] \ 4- (:ordimor 1 GreatAmerican ., n a SIDE VIEW WALL 22 GA,SHEET METAL CABINET - PLEX FACE WITH ► 0 NETWORK SYMBOLS allialliai . - . 13" V A C e .... i. ;. FLUORESCENT LAMPS n CLEAR PRISMATIC LENS FABRICATE ONE WALL MOUNTED SINGLE FACE CABINET/LIGHT BOX 1 - ___________-_ X DATE CUSTOMER GREAT AMERICAN BANK APPROVED BY BOOTZl .: �� __ !t94WE j . & DUKEDESIGNER PHOENIX,ARIZ4NA. IT MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED, COPIED,OR ;f;g� a o �_ ' �� EXHIBITED IN ANY FASHION TO ANYONE OUTSIDE OF YOUR o�$�o [�G� paOC�a��� $ o�� DATE 8-23-1993 SCALE 1 -1 -0 gT7S @t G50 Ri70.046os — ORGANIZATION WITHOUT THE WRITTEN PERMISSION OF AN ��____ - AUTHORIZED OFFICIAL OF BOOTZ& DUKE SIGN CO. 03/17/93 Minutes, Council Regular Session 4 activity at least 20 days before the hearing by the Board. 11. Comparison of the hours of operation of the proposed premises to the existing businesses in close proximity. Mayor Elliott opened the public hearing. Patrick Rielly, 11410 N. La Tanya Drive. Mr. Rielly stated he feels it is more appropriate to buy alcohol from a supermarket such as Fry's than from a Circle K. Mayor Elliott closed the public hearing. A MOTION was made by Councilmember Hoyt and SECONDED by Councilmember Karol to APPROVE the request for a Series 09 liquor license at the Fry's Food Store to be located at the southwest corner of North First Avenue and Oracle Road. MOTION UNANIMOUSLY carried 5 - 0. OV13-93-2 - APPEAL OF DEVELOPMENT REVIEW BOARD DECISION ON FRY'S FOOD STORES' REQUEST FOR APPROVAL OF PERMANENT WALL SIGNS Steve Hagedorn, Planning & Zoning Director stated on March 10, 1993 Councilmember Karol, Mayor Elliott, Town Manager, Town Attorney and Planning & Zoning Director met with representatives from the Fry's Food Stores to discuss proposed signage for the store. As a result of that meeting, Fry's Food Stores is willing to include the following type of signage on their wall at their shopping center: 1. Sign letter height would not exceed 3 ' in height on the store wall that faces North First Avenue; 4 ' on the wall that faces Oracle Road; all secondary signage would have a letter height not to exceed 2 ' . 2. All sign letters and symbols shall be metal finish and backlit with halo illumination. 3. The sign and logo for the Great American Bank shall be of the same metal finish as the other wall mounted signs. Mr. Michael Franks, Douglas Seaver & Associates, representing Canyon Del Oro Partners. Mr. Franks stated they submitted their sign package to the DRB, no decision regarding the signage could be reached, that is why they are before the Council this evening to appeal. They feel they have a compromise solution that is consistent with the "new" direction for signage in Oro Valley. He presented a sample of a reverse pan metal letter. The intent would be to have this letter illuminated from behind which would take on a halo effect when lit in the evening. The finish of the letter is a concept of what they envision for Phase I of Fry's. He stated it will be consistent with the overall package they are proposing for the center. 03/17/93 Minutes, Council Regular Session 5 In response to a question by Vice-Mayor Skalsky, Mr. Franks stated the concept is to develop a comprehensive package for the 40 acre site with approximately 350, 000 sq. ft. of building when this is built out. He stated they are looking at a reverse pan letter than would be consistent with major anchor tenants on this site, including Fry's. That same type of letter that is backlit, reverse pan, would be consistent with the overall effect on this building. The main letters for the 2 monument signs that will be before the DRB on April 13th, will also be reverse pan letters, rear lit. That sign will read "Rooney Ranch Center" and will have a metal finish similar to the finish proposed for Fry's. The logo's will be cut out and backlit. Mr. Franks stated approval tonight is for Phase I - 60,000 sq. ft. Councilmember Karol MOVED to overrule the DRB decision and approve OV13-93-02 Fry's Wall sign package with the following conditions: The four foot tall Fry's Food & Drug Store sign located on the northwest wall be reduced from 4 foot tall letters to 3 foot tall letters, thereby bringing the signage into compliance with the maximum square footage stated in the Code. Only natural metal letters and symbols be used such brass, bronze, copper, steel or brushed aluminum. These metal letters may be green or blue patina finish. Only non-colored halo illumination type lighting produced by recessing the light source inside a hollow letter with an open back or within the surface the letters are attached may be permitted. The light source shall not be visible from the front or sides. The logo and the bank sign will be the same metal and finish as all the other signs that we are talking about now. Mr. Franks clarified that the Oracle Road sign is four feet and the First Avenue sign is three feet. Mr. Karol replied that is correct. MOTION SECONDED by Councilmember Hoyt. Discussion. In response to a question by Vice-Mayor Skalsky, Steve Hagedorn stated there was a split decision by the DRB on both votes. Neither of the motions made by the DRB were approved. Vice-Mayor Skalsky asked Mr. Hagedorn if the DRB will be comfortable with this proposal? Mr. Hagedorn stated he is confident this proposal would get a majority vote from the DRB in favor, there are aspects of this proposal that 1 or 2 members may not have agreed with. However, it is a very difficult question to answer because of the 03/17/93 Minutes, Council Regular Session 6 circumstances. Vice-Mayor Skalsky suggested that if this happens again, the DRB should be encouraged to come to a decision so the Council can vote on a specific piece. Councilmember Karol stated he would like to add to his motion that since the petitioner has agreed to use patina copper, that is what will be used on the Fry's Stores. He also pointed out that when the DRB examined this under the old Zoning Code because this request was grandfathered. In the meeting that we had with Fry's, they were willing to give up their grandfathering and were willing to recognize the direction in which the Town was proceeding, and therefore they offered to do this on the basis of the green patina copper. He doesn't see any problem with what we are doing here. Mayor Elliott asked Mr. Franks to go back to the DRB with a presentation to inform them of where the direction of the town so that all the Boards are looking at the same thing and understanding the direction in which the Town has gone as a point of information, if nothing else. MOTION UNANIMOUSLY carried 5 - S. Terry Marshall, General Manager, Fry's Food Stores stated they are happy to be in Oro Valley and he hopes we will be as happy with them as they are with the Town. He stated the Town should be proud of its staff and Council because rather than coming in on an adversarial situation, we worked it out in a meeting and he feels they have accomplished with the Town wants, and what staff and Council wants and he feels they will be in compliance with the DRB as well. OV12-92-10 PRELIMINARY PLAT AND LANDSCAPE PLAN - CANADA HILLS, VILLAGE 14, LOTS 1-64, CONSIDERATION AND/OR POSSIBLE ACTION (CONTINUED FROM 3/4/92) Steve Hagedorn stated this came before the Council on March 3, 1993 and there was a question concerning additional access into this project. The Project Engineer has taken a look at that and he is proposed an option for the Council to look at this evening. Warren Thompson, Cella Barr & Associates, representing Canada Hills Development Co. Mr. Thompson stated they have been able to establish a paved 12 ' emergency ingress/egress located between Lots 6 and 7. The paving will consist of decomposed granite. Jim DeGrood, Town Engineer stated they will provide a full 12 ' width durable all-weather surface. Councilmember Karol MOVED to APPROVE OV12-92-10 Canada Hills, Village 14, Lots 1-64 preliminary plat and landscape plan with the � .. . - 1 - 33 FR I 1 3 32 :i3101 1.< S I GM co _ = BOOT? ill &DUKE -- .. ..� ...». NCAr It I . eAlpAw4b FAX (602 272-4608 Statewide Sales & Service j —free estimates --- DATE: / BILL GIBSON 4028 W.Whitton Ave. Phoenix, AZ 85049 Sa►oe Manager Phone 272-9356 TIME: . TRANSMITTING TO: , 2O -- FAX NUMBER: FROM: ,/ , 441 NUMBER OF PAGES INCLUDING THIS PAGE: :5? SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS: � O ,ire:W4/0.� {/�y��j�I�� 4/fi .9 ,r,;(e) 7-,/e7 ,04 ,c9, .0 'e:/oW/d/405 r :t.ey-fer4ac;:r, _ • ..... . 600tz & Duke Sign Co. • 4028 West Whitton Ave. • Phoenix, Arizona 85019 • Phone (602) 272.9356 Serving Arizona Since 1964 Fox (602) 272-4608