HomeMy WebLinkAboutOV131106 oho )2v
.44AWMO
�°UNDED.\91 A
DEV REVIEW BOARD
COMMERCIAL Resubmittal? N
Development Review Transmittal
Town of Oro Valley Planning and Zoning Division
11000 N. La Canada Drive
Oro Valley,AZ 85737
Review Agency: DEVELOPMENT REVIEW BOARD
Transmittal Out: Tuesday, February 22, 2011
Transmittal Due: Tuesday, March 08, 2011
Project Information APPLIED
Project Number: OV1311-06 Parcel Number:
Project Title: LA CANADA ANIMAL HOSPITAL -
Lots (if applies): 1
Location: MERCADO AT CANADA HILLS LOT 1
Applicant: EGLIN COHEN ARCHITECTS Phone: 520-885-4455
Zoning:
Oro Valley Planner: PLANNER TO BE ASSIGNED
Date Information (as applies)
DRB Hearing:
2nd DRB Hearing:
Additional Comments:
Written comments need to be returned to Development Coordinator, Shirley Gay. If you
have no comments,please sign and date this form, and return it via FAX(520) 742-1022.
For questions or comments, call (520) 229-4849, (520) 229-4816 or email sgay@,orovalley.net.
Wednesday, February 23,2011
DEVELOPMENT REVIEW BOARD
Approved Without Comments By: Date:
..... Planning&Zoning Division
11000 N. La Canada Drive,Oro Valley AZ 85737 r E B 2 2 2011
Phone: (520)229-4800 Fax: (520)742-1022
www.orovalleyaz.gov
APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT REVIEW COMMERCIAL ARCHITECTURE
DATE: (9-\�� < < OV CASE NO.: DO 1.N -Ot (office use only)
•✓Y.la°'°`�°»Jbm"i°&:... .. .. 91A6'1FGf8!%:'YE✓.. .&&.`L@6y6,pH` ili .. "Y`�.S:E."?•S.l::< � `.ti4 ',..�eN�'WH.. 4D11JSOAS.°6� 'GAN £F: LR%i. T4ffi °G.�4' eakh&iv '%:Y.iit
PROJECT NAME:La Canada Animal SUBDIVISION Mercado at Canada LOT# 1
Hospital Hills
LOCATION/ADDRESS: 10000 Blk North La Canada Dr City Oro Valley St AZ Zip 89737
El Conquistador
ZONING P. 4. D. PARCEL NUMBER: 1 LOT SIZE 15,255 scJ.ft.
REASON FOR SUBMITTAL: New Building
APPLICANT: Eglin/Cohen Architects, P.C. Attn: Evan S. Eglin
ADDRESS: 7391 E. Tanque Verde Road City, Tucson St AZ Zip 85715
PHONE NO.: 520/885-4455 FAX NO.: 520/885-2886
Email address: evane@eglincohen,corn
PROPERTY OWNER: Mary Anne Bolser DVM
ADDRESS: 10420 N. La Canada Drive, #160 City Oro Valley St AZ Zip 85737
PHONE NO.: 520/544-4734 FAX NO: 520/297-7964
444
SIGNATURE: Z7- DATE: 2 'ZJ l/
,f(
Submittal Requirements:
- Fees $270.00 First Pad$100.00 per additional pad
:One copy of 24x36 elevations in color
:Electronic submittal of submittal materials in dwg(CAD)or shp format and pdf form. Applications will not be accepted without
this disk
Eighteen copies of the following:
Dimensioned color elevations of all four sides of all,buildings and f1o9r plan(11"x 17"format) -----
Elevations must show wall for screening mechanical equipment
Site Plan(11"x 17"format) ./
Color chips of body,trim and roof tiles(8'/Z"by 11"format)Commercial
Photo of building with current colors if proposing color change on existing project ✓
• Applications will not be accepted without all required materials.
• PLEASE COLATE AND FOLD SUBMITTAL
Revised 11-20-08
'_ JWN OF ORO VALI Y
DEVELOPMENT AND INFRASTRUCTURE SERVICES
11000 N. LA CANADA DRIVE ORO VALLEY,AZ 85737
PHONE: 229-4800 FAX: 742-1022
RECEIPT
******************************************************************************
REFERENCE NUMBER: OV1311-06 RECEIPT #11P00054
SITE ADDRESS: 10590 N LA CANADA DR OV TAXCODE:
DATE: 02/22/2011 TIME: 04:10 PM
COMP TYPE: DEV REVIEW BOARD TYPE: COMM
DESCRIPTION: LA CANADA ANIMAL HOSPITAL-
APPLICANT: EGLIN COHEN ARCHITECTS OWNER:
BOLSER MARY ANNE
Notation: Receipt By: WVJ
*******************************************************************************************
Copy Reprinted on 06-22-2011 at 08:52:49 *COPY*
PAID BY:
Type Method Description
Amount
Payment Check 67865 270 . 00
TOTAL: 270.00
FEES PAID:
Description Account Code Current Pmts
Development Review Board 00000060-3045 270.00
TOTAL: 270.00
Account#:
Ending Balance: $
3 -
TOWN OF ORO VALLEY
DEVELOPMENT REVIEW BOARD MEETING DATE: April 12, 2011
TO: DEVELOPMENT REVIEW BOARD
FROM: Matt Michels, AICP, Senior Planner
SUBJECT: Architectural elevations for La Canada Hills Animal Hospital on Lot 1, Mercado at Canada
Hills, located in proximity to La Canada Drive and Lambert Road, requested by Eglin-Cohen
Architects, OV1311-06.
SUMMARY
The Development Review Board (DRB) is required to review commercial architecture. The proposed
building will incorporate architectural features, color schemes and materials compatible with the
existing commercial center and surrounding areas. The building design incorporates a contemporary
interpretation of traditional Southwest architecture, including varied rooflines, stucco and the use of split
face block. This design will blend seamlessly with the recently approved building on Lot 2 (0V1310-13;
Rubs Massage and two additional shop spaces), which is adjacent to this building.
Site Conditions
• Mercado at Canada Hills is 5.97 acres
• Lot 1 is 9,453 square feet (approximately .22 acres)
• Zoning is El Conquistador Planned Area Development (PAD) - Commercial
• Three existing buildings on this site (on Lots 4 and 5)
• 28 feet maximum building height
• Surrounding uses include single-family residences and vacant commercial lots
Proposed Improvements
• Veterinary clinic use
• Building size is 3,555 square feet
• Building height: 26'-8" proposed
• Building will utilize color and materials palette of existing buildings in the center
Related Approvals
• Mercado at Canada Hills Development Plan (0V1203-31) approved by Town Council on July 29,
2005
• Adjacent building on Lot 2 approved as OV1310-13. Rubs Massage will occupy Shop 3 and the
other shops/tenant spaces will remain vacant.
ANALYSIS OF DEVELOPMENT REVIEW CRITERIA AND GUIDELINES
The following is a list of noteworthy criteria (in italics) followed by staff commentary.
Review Criteria-Section 22.6.B
• Section 22.6.B.8: "All components of a development shall take cognizance of the unique desert,
climate and other environmental factors of this region and promote an indigenous architectural
feeling."
•
TOWN OF ORO VALLEY
DEVELOPMENT REVIEW BOARD Page 2 of 3
The architecture of this building is very similar to the existing buildings within Mercado at Canada Hills.
The three existing buildings include similar design elements and features such as exposed block and
low varied rooflines.
• Section 22.6.B.10: "All exterior materials and colors including roofs, walls and fences shall be
predominantly muted earth and plant tones and shall minimize contrast and glare."
The proposed stucco colors, exposed block and steel metal deck provide variations of similar muted
earth tone shades. The colors and material proposed were previously approved for the existing
buildings, including Sherwin Williams Compatible Cream (SW6387) and Baguette (SW6123) on the
stucco walls, and Canyon Clay (SW6054) on the exposed steel and metal deck.
Design Guidelines (Addendum "A")
• Design Guidelines, C.2.e (i), "Design buildings with consideration to all sides of building."
The north elevation, which faces existing residences, offers some articulation but could benefit from
additional design features and landscaping to break up and conceal the mostly blank wall mass. Staff
recommends additional design features or treatments be provided on this elevation, such as pop
outs/recesses, additional windows (real or faux) or trellises to provide consistency with the east and
west elevations (see Condition #1 in Exhibit "A").
The west elevation facing La Canada Drive and the east elevation facing Ace Hardware provide
adequate design treatments, including vertical columns.
• Design Guidelines, C.2.e (iv), "Rooftop mechanical equipment, vents and ducts should be screened or
installed in a manner that prevents obstruction or distraction of other views."
The final plat for the commercial center included a condition that rooftop mechanical equipment be
screened from view. A condition has been added to Exhibit "A" to require the applicant to demonstrate
that the rooftop mechanicals will not be visible from adjacent residences (see Condition #3 in Exhibit
"A").
• Design Guidelines, C.2.f (i), "Use exterior materials such as stucco, brick, adobe, natural stone, textured
concrete or textured and split face concrete masonry units."
The building includes a stucco finish and extensive use of comb-faced concrete masonry units on the
columns.
• Design Guidelines, C.2.g, "Variations in roof lines should be used to add interest and reduce the scale of
larger buildings."
The building design incorporates a small tower feature on the northwest corner which breaks up the
horizontal plane of the roofline, adds visual interest, and clearly defines the building entrance. The low
roofline reduces the scale of the building.
CONCLUSION/RECOMMENDATION
The architecture is in conformance with the Zoning Code development review criteria and Design Guidelines
and requirements with noted exceptions that have been addressed in the conditions of approval. It is
consistent with the architectural style and colors of the existing Mercado at Canada Hills development.
TOWN OF ORO VALLEY
DEVELOPMENT REVIEW BOARD Page 3 of 3
Staff recommends approval of this application subject to the conditions in Exhibit "A".
SUGGESTED MOTION
The DRB may wish to consider one of the following suggested motions:
I move to [approve, approve with conditions, OR deny] architectural elevations for La Canada Animal
Hospital on Lot 1, Mercado at Canada Hills, located in proximity to La Canada Drive and Lambert Road,
requested by Eglin-Cohen Architects, OV1311-06, subject to the conditions in Exhibit "A".
Attachments:
1. Exhibit "A"
2. Site Plan, Building Elevations, and Color/Materials
cc: Barry Kitay, Barry@whirlygig.com
Evan Eglin, evane@eglincohen.com
S:\PERMPLUS\DOCS\OV1311-06\P_DRB report 4-12-11.doc
l/
David A. Williams, AICP, Planning Division Manager
4
EXHIBIT "A" CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL
OVI 3I 1-06
LA CANADA HILLS ANIMAL HOSPITAL ARCHITECTURAL ELEVATIONS
1. The north building elevation must provide acceptable design features and landscaping to break up
the blank wall mass on the eastern portion of the north facade. Design features may include pop
outs/recesses, additional windows (real or faux) or trellises as well as enhanced landscaping along
the elevation.
2. The exterior paint colors must match the colors of the existing buildings.
3. All rooftop mechanicals must be entirely screened from all surrounding properties. Provide
the design details or necessary photo simulations to ensure that the mechanicals will not be
visible from the adjacent homes.
v
.„--------"-- /7ZZ s 1
77
7‘-`:_t• -7-2---"_ _-,t ,b,,-'';"VV.-1:fl•-'1 '-k.'!-:::.X.V 4-t--a--;-47-X.:1;,, 4-A 41 Z \
,/,,Z
S7u7
� LOT 6
_; : N " - '''''St'
/ ) LOT7
Zzz
MI
3� � THIS
�% ry7LOT 5 DEVELDEVELOPMENT OPMENT
T —i
•
,4$ "-z w;;s '- ' I' 11111 1 -ry
gm
�;- zi G d o 0 0_12 0
�isAir� 3 ^ h. 3
t
�" w �.� LOT 5 o g z i`
% o
i
• e r/ --N. ,--r•1 W t rt visnt r ;77;- 2 )4
O b 14 3 (7------,
j r o O 8
LOCATION MAP4
Z o g e 3
•
'' V '/ (
I -Th —
CI
3 I I g 3
i _
....---I / I 1
P
rz,Z-ye LOT 4 6 6 9 s IH
' a
8
9 I 7 I 9 3
II—I_--- cm LOT 3 H 7 g 3
o 1]�--- Q FUTURE
j \---... )
DEVELOPMENT —6 `� `�
6
I
, L J R
k A A, ___H i - - __._ --
I 1
ni 7
-- -- - �_��_L�_ I
_ II 5 5 ,,{ 57.3' \\\
1 i 111NQOIrQt i —_----- J ' --
nc ram 1 L
2-
SZ'
1 J 1
co
"° LOT1 � i - LOT9 LOT8 -Pi
LOT 2 I 6 6 6 T FUTURE cJI.,,
I BIADf1O ADJACENTOV 131013 I I ,_ — --- !-- DEVELOPME(YT J
I '� -1 5 L J-—
1 yTT;
I - _
\ .I,*. 8 V
1 . . ' .—. / J - —
�-y
1 1
8I 8 I D I I g , g g I
' f I ! I 1 1 II1
in 7
-- -1 -....1 _ ----1--1 --- : _
�_
___._:-.-___))
SITE LAN =30-o- ee- =--s
LA CANADA DR.
1.,,,,,,,
` 1 EaLIN/COHEN
"'--` ARCHITECTS
Cana HillsLA cANADA ALMERCADO AT LA CANADA
�,,, „�, HOSPIT
ORO VALLEY, ARIZONA � '(s�°)---
Canada ""°° �"u°>°�a�
02.16.11 J08#2710-10
t26'-8"1
24'-6"
T.O.R.
T.o.F� 22'-6"
•
. x ; T.O.P.
- iJ 1 T.O.P.
4 i 12
'` i 1 1,t26'-8" 2
� -- - TOR.
- 24._s2' .-
zz-s" o R
•
i
1
' tj T f .-. ;;� 4.-�-.. t .,,x- ,—. '' ---- - ��i Sri -- -..-__-._.- -- --- - - -- - _ sas --
NORTH ELEVATION ,
a a Mi. __ f
,,
1 6. •1' r - a mut `
u txs ,._ ES 'ATION
6
" 2oP.
I �
—l—- Sr
,...E.
----------------------------------------------
c OZr- ' T� illit
1E-,7
\ 1 '4DT��\ - - = i
-
j
, s--nag 3 - Iii
tt [
(/ -; I , '_ti - r - ° 7- -v--;- ' ',\ ' .. `44RFY LOCK ___y_ - i 3
� ,----11-
I
r uLa�«
1
' xxc. ; . , , ;
I
CC
� -
-
-
t • - Mr z. zuc
I r � URGIERY
_ : r_r.,e_xr ,� ; , CAI O.- �.; '� EAST ELEVATION
,C C.1C�' S _--- I ROOFING ON PLYWOOD
isdp
CORRUGATED METAL
"T a,N, _ 1f'_a.x14.-6: cc _ SHEATHING TO MATCH
re / -1-O EXIST.SHOPPING CENTER \ 12
' A�� ON WOOD TRUSS 2 8"
mnu. BUILT OFl t2 -
1 8"
UP RO NG ON 6
r n 18'-6"AFF PLYWOOD DECK ON 24'-6" T.O.R.
. ^{',�,J�°'x �I�Q TM '01 �°z■En e 1 A� ! PRE-ENGINEERED TJI,
'A _ 1D�'s'-CA/M�T rn, dtT.
- 3/8"/FT/SLOPE o' 22'-6"
e �M16 ♦ vd •Y � A f A 1 13'-10"AFF MECHANICAL UNIT SCREEN
_ UNDER SEPARATE PERMIT
OA �``-� X Y =',�__�--� T.O.P. J.19'-6" r T.O.P.
fa `_ P-9'B-!' _..- -Ir—�' —-- 9'-EoE-V i L. a - i ,, --- B 1 T T.O.P. .-
m y H
� _ ' >< !
19,T.O.P. Ir�
I �� + ,,, ,�GA■ I 19'-6"AFF r_--- — ll,,
�)a LAB PF�-...r, ■ T.O.P. a 11 sTUWocc�o FRAMING
I •3r I I
I 1 , t--- Min i-- 1 t _ T —
r- o r J
,, 'I, A,i.,..,---.....1
__ -I 9_, se-4. 19-6 AFF r r -''� i i i\ Tr
I. B"x4"z16'COMB-
J I I i T.O.P. r r N, I I I I m` ri I -
ri-1 - FACED CMU,
i n — — — I riii - } in INTEGRAL COLOR
I EXAM 1 �.EXAM-2 EXAM-3 EXAM-4 a r �i - L j i — — I , ! / � —
9 5.'U-a' !'-8'IA•-10" 9'rxlC'-r r-sxr-,� �j 1 I
i _ �' s}IOP 1 �J , \ ✓ _ - F.F.E.
L D D 7;; J
} 975 3 4"CONCRETE
_ SLAB ON 4-ABA BUILDING SECTION — 'A'
20 ____ Y-lrau-r 2
U _ .i -- �41 I ;I {n 18'-6"AFF ' 7.- 1 'I',
BUILT UP ROOFING ON 1/8"..c-0"
31 71,2‘ T.O.P. - PLYWOOD DECK ON
b. PRE-ENGINEERED T,N,
8 l• 3/8"/FT/SLOPE
ADJACENT BLDG I I MECHANICAL UNIT SCREEN
A _ �� 19'-6"AFF 22'-s"
IBC u'-0"eEd OV 131013 7 T.O.P.
UNDER SEPARATE PERMIT
4 on ..d.,,,,r N T.O.P.
1 r 0 \ ,
ini
, Is ,► a� -ire: ler
'" t 6'-8"AFF - __,-. I IXi
r.o.P.
�� �1 i��, �,, tf ' • n - iiip
O.R. i1 11111. 7 13'-10" i 13'-10•
4171
_., -- 4 T.O. i T.O.P.$
jet �� �� .ii T.O.( P e"LIGHT GAUGE
II
�� 41, 1 !1• +art v. i'GDr wl i saI ! METAL CHANNEL el ___ _ _ ......_ ._ .-_------..___ _ 7
F.
r ...■.� 7 711 A 11:31 = FRAMING
f 8'x4'x16"COMB- o I STUCCO FINISH
go „:„,1
..�"' $j - r ■ =�•L - FF INTEGRAFACED L rn b rn
19 PA - I
i4 i 4p _ 16'T.O6"AFF a — —
COLOR
T.O.P. F.F.E.
:e 40 I. } -1 \ BoNa ABC
4"CONCRETE
SLAB ROOF PLAN 1/6 GerAlk BUILDING SECTION - 'B'
FLOOR PLAN tA\ 1/e`=I'-0-
3555 SF 1/8-1
-0- qpir je.,,,x„,
EOLIN/COHEN
Canada Hills MERCADO AT LA CANADA ,.3:
ARCH ITECTB
IHospiTAI_,
7391 E TAROUE VERDE RAOD TUCSON,AZ 85715
ANIMAL, ORO VALLEY, ARIZONA �5za>885_7898 TEL(520)885-4455
02.16.11 JOB#2710-10
SW 6387 SW 6123 EXTERIOR PAINT
COMPATIBLE CREAM BAGUETTE SHERWIN WILLIAMS
agi n. ice_
!VS?
1�'\mac•
SW 6054 EXPOSED STEEL AND METAL DECK
CANYON CLAY SHERWIN WILLIAMS
101
NOTE:
ALL EXTERIOR COLORS AND MATERIALS SHOULD MATCH COLOR TO MATCH EXPOSED BLOCK
EXISTING SHOPPING CENTER.
EXISTING SHOPPING CENTER COMB-FACED C.M.U.
EGLIN/COHEN
7
ARCHITECTS
4?i
LA CAI IADA HILLS IMERCADO A4L4A , 1I5715
F ORO VALLE , A
02.16.11 JOB#2710-10
- Development Review Board Page 1 of 5
MINUTES
ORO VALLEY DEVELOPMENT REVIEW BOARD
REGULAR SESSION
April 12, 2011
ORO VALLEY COUNCIL CHAMBERS
11000 N. LA CANADA DRIVE
CALL TO ORDER REGULAR SESSION AT OR AFTER 6:00 P.M.
Chairman Schoeppach called the meeting to order at 6:01 P.M.
ROLL CALL
PRESENT: Michael Schoeppach, Chairman
Ray Shelton, Member
Richard Luckett, Member
Dennis Ottley, Member
EXCUSED: Gene Wowk, Member
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Chairman Schoeppach led the audience in the Pledge of Allegiance.
CALL TO THE AUDIENCE
Chairman Schoeppach opened and closed without comment.
CONSENT AGENDA
1. Review and/or approval of the March 8, 2011, DRB meeting minutes.
March 8, 2011, DRB meeting minutes
MOTION: A motion was made by Member Ottley and seconded by Member
Shelton approve the March 8, 2011, DRB meeting minutes.
MOTION carried, 4-0
REGULAR AGENDA
1. Architectural exterior color change for the existing ATA Blackbelt Academy
http://orovalley.granicus.com/MinutesViewer.php?view_id=5&clip_id=1208 11/04/2011
Development Review Board Page 2 of 5
building, located at 11133 N. La Canada Drive, represented by W. J. Choi,
OV1311-05. For questions and additional information, please contact
David Ronquillo, Senior Planner, at (520) 229-4817or
dronquillo@orovalleyaz.gov.
Staff Report
Existing Colors
Scheme 1-2
Site Plan
Dan Dagnal, non resident, standing in for the applicant stated plans were
submitted with samples for both the front/back buildings to be painted. The
front building and the back building are both being painted.
David Ronquillo, Senior Planner, presented the following:
- Request
- Context Map
- Existing Building
- Proposed Colors - Schemes 1 & 2
- Compatibility with adjacent buildings
- Buildings to the north
- Buildings to the west
- Summary
Discussion ensued amongst the Board regarding the color schemes.
MOTION: A motion was made by Member Ottley and seconded by Member
Shelton to approve scheme 1 architectural color changes for the existing
buildings currently owned by W. J. Choi.
MOTION carried, 4-0
2. Sign Criteria revision for Safeway Vistoso Center, located on the northeast
corner of Tangerine Road and Rancho Vistoso Boulevard, requested
Young Electric Company, OV310-004. For questions and additional
information, please contact David Ronquillo, Senior Planner, at (520) 229-
4817or dronquillo@orovalleyaz.gov.
Staff Report
Attachment 1
http://orovalley.granicus.com/MinutesViewer.php?view_id=5&clip_id=1208 11/04/2011
- Development Review Board Page 3 of 5
Attachment 2
Josh Goins, non-resident representing Young Electric Company, stated that
the applicant is requesting a revision to the current sign plan for the Rancho
Vistoso Shopping Center. The Safeway Grocery Store has recently gone
through a recent sign program change and the existing signage is no longer
valid.
Member Luckett asked if the new Starbucks logo was to be included. Mr.
Goins responded that the Starbucks logo is not included.
David Ronquillo, Senior Planner presented the following:
- Request
- Context Map
- Existing Signage
- Proposed Signage - Safeway
- Signage - Fuel Center
- Compatibility with Adjacent Buildings
- Adjacent Signs
- Summary
MOTION: A motion was made by Member Shelton and seconded by
Member Ottley to approve OV1310-004, revised sign criteria for Safeway
Vistoso Center, located on the northeast corner of Tangerine Road and
Rancho Vistoso Boulevard.
MOTION carried, 4-0
3. Architectural elevations for La Canada Hills Animal Hospital on Lot 1,
Mercado at Canada Hills, located in proximity to La Canada Drive and
Lambert Road, requested by Eglin-Cohen Architects, OV1311-06. For
questions and additional information, please contact Matt Michels, Senior
Planner, at (520) 229-4822 or mmichels@orovalleyaz.gov
Staff Report
Attachment 1
Evan Elgin, non-resident representing the applicant, presented the
following:
- Location Map
- North, East and West Elevations
http://orovalley.granicus.com/MinutesViewer.php?view_id=5&clip_id=1208 11/04/2011
Development Review Board Page 4 of 5-
Member Luckett asked about the trellis to be added on the north side of the
building. Mr. Eglin responded that a trellis is proposed for the north
elevation.
Chairman Schoeppach asked Mr. Elgin if he was okay with conditions listed
in Exhibit "A". Mr. Elgin responded yes.
Matt Michels, Senior Planner, presented the following:
- Existing Development - Lot 4 & 5
- North, East
- Color & Material
- Findings/Recommendation
MOTION: A motion was made by Member Luckett and seconded by
Member Shelton to approve with conditions the architectural elevations for
La Canada Animal Hospital on Lot 1, Mercado at Canada Hills, located in
proximity to La Canada Drive and Lambert Road, requested by Elgin-
Cohen Architects, OV1311-06, subject to the conditions in Exhibit "A".
MOTION carried, 4-0
Dr. Mary Ann Bolser, non-resident but a Oro Valley business owner, stated
she has a couple of issues the Board should be aware of.
- She had problems applying for business loan, initially not approved
because the appraiser did not believe the fee that she would incur by Oro
Valley should be taken into consideration, adding $40,000 to the cost.
- The tower is not a very nice design feature and reminds her of a gun
turret. She was told to live with it because it would be difficult to get any
other changes approved by the Design Review Board.
4. Architectural elevations for two-story custom home on Lot 403, Stone
Canyon II-A, located at 1250 W. Tortolita Mountain Circle, requested by
Robinette Architects, OV1311-07.
Staff Report
Attachment
Ron Robinette, of Robinette Architects, presented an aerial view of the
proposed home. Mr. Robinette stated the home is under the 30' height
requirements for Oro Valley and have gone through subdivision process.
http://orovalley.granicus.com/MinutesViewer.php?view_id=5&clip_id=1208 11/04/2011
- Development Review Board Page 5 of 5
Matt Michels, Senior Planner, presented the following:
- Site Plan
- Floor Plans
- Elevations
- Findings/Recommendation
MOTION: A motion was made by Member Shelton and seconded by
Member Ottley to approve architectural elevations for two-story custom
home on Lot 403, Stone Canyon II-A, located at 1250 W. Tortolita Mountain
Circle, requested by Robinette Architects, OV1311-07.
MOTION carried, 4-0
5. Planning Division Manager update.
David Williams, Planning Division Manager, presented the following updates:
- Design Standards is set to go in front of Council the first week of July.
- Implementing the Environmentally Sensitive Lands ordinance approved by
Council on January 19th. The ordinance goes into effect July.
- Conceptual Design Review Board: The Council Work Group met April 4th to
review the new criteria now called the Design Principles that are to replace the
thirteen principles in the code today.
- Pre-application for a rezoning for a 70 lot subdivision on La Cholla between
Glover Road and Tangerine Road.
- Rezoning and a development plan for a church on a 17 acre site on Tangerine,
goes to Town Council on May 3rd for rezoning.
- Pre-application for a memory care facility at Oracle Vista Center.
Future Agenda for the DRB
- One item for May 10th, Gadabout Salon & Spa.
ADJOURNMENT REGULAR SESSION
MOTION: A motion was made by Member Ottley and seconded by Member
Shelton to adjourn the April 12, 2011 Development Review Board at 6:49
p.m.
MOTION carried, 4-0
http://orovalley.granicus.com/MinutesViewer.php?view_id=5&clip_id=1208 11/04/2011
-i a
4416411__ APPROVID BY:TC/P1144.0A
27 34..
[
+iiic-il:_ .-- _40+
_.... +4IV- * Ali• iff i...L. 176
.-----i -...-----
, I 1; 1_410H-44. pz
--.."---)--
.dai -IF 40 ff-,Tirp1;._
'
0 ..
.•.•. og......
. ....
. . ,
. .
...................- .....—
immili
..
NORTH ELEVATION •11 ; i H IN= •
. ri
_
... . r
n 411116--- r it
•
' - ........___ . 1
it
..„.. ..,saivre,whfaus, 4.0
* * • ,
14111ftweim ....
' ,g _ -.
• *
C. --. -IIII Ilicti 4M'
...7.7....-
ALL EX TERIOR COLORS AND MATERIALS SHALL MATCIt
r)osT1,40 sHopNsic crNirR.
t
.. . . .
-.1 Pr-- 4 •. .
lriP -pti
,
• i I ', ltr
1 -
....' _,..
_
.„ . . ,__......,
at ' •-
,,,-"Ar--
----.17
, -„,
z.:„...
-- 1" ,
(P)11111to., ...-
.4..,..,....
'
wow"
1 11•111M, ,
, 4... i r-
.. i . .
'
_ i
.,.<
77 ,
, . .. . •
... ›...•
,. •
i ..
__.......1 -
—,
,.
__
(
_ _
_ _ imp,
In 11. 6.6 1 . Am
i Ohm.'44 N „ m i---- • '
1/41A z . r..-1.- ? i EAST ELEVATION CAPP4,40.13.OVAL
g lep SILlin
MUM
••• id in€ mai imit A
,„..._.. ...x,.......,?...._ .
11141.41110113 Mk Waal \
Milk.SP01411110 Ikpl Mk it
i 44 iriek . . A Av.-, 64 MC"Mg —I a
.
: W e 151"FICP MIN Cal
,-..:IS r
. -:1• 1-16* I ....
, 'ri911. 3.44eff rilart .krai.r.+.
r ....._ #4 •... CI
1.• Mt --., * '. i 1 Mg. . • -,C ---d--"` 1 )11' 1..be-IP
3 "1" ) i- i ; n .. 4 91, i ,
i
. ... 3 , I
ri,„0 MLitt" 1 :13 . 'Iiiii— ' I#
..ama. ..., _Iwo, wra......
'... ..— =—.....' --Waasst Illilikli
114111r s'hi
I slt..4
ip,
-,--
- -E % 111/v --- ilkobtO fair",
'll A
teri
1 . .,_
. -. IIIIII
iroArr rt. ....
I'---
,.. -...: - _ 11
I)
1 I riii i, rte....F.olio-
i r
, .`.. 1 1 T rigna owl.ilil ‘Mg ffe4 4 r- - . . i
, $611331441.O&M s-lor-1
-,.. mir ----_Jl ' , g
-"moil; i e awsim
5 `.. . 1 ULM•i i i 1 1 1 11
e.i a G
MILD NO SECTION - 'A'
_ ri
—
Mi i . . . . ,.......,--, gr -
..
I IfolaWl....... "-
T ...., ,.... ,...
wpm,cos Vilrair-e
ri gm my
... k.:40 II
k ,
rai. fift...4 TA
Mriri":114
L." - . M 3! I it`-rivr ADJACENT OLD° 442.4„/ __-
4.11 hSer top, OV 121010 .._. .. .......L...1
I ,4
_ ill
lik. No- _ 4•10' 4, i
I
.....,Jr-tr ______ .4,-, _L71771054
II- it . .1111l, .. ,./". .411`_
-T ,— or ---„„,...... ---.. . ,, ....
rid' 1-14 r ,
e iz,, ..—..i _ I if, . _ ,, .. ,,,i..... • , te toll brat I ii Mommo, ______
Ir , ink.anima
I it
0 4E)
irierW coo-
,
IF! 'N.
II 1
ii 0* neat tabbibial
re ill
1 la:
i
0 0 1) MI co.
sb
# -'.4 4111111.M.111111111.1r
4 I D a immommill
..., ,,.•,.......... ...,,,,.4 'fffm'
...Impu„._,......_____ =anew.
sr r 1 _
(;) 0 f."1 0 40 ....4) '41 Ce ir towing
- i ....i. ROOF PLAN
I
-r 414 BULDINCi SECTION - iiir
FLOOR PLAN rte.'
,01....r
3555 SF lrtari-e ehlir 141k%
__Alert__ seLliti00114114,4
.41114 Q.Fla TONIMIN, 0
Csiada Hills / MERCADO AT LA CANIADA
speopenmei / ,
, LA CANADA HILLS ANIMAL HOSPITAL *IP 4 Weil 1.1404 MAI
,...mit Ippr-prab mos aoliiionli
44144 NOM**+C ORO VALLEY. ARMONA
DI.1 t.I I JONI 271!--le
OQO IV*
ouNDED 19�d
Development and Infrastructure Services
April 15, 2011
Evan Eglin
Eglin/Cohen Architects, P.0
7391 E. Tanque Verde Road
Tucson, AZ 85715
Via e-mail: evane(c�eglincohen.com
RE: Architectural elevations for La Canada Hills Animal Hospital on Lot 1, Mercado at
Canada Hills, located in proximity to La Canada Drive and Lambert Road, requested by Eglin-
Cohen Architects, OV1311-06.
Dear Evan,
At their regular meeting of April 12, 2011, the Development Review Board (DRB) voted unanimously
to approve the request for the architectural elevations for the above captioned building, subject to the
following conditions:
1. The north building elevation must provide acceptable design features and landscaping to break up
the blank wall mass on the eastern portion of the north façade. Design features may include pop
outs/recesses, additional windows (real or faux) or trellises as well as enhanced landscaping
along the elevation.
2. The exterior paint colors must match the colors of the existing buildings.
3. All rooftop mechanicals must be entirely screened from all surrounding properties. Provide
the design details or necessary photo simulations to ensure that the mechanicals will not be
visible from the adjacent homes.
Please provide evidence of conformance with the aforementioned conditions for certification of the
architecture. Please feel free to contact me with any questions.
Respectfully,
•
11/7/17A / n/ittL,,6,
„_
Matt Michels, AICP
Senior Planner
cc: Shirley Gay, OV Permitting Division
S:\PERMPLUS\DOCS\OV1311-06\P DRB Action 4-12-11.doc
Planning Permitting Inspection&Compliance Engineering Operations Transit
(520)229-4821 (520)229-4815 (520)229-4815 (520)229-4894 (520)229-5070 (520)229-4990
Caring for our heritage, our community, our future.
11000 N.La Canada Drive•Oro Valley,Arizona 85737
fax (520)742-1022•www.orovalleyaz.gov
11/17/2011
-- Inspection Notice
_,, , ip.0
Town of Oro Valley Building Safety Tel. (520) 229-4800
41 .-, 11000 N La Canada Dr Fax (520) 742-1022
, .! Oro Valley, AZ 85737 Web: www.townoforovalley.com
License/AP #: C1100014 Type: CTI Status: REVISION
Address: 10580 N LA CANADA DR
Inspector: Jonathan Lew
Resp Party: BOCK COMMERCIAL CONSTRUCTION L L C - CONTRACTOR (P)
Inspection Item Item Description Result
9028 C of 0 Zoning PA
Result Notes: Okay for Temporary C of O. Please address the comment in the
Zoning Architecture inspection.
9700 Zoning Outdoor Lighting AP
9701 Zoning Mechanical Equipment Screening AP
9703 Zoning Architecture FL
Result Notes: The colors on the building and in the approved building permit set
do not match the colors shown in the approved DRB file
(OV 13-10-13). Per Senior Planner Karen Berchtold, a revision to
case OV 13-10-13 is required. Please submit for the revision
showing the existing building colors. A set of revised building
plans is not required.
S,
CAD 1- --1
oQ .
—� -QC\
� os
P c Ot�
Page 1ofl