HomeMy WebLinkAboutOV139906 12/11/1998 OS:88 520292129D MMLP, PACE i2
ilivc- 10-96 Oa!OOP Town or ot'o 4,, l1f-le 520 74 1072
TOWN OF ORO VALLEY
APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
P R'0.1ECT ARCHITEcTURE
DATS, ilt.
CV CASE NO. 7 LD 11
(0111:4ce use nly
PRO,7r,r7T 7, ....401. 04.mtpirs. ci4pap..._
LocATTO111
ApnicANT: _Clif4K itioc... -- ... 1014.) 4:. **SAUL.,
ATRE-'",frSS 1S35 14*- --- f-OtteilSabte&-A/Z----2525r
TFLFYHONF, NO - 1,01L! 5iid56 tb13
PROnnY nWT,IR '
--t'' P. am'
tOAL ,.
if
ADDRESS: tftge, PHONE NQ. ; dg:214M0421111 PROJECT ARCHITECT/ENGIN4SR: titaittiL
1;441 i J4ROAA _
i
ADDRESS talk* 1,111C00,__OMW:300411/044L50114 ` 041VilL
DEVELOPMENT 1:- , BO. * : . EARING DATE; to64)
1111 f i
SICNATURE: alo 6 , ..._. ,. DATK
NOTE: This ap• ication must b arcompaned by the required $150.00 fee
and twelve copies of the pan5, 1'1" x 17" an size, each to incll:de
dimensioned elevations of all structures from all four sides and a ccpy
of the project's site plan. The submittal must also includ
q911, r palette. for the project in an 8 _5" x 114 format, to i 4
chips of body and trim ,colcrs and tile color and style, if FTOtal h
Building square fcxtage is also requiz-ed. AT THE MEETING, CRO VALLEY
m a ust have on hnd for present n,atio cclorq4 ,perspective
Alevations of all four ides of t.he struct4.res 11000 N LA CANADA DR
ORD VALLEY, AZ 85737
SUBMITTALS MUST BE RECETVED BY THE PLANNING DEPARTMENT
CALE/411AR DAYS IN ADVANCE OF THE DESIRED DEVELOPMENT R (5203 297-2591
HEARING PATE
12/22/98 1:49PM
00140022
001-408 ZONING
$15n.an
-- .....
- ._
ITEMS 10
MED $150.00
rital OF
•
7
by==`< 7;-.1 CL.4",•..�ww:=�i�1�S r '` Q� 7
,,,,aeott.r.altitt more
i 'et"L a .r,,,a: :r.St.,.r'v TOWN OF ORO VALLEY : \\� ,;�1-
I t $ r �'' =',�• X r�fat,. ' 11,000 N. La Canada Drive ''
.= r<,ISF6::� :,, ..s.i.,.,3-.. Oro Valley AZ 85737 �',
liiirrn « ..L...3 si`.:j./�^,`"IY t,.(w'►-Aar• �IVC��'
_ ¢�• „:.. Phone: 797-9797
.! 1.Y .�S w/ ram//r�'
1 �- ',,,�- ,. Fax 742-1022
;ira.'}::.::x c r:...L...
I - ^. ,f,,- y: Date: '3 Ukt
y gal Frrt
I.• r
y.,-.-,am: =^;<�
: Zf.7.•47;47-..S.-:,.:,& . 1.4,%•,3Z , To: SIV11- 'CM OiNy
.� •- : t., - Company:
� �=:gip � _ ' 12. Oo� <69,S- O 15
:Y-w -,, ... �:.4:Y• Fax#.
•
O-" - From: S J )i,_.
Yam`..=`►j ,
%- Number of pages incluci_�g cover
c'= tom l'I' _
:=•✓..,,,.--,_ _•off.,
-.�:eta:._:-..i,r --^.. .
� ,4,t.---.' '.:. : If you do not receive all cages please call:
�•tci =[.a..VM.srT...,sr yr:;�,,> ', 1MM Q1
k at
• .:;--r� l��=�.._ 'IESS AGE
�� - .Ct
li "4
'. :,-..-.. ..1"2 .41 tg.:2-4.-—. ,. I PW—c.\t%, r, (.,K0 Inc, 00/vDt-cp3A .47 wt., v,)11.1 Go--
. 7---=,;..;,-,,,.. ,-,,,,r.. ..:•"--f-"tv....,.4=. • ti/C34'05A) Ni?' A'K )kA t NI wces " --?-01,k --WE; 1 1 0-\°R `Qm
., ..*Ple-,_:.C..•:=.2;.:-.".....7 .4. .....:-. ., Ikt INNEYO9S-CCIVC‘O cc-CaoR bC‹)4,m klciloe oN Moo*/ A-t4,
'I' VI I'LL °AIL YO0 e4C1 ..ek IlkfrklY' N/00.
et1> :d a .•.1.
j �R1O.wI r..y.y,.r
• ..•.itorodowir-.,...,`���"L.`,,,,...M ,a.�
• •
`. ':z. x� s;.'.� -=.% r - Administration 297-2 91 Legal 297-5222 � 2 _
i ,r.. 1. strate Court 97- =0=
-_ - .. Parks&Recreation 797-9096 Engineering 797-24-"
01-12-99 Development Review Board Minutes Page 5
Chair Lewis asked would the patios be stuccoed Ms. Kuenhold replied patio's would be fully
stuccoed.
Chair Lewis recommended that the stuccoed patio's be added as a condition.
Martin Falkowski 13113 N. Woodburn Avenue, commented that his property backed up to the
wash. He also attended a meeting with Richmond American and the neighborhood, he wanted to
affirm the work that Richmond American had done in addressing their concerns. He now feels
comfortable with the development that Richmond American is building.
MOTION: Moved, seconded (Vogelsberg/Smith) and carried by a 5-0 vote (Glueck
absent/Underwood excused) to recommend approval of OV13-98-93 Richmond American
Homes request for Architectural approval of Models 548, 528, 529, 539 and 589 for use in
Rancho Vistoso Neighborhood 10, Parcel K and L (Sunset Ridge) subject to Staff Conditions
and stipulating patio's be stucco.
PLANNING STAFF CONDITIONS:
1. Windows must be pop-outs or recessed on all sides.
2. If fireplaces are to be provided, an Oro Valley approved chimney cap must be used.
3. Ground mounted mechanical equipment shall be enclosed by a wall for visual
screening and noise mitigation.
4. Wainscoting on all models be extended to the side yard gate wherever visible from
the street.
5. The models shall include one patio as standard and the vertical supports must be
wrapped and stuccoed to match the house.
OV13-99-6 GIANT AT ORO VALLEY RETAIL CENTER, ARCHITECTURE
Valerie Feuer introduced the staff report into the record. A one-story convenience is proposed
for this site. The development will have vehicular access off the main parking area of the Oro
Valley Retail Center and Oracle Road. The building features 21 parking spaces, including two
handicapped accessible spaces, 2-bike racks, and a loading area. The architectural style may be
described as Southwest Contemporary with a flat roofline. Architectural elements include tile
accents and synthetic stucco exteriors. The entire storefront will be aluminum with powder coat
finish matching the building color. The proposed architecture lacks the decorative medallions as -
designed in the other structures for the Oro Valley Retail Center. The proposed architecture for
the Giant convenience store complies with Policy 9.1 A in that it blends the built environment
with natural surroundings by using earth tone colors and masonry/tile materials. Staff
recommends approval of the proposed Development Plan for Giant.
Steve Day, architect, representing Giant, was available for questions from the Board.
01-12-99 Development Review Board Minutes Page 6
Chair Lewis asked would the accent color be the same as Rancho Vistoso Giant. Mr. Day
replied yes. Chair Lewis also asked did he have any problems with the conditions. Mr. Day did
ask for clarification on item 5. He commented the aluminum would be the same color as the
building and it only as small strip used as trimmings. DRB Members agreed item 5 could be
deleted.
Mr. Day presented a colored photo for member to see of how the project looked.
Member Vogelsberg asked about the northwest side of the project, does the pedestrian sidewalk
connect to the sidewalk on Oracle. Mr. Day replied that would not be a problem to connect the
sidewalk to the existing sidewalk on the northwest side. Member Vogelsberg asked to see the
tiles that would be used for accent. Members of the Board suggested toning down the glossy red
tile with perhaps a non gloss tile.
Valerie Feuer asked to add a condition, after discussion with the Oro Valley Police Department.
The condition would be the architect work the OVPD regarding safety issues. Mr. Day agreed.
Bill Adler, 10720 N. Eagle Eye, commented that the painted aluminum would be inconsistent
with the PAD. He asked the Board to make the stucco like texture treatment, apply to the
exposed surfaces. He felt the light structure should be covered in this review. He also
commented that the pumps are painted and should be stuccoed. He felt that the colors of the
pumps should be included as a part of the signage. The purpose of this Advisory Board is to
make judgments to the aesthetics.
Member Mager asked Board Members to give her information as to what the lighting standards
are. Valerie Feuer commented that all the lighting standards on this project would be consistent
with the Fry's standard. There has not been a lot of discussion with what the lighting standards
are. Consistency would be what is already there at the Fry's Center.
Member Underwood commented he is not ready for stuccoed gas pumps. Member Smith
commented he liked the way the Diamond Shamrock turned out and is in favor of keeping those
kinds of standards.
MOTION: Moved, seconded (Underwood/Mager) and carried by a 6-0 vote (Glueck absent)
to recommend approval of OV13-99-6 Giant at Oro Valley Retail Center Architeture,
subject to Staff Conditions, stipulating the red tile color be non-gloss.
PLANNING STAFF CONDITIONS:
1. The refuse dumpster shall be enclosed on three sides by a 6' masonry wall and
plantings, and shall be finished to match the architectural character of the project,
per Section 9-110C of the OVZCR. The color of the masonry wall shall match the
colors of the existing and adjacent structure (s).
2. Mechanical equipment, whether ground level or roof-mounted, shall be screened
from public view and designed to be an integral part of the building, per Section 9-
01-12-99 Development Review Board Minutes Page 7
110H of the OVZCR. The color of the screening shall match the building.
3. The color of the flat roofed portions shall match the wall color.
4. A wainscot trim shall be added along all elevations in order to embellish the
architecture for this project.
• .
.
6. Per the approved Oro Valley Retail Center Sign Package, signage for this project
must be submitted for Staff review.
7. Per Section 9-108D of the OVZCR, the design of the canopy shall architecturally
match the design of the main building. Signage of any type is prohibited on
canopies. All canopy lighting must project downward, not upward or outward from
the structure and must be low-pressure sodium. The maximum height of the canopy
shall not exceed 18 feet.
8. The proposed tile accents shall be toned down or non-gloss and re-submitted for Staff
review.
9. The decorative medallions (moldings) shall be integrated in the Giant architecture.
This embellishment will add to the consistency required PAD.
10. The proposed color palette should be consistent with the color of the existing and
other proposed buildings in the Oro Valley Retail Center.
11. Architect work with the Oro Valley Police Department regarding safety issues.
12. Gas pump colors be reviewed with signage.
13. Add pedestrian access link on inner road.
OV12-98-18 SIGMA TECHNOLOGIES EXPANSION, DEVELOPMENT PLAN
Valerie Feuer introduced the staff report into the record. Sigma Technologies propose to expand
their existing 40,000 square foot building by 5,000 square feet. The maximum total building
coverage allowed under the La Reserve PAD is 33%. The actual building coverage for this site
with the expansion will be 20%. There are 165 existing off-street parking spaces, including six
handicapped accessible spaces. The proposed expansion is less that 25% of the entire
development. Therefore, no landscape plan was required for this project. The existing off-street
parking is designed in accordance with Pima County development standards, and does not need
modification to Oro Valley design and planning standards because of the small percentage
expansion. The public art requirement is also waived from this project for the same reason.
Vince Catalano, VVC Design representing Sigma Technologies, was presented to answer
questions from the Board. Member Underwood asked what is Signa. Mr. Catalano replied we
are a research and development company. Member Mager asked could the eucalyptus trees be
saved. Member Underwood replied it would be very expensive to save those trees.
MOTION: Moved, seconded (Mager/Allen) and carried by a 6-0 vote (Glueck absent) to
recommend approval of OV12-98-18 Sigma Technologies Expansion, Development Plan
•
• ITEM
ORO VALLEY PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT
DEVELOPMENT REVIEW BOARD
MEETING DATE: January 12, 1999
TO: DEVELOPMENT REVIEW BOARD
FROM: Dennis Silva, Jr., Planner I
SUBJECT: OV13-99-6 GIANT AT ORO VALLEY RETAIL CENTER,ARCHITECTURE
BACKGROUND:
Stephen Day, the architect representing Giant, requests DRB recommendation for architectural approval. The
subject property is a 1.42 acre pad with a 3,000 square foot building envelope, Building 10, Block 5, within the
Oro Valley Retail Center. The subject property is abutted on the north by Block 2, Target, to the south by the
intersection of Pusch View Lane and Oracle Road to the east by Oracle Road, and west by Building 11, Block
4, which is undeveloped.
SUMMARY:
A one-story convenience use is proposed for this site. The development will have vehicular access off the main
parking area of the Oro Valley Retail Center and Oracle Road (SR 77). The building features 21 parking
spaces, including two handicapped accessible spaces, 2-bike racks, and a loading area.
The elevations submitted show the building from all four sides. The architectural style may be described as
"Southwest Contemporary" with a flat roofline. Architectural elements include tile accents and synthetic stucco
exteriors. The opaque wall and fascias will be synthetic stucco with sand finish. The entire storefront will be
aluminum with powder coat finish matching the building colon The proposed architecture lacks the decorative
medallions (moldings) as designed in the other structures for th ,,Oro Valley Retail Center. This architectural
element shall be integrated in the Giant store design.
The proposed color palette has been submitted for DRB review and approval. However, proposed signage colors
have not been submitted for DRB review and approval. Signage must comply with the sign package for the Oro
Valley Retail Center. The signage shown on the canopy is not allowed under the OVZCR. Refer to Section 9-
108 of the OVZCR and Exhibit "A" for more details on canopy requirements. The proposed color palette
should be consistent with the color of the existing and other proposed buildings in the Oro Valley Retail Center.
CAcii
GENERAL PLAN COMPLIANCE:
The proposed architecture for the Giant convenience store complies with Policy 9.1A in that it blends the built
environment with natural surroundings by using earth tone colors and masonry/tile materials.
RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends approval of the proposed Deveip _±P1 n for Giant, subject to the conditions listed in
Exhibit"A".
.
Attachments:
1. Exhibit"A"
2. Reduction of proposed architecture and site plan
F:\OV\OV 13\1999\13-99-6\ARCHDRB.RPT
2
•
EXHIBIT A
CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL
OV13-99-6 GIANT AT OV RETAIL CENTER
ARCHITECTURE
1. The refuse dumpster shall be enclosed on three sides by a 6' masonry wall and plantings, and shall be
finished to match the architectural character of the project,per Section 9-110C of the OVZCR. The
color of the masonry wall shall match the colors of the existing and adjacent structure(s).
2. Mechanical equipment, whether ground level or roof-mounted, shall be screened from public view and
designed to be an integral part of the building,per Section 9-110H of the OVZCR. The color of the
screening shall match the building.
3. The color of the flat roofed portions shall match the wall color.
4. A wainscot trim shall be added along all elevations in order to embellish the architecture for this project.
5i The aluminum material used for the storefront shall be changed with a material that is more consistent
with the surrounding and adjacent developments.
6. Per the approved Oro Valley Retail Center Sign Package, signage for this project must be submitted for
Staff review.
7. Per Section 9-108D of the OVZCR,the design of the canopy shall architecturally match the design of
the main building. Signage of any type is prohibited on canopies. All canopy lighting must project
downward, not upward or outward from the structure and must be low-pressure sodium. The maximum
height of the canopy shall not exceed 18 feet.
8. The proposed tile accents shall be toned down and re-submitte
p p for Staff review.
9. The decorative medallions (moldings) shall be integrated in the Giant architecture. This embellishment
will add to the consistency required by the Rooney Ranch PAD.
10. The proposed color palette should be consistent with the color of the existing and other proposed
buildings in the Oro Valley Retail Center.
k'L 4.1)f-421-
r
C)-4
L(if\L
3
- .
EXTER I OR UILINNCv MATERIAL b AND C,CY-OKb .
ALL OPAQUE WALL AND FASGIA
FINISH5S TO YNTH5TIC,
STUGGO WITH SAND FINISH
ALL STOREFRONT TO 55
ALUMINUM WITH POWDERGOAT
FINISH - GOLOR. TO MATCH
15UILDIN& COLOR. TILE AGGENT5
1 - AT DUILDIN&
ALL &LAZIN& TO 155 CLEAR
WITH DUTT JOINTS
. I
A
DUNN-EDWAKDS FAINT GOLOKS TILE DANDb . __J
AT GANOPY
I MATCH
DUNN-EDWAKIDS
MOONeLOW #IN 80
2 MATGH
DUNN-EIDWAIZDS
SHAWL #DE1058-LI A lik%
1 Stephen C. Day •„, s,
/71111147
A r chi tec ,
P , 0 . B 0 X 2 2 2 6 - A
C o r r a 1 e s inoso
Nev Mexico USA S';-epn C Day
s 7 0 4 8
Tel 505.898.3774 I044
Cell 505.269.7909
Fax 505.898.9015
SCDay@Compuserve.com
At CONVENIENCE
Ar STORE
ORACLE ROAD AT PUSCH VIEW LANE
INDUSTRIES , INC . O R O V A L LEY , A R I Z O N A
&I OP-A03 DW& 01996 f,TEPHEN G. DAY - 12/15/1118-12 57
-.00-0007'', -- - - - - ' ' Nit* • . -
-
e 41,1Wo t-
-
"
d
§# '�tt'y�.% '��',r�Y1).,S•nia-may t - • +
a; a- . .- e . , a__., !
. ..:4__,.., - ,
-,,,,
, 4 . .
,,... ...:, _
•
::. .
t:� F s _--... ` nil+ Z . t .
t
• - .Op* ' `-.: ,,,r,--..., -,, . maw f - 17- , '. ' i
# ) .,ra..:.. is �. " at ; f,.-+'` ' C r%•� " ..:-
no I ,
i 5..
f'
• - .c'' . -:-L5011011
41/07111r
ar ar-— --- --_r
Ka I
�4 -a° .:
1
D. -
I li
li k111
_ ,
,1 .... ,,
00
00
8 O
1
0
•• › I I III. i
El • Z 1i ' • ,
Q i b o
' —0 -
''.< I) -— I D 0 it
--‹ j ; . .
I !
K
t
tr-
a, 1 ,• it)
1 , ,. �"r A
U
•
r- I 1,+ ❑ r
p I CI
Z I A a
I j
I
r '
I4 11 g
El cs
i8 . —... g , 0 0 7----_ i . .
I I f ii III
1
t V Li,
V ,, C \ — .
. , r '..:1-1Zio 1 ___../
z
I I
A
iI
/ kfit- ,
,1 i
l } ; o Ia " Z is
I � HI
'
I
,_.—i
! IN, --,- Ise --i
it.t' .g§. Q
1 baill
J
] — 0 it
— i
I 1 ,'
k_. 1 EllCI- C J Ill 4 ',) cj)I II
1 Ti:y
�C
1i _
0 ..
'' ,l-it ,F;C..
I ❑ -
El
I - ❑ ❑
!u z C1
Al
D.
8 1 lig
.,I 0❑
tIll a • 00 — . '
r I
I i
I I I
! ! I A—
•
v,a CONVENIENCE I T.'
rr
; i � -
ORACLE ROAD AT PUSCH VIEW LANE iv.-- '
Na 40 t, Rt�s`a n
'
f g g O
:I I 1 4 0Na x •r) 08
INDUSTRIES , I N C O R O V A L L E Y A R I Z O N A i Gg � �: ,, 6 >r
1 i ;
k
•
•
A
I ;
•
I
1
1
I
1
I
•
1
1
i
r') i
1
1
1 1
1;( I
L........: I I
, ,
I_....... ______
i
t---,,, 1
,
•
,
i \
, „, it
-----.......„,/ ,
,..
i \ ,
, .
, :
\ I
il'.....,,,,
N.,1
/
''''' ''''''ll
//
I /
.,,,,
k -'',..,
'''.%%',...s.,...7:..i.,..............„..s
.........,,.
....-
----------,....,-....,......,........,,,.... .,
.----.......„..,—....--
..'.....'",......<
i
..............- ..„. ....... ..,,.._...
i
.................._ . .„ .. .
,
,
.. .,
,
.....................„.. ....
!
,
.. s
I
•.
....
:. -“,—,..,........... ...
f ......._..--
-.,...,
. -",...,..........., ,
--....,
4" -,....
-‘"*....„........,
/ ..
‘71‘
h
/
//
I
i I
,
.,,,
-.I
.
- . -
, ,,,• ....,,...,"-',,„,,,
-.
/"...,
1 I'S. I
\•,,,
1
tr---CINN
...... ,,,
1
\\,17
1 1 NNN,
1
ni 1
1
: 6
,
_...---
1
r
........_
/
,...,
( / '''''
,
/
. 1
,
/ / ,,--,,
1
1
ti
I
, 1
,:,,'
\........../
z /
I
I
1
9r°
tt
44'
a6 I
/ . ___.......4_,....)
..
' .--":.:::=::.:::-71:::.":: 1 7\ 1
0.0.
1,-4"'°' T31 I
i N 1
r-13
gi
I
z
.4-41 C.), I
94) ' 1
I
. . i
/
/I
‘
/ /
ril /
) I ,
,
.4'
I
/
— ...,,,,, .
't•
#
I
1
'. 1
iny: I 1.,......................
424
tY
.t‘
I
%
la
, r
xi /
,
,e* 1
•
-----------—
i )
'‘
/"
,,.
Ai
/ I
‘,...%
/
,i'
f, / /1''',„...
•
0'
/
I'
• 111,
/
+.1
/V
gii.
.,;"
I '
() i
/
/
,/ /4'...,....
\ .
/
'
.
i
\
\N
...
,,,,....._
-",,,..........
,.
N.,„,....„..
',..,,...
...„,„,........
N.,........
....,-,,
..............
. / ,I....",..,.....„..,„
`......„
.,
N..„.........
.....,...
1..,......„
. .
I •`,,,,
. ..
',...........
'',...„..
/
. ,
......,
/
...
/
' Z
. ..
.........,
..,
...,„.,,
.,....
,,.
.........,
......
.........,,,,.,,,..
....
b .
........
.........., , i
,
...„.
..........,, ,,
.
..fr.....,.,..j „
k
.......
,...„
......
i
..„_..
,,..
/
/
c
.......,
---,
.......„
44...
,-...
",....
1
':•:::,---
'''..,,,...
''''...."...............,...
it
.. o
,.........„
.... ....„... 4
ica
..,„,,,,......
,.....
..
-...„
.....,
-.....,,.....
...,.
-.....
-....
.... ,Cs
......., .
. . .........
.............., .
„......
rt
,,-,t *Co -,A-
, .,,,•-_,-- ..1,',„ ,s'
,A., -
c \ ' ,
,...S.,
91 •,S
\ 1.
\ C;s:' 1 ."Y'
1
0 'C 0 \ 11;;it - \ g
1-- %SS?. °" '0
I- V N t;t1-4,
5 v\I
P• \e.,
-...-- \--‘
i 0
0 5 C
c--
0
c 0 \ ?
A
P\
V. ‘....
0 \-
C C
\NI
lir
\ 0
\
C '
\ 5 '
\l'.
A 0
.1.
V
‘ 1