Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPackets - Planning and Zoning Commission (168)       AGENDA ORO VALLEY PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION REGULAR SESSION December 1, 2020 JOIN ZOOM MEETING: https://orovalley.zoom.us/j/95005803678?pwd=QVFJNDBvY1dna0dhYTg5WXp6UGVNZz09 To dial by phone: 1-346-248-7799, enter meeting ID: 95005803678 and passcode: 781767 Executive Sessions – Upon a vote of the majority of the Planning and Zoning Commission, the Commission may enter into Executive Sessions pursuant to Arizona Revised Statues §38-431.03 (A)(3) to obtain legal advice on matters listed on the Agenda.        REGULAR SESSION AT OR AFTER 6:00 PM   CALL TO ORDER   ROLL CALL   PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE   CALL TO AUDIENCE - at this time, any member of the public is allowed to address the Commission on any issue not listed on today’s agenda. Pursuant to the Arizona open meeting law, individual Commission members may ask Town staff to review the matter, ask that the matter be placed on a future agenda, or respond to criticism made by speakers. However, the Commission may not discuss or take legal action on matters raised during "Call to Audience." In order to speak during "Call to Audience", please specify what you wish to discuss when completing the blue speaker card.   COUNCIL LIAISON COMMENTS   REGULAR SESSION AGENDA   1.REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF THE NOVEMBER 10, 2020 SPECIAL SESSION MEETING MINUTES   2.DISCUSSION AND POSSIBLE ACTION ON A REVISED SIGN CRITERIA FOR THE SHOPS AT ORO VISTA LOCATED ON THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF LA CANADA DRIVE AND LAMBERT LANE   3.DISCUSSION REGARDING THE TOWN’S PROGRESS ON IMPLEMENTING THE YOUR VOICE, OUR FUTURE GENERAL PLAN   4.DISCUSSION REGARDING THE PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION SCHEDULED MEETING DATES FOR 2021   5.DISCUSSION REGARDING PLANNING STAFF REPORTS AND POWERPOINT PRESENTATIONS      PLANNING UPDATE (INFORMATIONAL ONLY)   ADJOURNMENT     POSTED: 11/24/2020 at 5:00 p.m. by pp When possible, a packet of agenda materials as listed above is available for public inspection at least 24 hours prior to the Commission meeting in the Town Clerk's Office between the hours of 8:00 a.m. – 5:00 p.m. The Town of Oro Valley complies with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). If any person with a disability needs any type of accommodation, please notify the Town Clerk’s Office at least five days prior to the Commission meeting at 229-4700. INSTRUCTIONS TO SPEAKERS Members of the public have the right to speak during any posted public hearing. However, those items not listed as a public hearing are for consideration and action by the Commission during the course of their business meeting. Members of the public may be allowed to speak on these topics at the discretion of the Chair. In accordance with Amendment #2 of the Mayoral Proclamation of Emergency issued on March 27, 2020, the following restrictions have been placed on all public meetings until further notice: 1. In-person attendance by members of the public is prohibited. 2. Members of the public can either watch the public meeting online https://www.orovalleyaz.gov/town/departments/town-clerk/meetings-and-agendas or, if they would like to participate in the meeting (e.g. speak at Call to Audience or speak on a Regular Agenda item), they can attend the meeting and participate via the on-line meeting application Zoom: https://orovalley.zoom.us/j/95005803678?pwd=QVFJNDBvY1dna0dhYTg5WXp6UGVNZz09 or may participate telephonically only by dialing 1-346-248-7799 and enter meeting ID:95005803678 and passcode: 781767 prior to or during the posted meeting. 3. If a member of the public would like to speak at either Call to Audience or on a Regular Agenda item, it is highly encouraged to email your request to speak to jancona@orovalleyaz.gov and include your name and town/city of residence in order to provide the Mayor/Chair with advance notice so you can be called upon more efficiently during the Zoom meeting. 4. All members of the public who participate in the Zoom meeting either with video or telephonically will enter the meeting with microphones muted. For those participating via computer/tablet/phone device, you may choose whether to turn your video on or not. If you have not provided your name to speak prior to the meeting as specified in #3 above, you will have the opportunity to be recognized when you “raise your hand.” Those participating via computer/tablet/phone device can click the “raise your hand” button during the Call to the Public or Regular Agenda item, and the Chair will call on you in order, following those who submit their names in advance. For those participating by phone, you can press *9, which will show the Chair that your hand is raised. When you are recognized at the meeting by the Chair, your microphone will be unmuted by a member of staff and you will have three minutes to speak before your microphone is again muted. 5. If a member of the public would like to submit written comments to the Planning and Zoning Commission for their consideration prior to the meeting, please email those comments to jancona@orovalleyaz.gov, no later than sixty minutes before the public meeting. Those comments will then be electronically distributed to the public body prior to the meeting. If you have any questions, please contact the Commission’s recording secretary at jancona@orovalleyaz.gov. Thank you for your cooperation. “Notice of Possible Quorum of the Oro Valley Town Council, Boards, Commissions and Committees: In accordance with Chapter 3, Title 38, Arizona Revised Statutes and Section 2-4-4 of the Oro Valley Town Code, a majority of the Town Council, Board of Adjustment, Historic Preservation Commission, Parks and Recreation Advisory Board, Stormwater Utility Commission, and Water Utility Commission may attend the above referenced meeting as a member of the audience only.”    Planning & Zoning Commission 1. Meeting Date:12/01/2020   Requested by: Bayer Vella, Community and Economic Development  Case Number: N/A SUBJECT: REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF THE NOVEMBER 10, 2020 SPECIAL SESSION MEETING MINUTES RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends approval. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: N/A BACKGROUND OR DETAILED INFORMATION: N/A FISCAL IMPACT: N/A SUGGESTED MOTION: I MOVE to approve (approve with changes), the November 10, 2020 meeting minutes as written. Attachments 11-10-2020 Draft Minutes  D R A F T MINUTES ORO VALLEY PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION SPECIAL SESSION November 10, 2020 MEETING HELD VIA ZOOM            SPECIAL SESSION AT OR AFTER 6:00 PM   CALL TO ORDER Chair Gambill called the meeting to order at 6:00 p.m.   ROLL CALL Present: Hal Bergsma, Commissioner Neal Herst, Commissioner Ellen Hong, Commissioner Skeet Posey, Commissioner Daniel Sturmon, Commissioner Celeste Gambill, Chair Absent: Jacob Herrington, Vice Chair Staff Present:Joe Andrews, Chief Civil Deputy Attorney Michael Spaeth, Principal Planner Attendees: Melanie Barrett, Town Council Liaison PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Chair Gambill recited the Pledge of Allegiance to the Commission and audience.   CALL TO AUDIENCE There were no speaker requests.   COUNCIL LIAISON COMMENTS Council Liaison Melanie Barrett provide updates on past and upcoming Town Council meetings as related to Planning cases.   SPECIAL SESSION AGENDA   1.REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF THE OCTOBER 27, 2020 SPECIAL SESSION MEETING MINUTES       Motion by Commissioner Hal Bergsma, seconded by Commissioner Skeet Posey to approve the October 27, 2020 meeting minutes as written.    A roll call vote was taken:  A roll call vote was taken: Commissioner Bergsma - Aye Commissioner Herst - Aye Commissioner Hong - Aye Commissioner Posey - Aye Commissioner Sturmon - Aye Chair Gambill - Aye    Vote: 6 - 0 Carried   2.PUBLIC HEARING: DISCUSSION REGARDING THE PROPOSED 1ST AVENUE AND TANGERINE ROAD GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT AND REZONING FOR A 13.44-ACRE MULTI-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT, LOCATED SOUTH OF TANGERINE ROAD AND APPROXIMATELY 0.2 MILES EAST OF 1ST AVENUE A. TYPE 1 GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT TO CHANGE TWO KAI-CAPRI SPECIAL AREA POLICIES TO ALLOW MULTI-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL USES ON A VACANT COMMERCIAL PARCEL (2001085) B. REZONING TO CHANGE THE ZONING DESIGNATION OF A VACANT PARCEL FROM C-1 COMMERCIAL TO R-6 MULTI-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL (2001306)       Senior Planner Hannah Oden provided a presentation that included the following: - Purpose - Location - Applicant's Request - Key Considerations - Background and History: General Plan and Special Area Polices - Background and History: Rezoning - A. Applicant's request: General Plan Amendment - A. General Plan Amendment Criteria Analysis - A. Vacant Commercial Parcels Transition to Residential - B. Applicant's Request: Rezoning - B. Proposed Tentative Development Plans - Public Participation - Your Voice, Our Future General Plan and Zoning Code Conformance - Summary and Recommendation Applicant Paul Oland, with Paradigm Land Design, provided a presentation that included the following: - Background - Special area policies and overall master plan - Updated road connection to Tangerine and First Avenue since original rezoning - Aerial photo of grading when Arizona Department of Transportation (ADOT) built the Tangerine Bridge - Commercial areas surrounding subject parcel - Struggling commercial areas along Oracle Road - Valbridge Economic Impact Analysis report - Proposed tentative development plans - Multi-family/apartments will provide needed diverse housing options Discussion ensued among the Commission and the applicant. Chair Gambill opened the public hearing. Oro Valley resident Devon Sloane spoke on agenda item #2. Oro Valley resident Dave Perry spoke in support of agenda item #2. Chair Gambill closed the public hearing. Further discussion continued among the Commission, the applicant and staff.    Motion by Commissioner Daniel Sturmon, seconded by Commissioner Neal Herst move to recommend approval of the Type 1 General Plan Amendment to change two Kai-Capri Special Area policies to allow multi-family residential development on the subject parcel located southeast of the 1st Avenue and Tangerine Road intersection, based on the finding that the request complies with the amendment criteria and the General Plan.    A roll call vote was taken: Commissioner Bergsma - Aye Commissioner Herst - Aye Commissioner Hong - Aye Commissioner Posey - Aye Commissioner Sturmon - Aye Chair Gambill - Aye    Vote: 6 - 0 Carried    Motion by Commissioner Hal Bergsma, seconded by Commissioner Daniel Sturmon move to recommend approval of the 1st Avenue and Tangerine Road rezoning, removing the existing zoning designation of C-1 and adding the zoning designation of multi-family residential R-6, based on the finding the request complies with the Town of Oro Valley Zoning Code and the General Plan, subject to Conditions 2 and 7 listed in Attachment 1 of the November 10, 2020 staff report, as well as the following conditions: only tentative development plan Exhibits III-C-2a Apartments and III-C-2b Rental Casitas are included for the rezoning, and staff recommended Condition 3 is modified to remove mention of Exhibit III-C-2d Townhomes. To clarify, staff recommended Conditions of Approval 4, 5 and 6 are not included in this motion, since they are not relevant to the recommended tentative development plans.    Staff asked questions to clarify the motion proposed.    A roll call vote was taken: Commissioner Bergsma - Aye Commissioner Herst - Aye Commissioner Hong - Aye Commissioner Posey - Aye Commissioner Sturmon - Aye Chair Gambill - Aye    Vote: 6 - 0 Carried   PLANNING UPDATE (INFORMATIONAL ONLY) Principal Planner Michael Spaeth provided updates on an upcoming neighborhood meeting and items on the December and January Planning and Zoning Commission meeting agendas.   ADJOURNMENT    Motion by Commissioner Daniel Sturmon, seconded by Commissioner Skeet Posey to adjourn the meeting.    Chair Gambill adjourned the meeting at 7:44 p.m.     I hereby certify that the foregoing minutes are a true and correct copy of the minutes of the regular session of the Town of Oro Valley Planning and Zoning Commission of Oro Valley, Arizona held on the 10th day of November, 2020. I further certify that the meeting was duly called and held and that a quorum was present. Dated this 16th day of November, 2020. ___________________________ Jeanna Ancona Senior Office Specialist    Planning & Zoning Commission 2. Meeting Date:12/01/2020   Requested by: Bayer Vella, Community and Economic Development  Case Number: 2002600 SUBJECT: DISCUSSION AND POSSIBLE ACTION ON A REVISED SIGN CRITERIA FOR THE SHOPS AT ORO VISTA LOCATED ON THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF LA CANADA DRIVE AND LAMBERT LANE RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends approval of the revised sign criteria for the Shops at Oro Vista as shown in Attachment 1.  EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: The purpose of this request is to consider a revised sign criteria for the Shops at Oro Vista. The Shops at Oro Vista is a commercial development that contains a variety of businesses such as Noble Hops, Chase Bank and the newly redeveloped former Big 5 building along with an apartment complex. This submittal is to update the signage on the property and is not an architectural or site plan review.  The zoning code requires that a multi-tenant development establish reasonable sign regulations to provide effective communication while preserving the unique character of the Town. This proposal is a revision to the current sign criteria that was established for the development in 2011 (Attachment 2). The revised sign criteria will preserve the design of the current monument signs which includes elements of copper, both patina and polished, along with bronze which can be found in architectural elements on buildings within the development. The monument signs will also continue to use stucco and stone veneer to blend with the buildings found on the site. The sign design continues to compliment development's aesthetics with a proposal to allow an increase in size and quantity in the future.  All signs proposed in this new sign criteria meet the standards of the zoning code. The request is to update the current sign standards which includes:  Allowing wall sign letters of different types i.e.: pan channel, reverse pan channel, flat cut.   The use of either halo or internal illumination for wall signs  Expanding the color palette for the wall signs and entryway signs Allowing an increase in size and quantity of monument signs up to the zoning code standards  Clarifying and simplifying the standards to align with the current zoning code The Planning and Zoning Commission is the review and approving body for a Sign Criteria. The proposed sign criteria is in conformance with the Oro Valley Zoning Code and staff recommends approval. BACKGROUND OR DETAILED INFORMATION: Related Approvals:  2003: The commercial and apartment site was approved  2003 to 2008: Signs for each business were individually approved by the Development Review Board 2007: Sign criteria was established 2011: The sign criteria was revised to add two more wall sign colors Existing Site Conditions  Zoning is El Conquistador Planned Area Development (PAD) 13 acre site The site contains an apartment complex, 4 commercial buildings and 1 vacant parcel for future development The primary focus of the proposed revisions is to bring the sign criteria in-line with the allowances of the zoning code in terms of wall sign types, illumination, colors and monument sign size and quantity.  Wall Sign Type and Illumination Wall signs are individual letters and/or logos attached to the exterior wall of the tenant space that provide identification for the business.   Current: Reverse pan channel with halo illumination Proposed: Allow both pan channel and reserve pan channel with halo or internal illumination Below are examples of reverse pan channel halo illuminated letters and a pan channel internally illuminated letters.  Reverse Pan Channel                           Pan Channel  Halo lit letters                                       Internally lit letters     Both letters types and illumination are allowed in the zoning code but the shopping center's current sign criteria only allows the reverse pan channel halo lit type of sign. The goal is to update the sign criteria to allow both.  Colors The zoning code allows all colors except florescent and iridescent.  Current: Three colors are allowed in the sign criteria for wall signs in addition to registered trademark logos.  Proposed: A total of 17 colors as shown in the applicant's submittal (Attachment 1) and continue to allow registered trademark logos. The proposed colors meet the standards of the zoning code. The goal of the revised sign criteria is to provide a broader choice of sign colors for the tenants as allowed by the zoning code.  Monument and Entryway Signs Monument signs are freestanding signs placed near the main street of the development that identify the center and its tenants. Entryway signs also identify the development and are placed on perimeter walls at entrances to the development.   Current:  Four entryway signs with copper patina letters.  Two monument signs at 50 square feet in size  Proposed:  Continue to allow the 4 entryway signs but will a broader color palette. Allow up to four monument signs at 72 sq ft which is the quantity and size allowed by the zoning code. There is not a significant change in the designs proposed for the monument and entry signs. The goal is to allow the monument signs to increase in quantity and size as allowed in the zoning code. Discussion/Analysis: Applicable Design Standards and Design Principals are below in italics followed by staff commentary: Sign colors, design and placement shall be complementary and integral to the projects architectural and site design themes. Project identification and sign elements shall incorporate architectural treatment and project unifying elements which are integrated with the overall design of the project in terms of style, materials, color and theme . As feasible, sign colors shall utilize the project color palette approved as part of the Conceptual Design for the project. The monument sign style will remain complimentary to the site by continuing the use of architectural elements found throughout the buildings such as stone veneer and stucco. The signs will also use copper and bronze that are also an integral part of the building design. The primary change to the monument signs is allowing a future increase in size and quantity.  The entryway signs that currently read "Oro Vista Apartments" are proposed to change the letter color from copper patina to one of the colors listed in the new criteria.  The signs will continue to be located on the stuccoed entryway walls which match the color of the development. General Plan The proposed sign criteria was reviewed for conformance with the General Plan’s Goals and Policies. Listed below are relevant policies within the General Plan relating to signage: Goal Q: A built environment that creatively integrates landscape, architecture, open space and conservation elements to increase the sense of place, community interaction and quality of life. Policy Land Use 6: Maintain the small town, neighborly character and improve the design and safety of the built environment. Action item #125: Maintain the unique character of Oro Valley by studying and updating: Signage regulations to emphasize identification and direction over advertising goods or services to maintain compatibility and minimal intrusiveness. The proposed sign criteria will allow for better identification for businesses in the development while maintaining architecturally compatible and non-intrusive monument signs.    Summary The proposed sign criteria will bring the Shops at Oro Vista sign allowances up to the standards allowed in the current zoning code. Bringing the sign criteria in-line with the zoning code includes:  Allowing wall sign letters of different types i.e.: pan channel, reverse pan channel, flat cut Allowing either halo or internal illumination for wall signs  Expanding the color palette for the wall and entryway signs Allowing the size and quantity of monuments signs to increase Clarifying and simplifying the standards  The proposed standards will allow the Shops at Oro Vista development to provide updated and effective signage for the property and its tenants. Recommendation All changes proposed in the revised sign criteria (Attachment 1) meet the standards of the zoning code. Therefore, staff recommends approval of the proposed sign criteria. FISCAL IMPACT: N/A SUGGESTED MOTION: The Planning and Zoning Commission may consider one of the following motions: I MOVE to approve the sign criteria for the Shops at Oro Vista as depicted in Attachment 1, based on the finding that the criteria are consistent with the Design Standards and Principles of the Zoning Code. OR I MOVE to deny the sign criteria for the Shops at Oro Vista as depicted in Attachment 1 based on the finding that ______________. Attachments Attachment 1 Proposed Sign Criteria  Attachment 2 Current Sign Criteria  THE SHOPS AT ORO VISTA SIGN CRITERIA - REVISED 2020 REVISED 10-5-20 ORO VALLEY LUXURY APARTMENTS 224-522-70 CORNER SHOPS 224-250-25D INLINE SHOPS 224-252-240 BANK ONE 224-250-25F INLINE SHOPS 224-252-50 PARKING LOT 224-252-60 DEVELOPMENT AT SOUTHEST CORNER OF LA CANADA & LAMBERT LANE Shops at Oro Vista is updating their sign criteria in order to bring the criteria more in line with the present sign code of Oro Valley. The new criteria will allow for color options to be expanded from the original color palette. The new sign criteria will allow logos per the tenant design. This update will accommodate new tenants that are moving in to the center, including TMC One and Arizona Blood and Cancer Specialists. NARRATIVE DEVELOPMENT AT SOUTHEST CORNER OF LA CANADA & LAMBERT LANE THE SHOPS AT ORO VISTA SIGN CRITERIA - REVISED 2020 DEVELOPMENT AT SOUTHEST CORNER OF LA CANADA & LAMBERT LANE Purpose: The following sign criteria has been created for the Shops at Oro Vista, to ensure that sign colors, design and placement are complementary and integrated into the property's architectural design themes. This criteria, once approved by the Town of Oro Valley, will serve as a binding guide to sign design for this property. Apartment Complex: 1. ENTRYWAY SIGNS: a. There shall be (4) four entryway signs on the property. b. The size of the wall sign shall not exceed 32 square feet and be no higher than 6 feet from grade. Shopping Center: 2. MONUMENT SIGNS: a. There shall be no more than four (4) freestanding monument signs for the shopping center b. Signs shall have 2-4 tenant panels with routed out /backed up copy. i. The landlord shall determine the final location for each tenant panel on the sign. c. The signs shall be illuminated. d. The sign shall be double sided. e. Signs shall have Seventy-two (72) square feet in area f. The maximum height of each sign is eight (8) feet above grade as allowed by OVZC. An architectural element of the sign, such as an arch or column, may exceed the height of the monument sign by twenty-five percent (25%) provided, that all text and logos are eight (8) feet or less in height from grade. THE SHOPS AT ORO VISTA SIGN CRITERIA - REVISED 2020 EXISTING MONUMENT SIGNS DEVELOPMENT AT SOUTHEST CORNER OF LA CANADA & LAMBERT LANE Monument and entryway signs include, but are not limited to: 1. Base to be aluminum with stucco finish to match building, or stone to match stone accents on building. 2. Face panel colors to match Deep Mahogany Brown PMS 4625c 3. Tenant names to be white 4. Copper patina between top cap and sign cabinet to match existing signage. 5. Cabinet retainer/divider to be Deep Mahogany Brown to match faces 6. Top cap and accents to be painted Copper Metallic. 7. Address to be Deep Mahogany Brown to match cabinet/face 8. Entryway signs to be painted a color chosen from the approved color list. 9. Entryway sign letters and pillbox to be mounted to backing panel attached to entry walls 10. Entryway sign pillbox section to be routed metal, backed with white plex and illuminated with white LED’S. 1 0 3 7 0 THE SHOPS AT ORO VISTA SIGN CRITERIA - REVISED 2020 DEVELOPMENT AT SOUTHEST CORNER OF LA CANADA & LAMBERT LANE 3. WALL SIGNS: a. The following wall sign types are allowed: Pan Channel letters, Reverse Pan Channel letters, or Flat Cut-Out letters, non-illuminated, internal illumination, halo illumination (white only) and other sign types as allowed in the OVZC. b. Registered Business logos and trademarks will be accepted. c. Sign may not project more than eight (8) inches from the wall on which the sign is mounted. d. No sign shall be wider than 80% of the leased tenant space. e. Area: Sign area per OVZC sign measurement standards. f. No wall sign shall extend above the roofline of a building. g. All transformers/power supplies shall be remote or Raceway mounted. h. Shall be submitted for approval by the landlord. i. Colors: Shall conform to the colors shown on page 4, attached. 4. WINDOW SIGNS: a. Per OVZC Window sign requirements 5. TEMPORARY SIGNS: a. Per OVZC Window sign requirements. Various shades and tones of the following colors will be acceptable.These colors were pulled from the previous sign criteria and will be included in the new. LIGHT BLUE TURQUOISEDEEP MAHONANY BROWN COPPER PATINA GRAYWHITEBROWN BLACK AQUAPURPLEORANGEYELLOWGREENBLUERED COLOR OPTIONS DURANODIC PMS 439C PMS 410C THE SHOPS AT ORO VISTA SIGN CRITERIA - REVISED 2020 DEVELOPMENT AT SOUTHEST CORNER OF LA CANADA & LAMBERT LANE Deep Mahogany Brown 19 PMS 4625 C 220, 225-19    Planning & Zoning Commission 3. Meeting Date:12/01/2020   Requested by: Bayer Vella, Community and Economic Development  Case Number: N/A SUBJECT: DISCUSSION REGARDING THE TOWN’S PROGRESS ON IMPLEMENTING THE YOUR VOICE, OUR FUTURE GENERAL PLAN RECOMMENDATION: This item is for informational purposes only. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: The purpose of this item is to report the Town’s progress on implementing the Your Voice, Our Future General Plan. The Planning Division's current work plan includes updating the Planning and Zoning Commission on the land use and zoning-related items. Specifically, to assist in reviewing the associated work plan progress report. The General Plan is a 10-year policy document that guides all Town departments and decisions through 2026. Extensive community input was gathered through outreach events, committees and surveys to create the General Plan. This three-year long process, resulted in over 71% of the voters ratifying the General Plan in 2016. The community’s vision and guiding principles provide the foundation for building the goals, policies and actions in the General Plan. The actions were created by the General Plan committees’ to produce tangible results and deliver on the promises made to the community.  The actions are prioritized every two years through strategic plans and implemented through individual department work plans; such as the Planning Division Work Plan. This update serves as a commitment to the Oro Valley residents to provide transparency on implementing the General Plan.   There are 310 action items in the General Plan. They are divided amongst three main sections to carry out the goals and policies related to the Community, Environment and Development.  Of the 310 action items, 82 are related to land use and zoning In 2019, the Town reported 126 outstanding items (for previous staff report and findings, click here). These items were either being worked on (in progress) or recommended for future strategic plans (future items).   Of the 126 outstanding items, 38 are related to land use and zoning A summary and detailed analysis of all 126 outstanding items is included in Attachment 1. Items related to land use and zoning are highlighted in yellow. Notable elements include:  Ninety percent (92%; 286 out of 310) of all action items are either completed, in progress or maintained through staff's daily duties. This is a 9% increase from last year.  Progress has been made on the outstanding land use and zoning related items. Of the 38 remaining items, 12 have been completed or maintained and 20 are being worked on through various projects. Notable accomplishments and updates include:  Several zoning code amendments were approved by Town Council to address actions related to economic development. These include updating the uses allowed in Tech-Park and commercial centers, allowing shovel-ready sites in the Economic Expansion Zone and establishing more realistic and enforceable standards for noise and odor. Public engagement and input significantly increased by launching informational videos about development proposals and hosting online meetings.  Additional code amendments were approved to increase customer service. These include updating the variance findings and allowing minor setback reductions to be administratively approved. Updates to the development review process and the Design Principles and Standards are also in progress. Staff evaluated the Environmentally Sensitive Lands Ordinance and identified known gaps. Although budget constraints preclude the Town from contracting a habitat specialist and biologist at this time, staff is researching policies to resolve several of the known deficiencies. These include additional standards for preservation, health determination, transplant potential and procedures for Saguaros and Ironwood trees, etc.   Efficiencies were gained in the development review process through electronic plan submittals and increases in department coordination.  In coordination with the Town Manager's Office and several other departments, an annexation blueprint policy was approved by Town Council in July 2020. The 6 (of the 24 total) remaining land use and zoning related items (notated as future items) require additional resources and are recommended for a future strategic plan or work plan. In summary, the General Plan has been in effect since November 2016 and served as the basis for two strategic plans. Three more strategic plans will be created from this General Plan to complete or evaluate all future items. Since its ratification, 92% of the tasks have been or are currently being implemented.  This item is being provided for information and discussion only, as directed by the Planning Work Plan. Should the Planning and Zoning Commission have questions regarding land use and zoning tasks related to other departments, please let Planning staff know before the December 1, 2020 meeting to assure the applicable representatives are present.  BACKGROUND OR DETAILED INFORMATION: The Your Voice, Our Future General Plan is a 10-year policy document that guides all Town department and decision-making. The General Plan was ratified by 71% of the voters in 2016 and includes the goals, policies and actions needed to achieve the community's vision.  The General Plan is divided into three main sections focusing on the community, environment and development. Each section includes goals, policies and actions needed to fulfill the community’s vision. Specifically, the actions were created by the General Plan committees’ to produce tangible results and deliver on the promises made to the community.  There are a total of 310 action items (82 related to land use and zoning). In 2019, the Town reported 126 outstanding action items (for previous report and findings, click here). These items were either being worked on (in progress) or recommended for future strategic plans (38 related to land use and zoning). The actions are prioritized every two years through strategic plans and implemented through  individual department work plans; such as the Planning Division Work Plan. Two strategic leadership plans have been created based on this General Plan; the most recent being adopted in March 2019. Staff anticipates three more Strategic Plans prior to 2026. This will help ensure all actions are addressed over the General Plan's 10-year term. This update serves as a commitment to Oro Valley residents to provide transparency on implementing the General Plan. A summary and detailed analysis of all 126 outstanding items is included in Attachment 1. The role of the Planning and Zoning Commission is to advise on action items related to land use and zoning (highlighted in yellow in Attachment 1). A summary is provided below.   DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS: 1. Community The community actions implement the goals and policies for creating a robust economy, complete community, safe environment and exemplary Town services. The following information only refers to the items related to land use and zoning.  Total action items related to land use and zoning: 15   Actions previously reported as outstanding: 10  Update on outstanding items:  Completed, maintained or in progress: 9 Recommended for future strategic plans: 1 Notable accomplishments or updates:  Several zoning code amendments were approved by Town Council to address actions related to economic development. These include updating the uses allowed in Tech-Park and commercial centers, allowing shovel-ready sites in the Economic Expansion Zone and establishing more realistic and enforceable standards for noise and odor.  Public engagement and input significantly increased by launching informational videos about development proposals and hosting online meetings. The videos had roughly 400-1400 views and participation in online meetings ranged from 40-150 people.  Additional code amendments were approved to increase customer service. These include updating the variance findings and allowing minor setback reductions to be administratively approved. Updates to the development review process and the Design Principles and Standards are also in progress. 2. Environment The environment actions implement the goals and policies for protecting natural and cultural resources and maintaining a clean environment . The following information only refers to the items related to land use and zoning.  Total action items related to land use and zoning: 33  Actions previously reported as outstanding: 13  Update on outstanding items:  Completed, maintained or in progress: 11 Recommended for future strategic plans: 2  Notable accomplishments or updates:  The majority of the action items related to land use and zoning focus on conserving environmental resources. Staff evaluated the Environmentally Sensitive Lands Ordinance and identified known gaps. Although budget constraints preclude the Town from contracting a habitat specialist and biologist at this time, staff is researching policies to resolve several of the known deficiencies. These include additional standards for preservation, health determination, transplant potential and procedures for Saguaros and Ironwood trees, etc. 3. Development The Development section includes the goals and policies needed to support existing and future development areas with respect to land use, transportation and infrastructure .The following information only refers to the items related to land use and zoning.  Total action items related to land use and zoning: 33 Actions previously reported as outstanding: 15  Update on outstanding items:  Completed, maintained or in progress: 12 Recommended for future strategic plans: 3 Notable accomplishments or updates:  Efficiencies were gained in the development review process through electronic plan submittals and increases in department coordination. In coordination with the Town Manager's Office and several other departments, an annexation blueprint policy was approved by Town Council in July 2020. The Design Principles and Standards are in the process of being updated to fix minor errors and address known gaps. However, staff recommends expanding the scope of this project to include more actions related to community gathering places and walk-ability.  Future items: In total, the amount of tasks (related to land use and zoning) to be evaluated or completed in the future reduced from 10 to 6. These include the following code amendments that need additional time and resources (consultants) to complete:  Technical updates to the lighting requirements (2 tasks) Updating the Master Planned Community code requirements (1 item) Expanding the scope of the Design Principles and Design Standards amendment to bolster community gathering places, mixed-use zoning and the pedestrian experience (3 items) Staff recommends these items be placed on future strategic plans and the Planning Work Plan. The next Planning Work Plan will be presented to the Commission in late Spring 2021 (before the current plan expires in June 2021). SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION: In summary, the General Plan has been in effect since 2016 and has served as the basis for two strategic plans. The strategic plans direct staff by prioritizing the goals and policies of the General Plan in two-year increments. The strategic plans, individual department work plans, such as the Planning Division Work Plan, and other Town initiatives have led to approximately 92% of the 310 tasks being completed, maintained or in progress.  The role of the Planning and Zoning Commission is to advise on action items related to land use and zoning (see yellow highlighted items in Attachment 1). Of the 82 actions related to land use and zoning, 38 were reported outstanding in 2019. Progress has been made on several of these items by:  Completing 5 items- included several zoning code amendments to address actions related to economic development, an annexation blueprint policy and efficient review process. Maintaining 7 items- includes community engagement and existing code requirements In process of completing 20 items- includes evaluation of the Environmentally Sensitive Lands Ordinance to identify gaps, and preliminary work on the Design Principles and Standards Recommending 6 items for future strategic plans and work plans- these items require additional resources for completion This item is being provided for information and discussion only, as directed by the Planning Work Plan. Should the Planning and Zoning Commission have questions regarding land use and zoning tasks related to other departments, please let Planning staff know before the December 1, 2020 meeting to assure the applicable representatives are present.  FISCAL IMPACT: N/A SUGGESTED MOTION: This item is for informational purposes only.  Attachments ATTACHMENT 1- GENERAL PLAN UPDATE ON LAND USE AND ZONING ITEMS  1 YOUR VOICE, OUR FUTURE GENERAL PLAN 2020 UPDATE BRIEF SUMMARY ACTION ITEMS ACCOMPLISHMENTS (71%) TASKS TO COMPLETE (29%) Community actions (pg. 2) 123 Total tasks completed 84 Total tasks currently in progress 66 Environment actions (pg. 16) 116 Development actions (pg. 31) 71 Total tasks maintained through ongoing operations 136 Remaining tasks to evaluate or complete in the future 24 Total 310 2019 STATUS 2020 UPDATE ON THE 126 REMAINING TASKS (PREVIOUSLY REPORTED AS IN PROGRESS OR FUTURE ITEMS) Completed items 69 Completed items +15 Maintained items 115 Maintained items +21 In progress 73 In progress 66 Future items 53 Future items 24 General Plan 2016-2026 Strategic Leadership Plans Town Department Work Plans Staff Resources/ Annual Budget Purpose The Your Voice, Our Future General Plan was ratified by the voters in November 2016. The General Plan consists of the community ’s vision and goals for the Town and is used as a guide in long range decision - making. The General Plan is a long-range 10-year policy document designed to guide the Town through 2026. Implementing the General Plan The community ’s vision and guiding principles provide the foundation, building the goals, policies and actions in the General Plan. The actions fulfill the goals and policies of the General Plan and are intended to be somewhat flexible as priorities and resources shift. The actions are prioritized every two years through the Town Council’s Strategic Leadership Plan. These priorities are translated to individual Town Department Work Plans for implementation. As a commitment to the Town Council and Oro Valley residents, the following information provides an update on the remaining 126 items to complete from the General Plan. TOTAL TASKS CURRENTLY IN PROGRESS REMAINING TASKS TO EVALUATE OR COMPLETE IN THE FUTURE Key Points: • 92% of the action items are complete, maintained or actively being worked on (compared to 83% in 2019) • The Town is almost ½ way through the 10-year timeframe for the General Plan. Three more strategic leadership plans will be based on this General Plan to prioritize and direct resources towards completing or evaluating the remaining items. 2 COMMUNITY ACTIONS 2019 SUMMARY 2020 UPDATE ON THE 52 REMAINING TASKS ACCOMPLISHMENTS (70%) TASKS TO COMPLETE (30%) Completed 23 Completed +6 Total tasks completed 29 Total tasks currently in progress 34 Maintained 48 Maintained +9 In progress 43 In Progress 34 Total tasks maintained through ongoing operations 57 Remaining tasks to evaluate or complete in the future 3 Future items 9 Future items 3 ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT- REMAINING TASKS NO. TASK TIMEFRAME DEPT. STATUS COMMENTS SLP 2019 2020 4 Evaluate and increase the community’s economic opportunities while balancing community needs and desires through planning and analysis measures that: A. Modify land use regulations as needed to encourage new business opportunities in industrial, commercial and mixed-use areas. Medium TM, CED In Progress Complete • The Comprehensive Economic Development Strategy (CEDS) was adopted by Town Council in 2019. The strategy identifies several barriers and opportunities to expand economic development in balance with the community’s values. • A study was completed in 2017, identifying the lack of density in Oro Valley as a barrier for retail development. An apartment study was completed in 2020 to further assist decisions about higher-density housing. • Several code amendments were approved to address these items and barriers identified in the CEDS plan, which include: o Expanding uses permitted in Tech- Park and Commercial (C-1 and C-2) zoning districts to support mixed commercial and employment centers. 1A B. Change the Zoning Code such that economic opportunity both increases and remains equitable to the surrounding community. Short TM, CED In Progress Complete 1A C. Highlight deficiencies and barriers to economic development in growth areas and commercial corridors. Short TM, CED In Progress Complete 1A 1B 3 o Updating the scenic corridor standards to apply the same standards to both commercial and employment centers. o Gaining efficiencies for EEZ projects. o Updating the noise and odor requirements to set enforceable standards. 5 Develop strategies and resources to promote Oro Valley, by identifying and highlighting key assets such as: A. Its community gathering places as premier destinations for retail, restaurants, entertainment and public art. Medium TM, CED, I&T In Progress Maintained • The Town currently promotes Oro Valley’s assets and amenities on the Town’s website, through social media, print media and by partnering with Visit Tucson and the Greater Oro Valley Chamber of Commerce. • These partnerships include a video with Visit Tucson and promotion in Tohono Chul Park’s Visitors Guide. 1E 6 Create private and public sector partnerships and programs for use, beautification, art displays or publicity on underutilized or vacant employment and retail centers. Medium CED In Progress In Progress • The Town is currently working with the new owners of the Oro Valley Village Center (previously known as the Oro Valley Marketplace) to create a community gathering space in the center. 1B 7 Develop strategies that promote a range of retail options, including regional- serving, neighborhood- serving and pedestrian- oriented, at appropriate locations. Medium CED In Progress In Progress • The CEDS Plan was adopted in 2019, which includes “retaining and supporting retail” as a main priority. • A study was completed in 2017, identifying the lack of density in Oro Valley as a barrier for retail development. An apartment study was completed in 2020 to further assist decisions about higher-density housing. • Staff is currently updating the Design Principles and Standards but recommends expanding the scope to 1B 4 include creating commercial nodes in strategic locations throughout the Town. 8 Develop partnerships with Pima Community College, community organizations and local businesses in order to: A. Connect skilled workers with targeted employment sectors. Ongoing CED In Progress In Progress • Through collaborations, the Town has visited local businesses to initiate conversations about current and future workforce needs. • The Town attends UA networking events to educate students with high-level skills about major employers in OV with potential current or future workforce needs. 1A B. Identify needs for workforce training for a range of industries, such as biotechnology, technical education, trades, aerospace and clean energy technologies. CED In Progress In Progress • The Town works with multiple organizations (Greater OV Chamber of Commerce, Tucson Chamber of Commerce, PCC, Pima County and NAU) to identify the needs for workforce training. 1A C. Identify needs for higher education in the community. Medium CED In Progress In Progress • Town officials remain connected to state efforts to assess and identify regional higher education needs. 1A 9 Develop partnerships with local organizations and businesses in order to: A. Identify needs for businesses which provide quality, accessible childcare, preschool, special needs and adult/elder care options. Medium CED Future Item In Progress • Town staff is working with the Oro Valley Chamber of Commerce to create a plan addressing these items. B. Support and promote the success of working families. Medium CED Future Item In Progress 5 COMPLETE COMMUNITY- REMAINING TASKS 10 Develop a plan for designating areas in Oro Valley that serve as the community’s gathering places and are envisioned to: A. Reflect the character of the Town. Short CED, P&R In Progress In Progress • Phase 1 (Needs Assessment) of the Parks and Recreation Master Plan was completed and presented to Council in May 2020. o Phase II is anticipated to go to Council early 2021 for adoption. • The Town is currently working with the new owners of the Oro Valley Village Center (previously known as the Oro Valley Marketplace) to incorporate a community gathering space in the center. 2A B. Include such amenities as sidewalk cafes, outdoor seating and desert landscaping. Short CED In Progress In Progress • The Town is currently working with the new owners of the Oro Valley Village Center (previously known as the Oro Valley Marketplace) to incorporate a community gathering space in the center. • Staff is currently updating the Design Principles and Standards and recommends expanding the scope to include this item. C. Emphasize the pedestrian experience. Short CED, P&R, PW In Progress In Progress • All new public roadway projects require a multi-use path. • All private developments must have pedestrian connectivity from roadways to entry points and courtyards/recreation areas. Staff is currently updating the Design Principles and Standards and recommends expanding the scope to include this item. 11 Update existing Town programs, plans and Medium CED Future Item Future Item • The neighborhood commercial (C-N) zoning district has standards for 6 regulations to create or expand Oro Valley’s community gathering places, such as: A. Development and zoning regulations to include new designations, such as mixed-use zoning. residential and commercial developments. However, staff is currently updating the Design Principles and Standards but recommends expanding the scope to include this item. 12 Develop public/private partnerships in order to create synergy and achieve common goals and desired improvements for Oro Valley’s community gathering places. Medium CED, P&R, TM, I&T In Progress In Progress • The Parks and Recreation Master Plan project will include partnership opportunities, such as working with Amphitheater Public School District. • The Town continues to work with Tohono Chul Park. • The Town is currently working with the new owners of the Oro Valley Village Center (previously known as the Oro Valley Marketplace) to incorporate a community gathering space in the center. 13 Creating development review strategies for commercial and retail areas that encourage public spaces. Medium CED In Progress In Progress • The code requires public spaces (courtyards) for all non-residential projects. • Staff is currently updating the Design Principles and Standards but recommends expanding the scope to include this item. 14 Develop strategies to increase opportunities for recreational and community events by: Streamlining the planning and approval process which may include designating suitable locations, expediting Short CED, TM, I&T In Progress Complete • Events are temporarily on hold, due to COVID-19 but the special event process has been improved and related amendments to Town Code Chapter adopted by the Town Council. 7 permitting or making a central calendar available. 16 Create a program that promotes accessible, convenient and age-friendly design of public and private facilities, services and programs. Medium CED, PW Future Item Future Item • This is recommended for a future strategic plan. 19 Provide for Oro Valley’s future education needs by developing collaborative measures with: Colleges and universities to explore growth opportunities and attract new campuses. Long TM, CED In Progress Maintained • The Town collaborates with the University of Arizona. This partnership as led to the UA Innovation Labs at Oro Valley and new UA College of Veterinary Science in the community. 23 Continue support of the Oro Valley Public Library by: A. Identifying collaboration measures and continuing service needs for the community. Medium TM in partn ership with Pima Count y In Progress Maintained • The Town leases the library building to the Pima County Library District and works with them on supporting their facility and parking needs. • The Town assists the Friends of the Oro Valley Library with construction projects and leases storage space. B. Taking an active role in library planning with the County. Medium TM in partn ership with Pima Count y In Progress Maintained • The Town attends applicable meetings specific to the Town's location only and not overall library planning. 27 Explore options for creating a Town Senior Advisory Council to direct priorities for senior services in the community. Long TM, I&T Future Item In Progress • The FY19/21 Strategic Leadership Plan includes working with all age groups and demographics. The Town is using social media, video, FlashVote and the website to engage residents of all ages. 28 Continue to provide Town information through the Ongoing CED, P&R, TM, In Progress Maintained • Town staff launched the new website at www.OroValleyAZ.gov and is now working to refine and continuously 6A 8 Town's website, publications, social media and local media OVPD, PW improve the site. The new website has multiple opportunities for residents to engage with staff. • An online engagement platform called “Discuss” will become an additional method of gathering community input on a variety of topics. The feature has been successfully launched, and next steps include planning and rolling out questions. • The Town continues to utilize FlashVote, the online survey tool to gather community input. • Communications has begun the process of taking a cross-departmental look at marketing and communications needs (to include Parks and Recreation, Tourism and Economic Development) as well as a methods and tools assessment with the goal of creating the Town’s first Communications Strategic Plan. This plan will directly support relevant areas of the Council-adopted Strategic Leadership Plan. • Parks and Recreation hosts the Town's Instagram page and has their own Facebook page. Usage of the Facebook pages is trending up. • OVPD has a public information officer and utilizes Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and Nextdoor. They have 13,018 Facebook followers, 5,911 Twitter followers and 1,354 Instagram followers. PD also conducted various live or pre- recorded media interviews. • The use of video to communicate with residents, including video messages from 9 the Mayor to address COVID-related issues, videos explaining complicated issues like Proposition 480 and the development applications n, and videos to connect with and celebrate residents has dramatically increased. These videos, specifically from the Planning Department have generated more engagement than in-person meetings. • The Town Code continues to be updated appropriately as amendments are approved and for ease of use. 30 Continue support of the Town's Public Art Program by: A. Developing an inventory and maintenance program, including training for staff on correct maintenance procedures Medium CED In Progress In Progress • A process improvement to create a well- defined process for inspecting and maintaining the quality of art on public property (roadways, parks, Town owned property) and art that is on private property but part of the 1% program has begun. 33 Assemble a team tasked with pursuing grants and alternative funding options as a means to continue and expand public art programs. Medium F, TM, I&T Future Item In Progress • The Town continues to fund the Southern Arizona and Arts and Cultural Alliance (SAACA) to provide free public art programs for residents and visitors. 34 Develop strategies to expand outreach and information regarding public art offerings. Ongoing TM, CED, I&T In Progress In Progress • The public art database was launched and is viewable on the Town’s new website. • Public art tours are on hold due to COVID-19 but will resume once safe. • The Town continues to partner with SAACA to communicate public art offerings via their website and social media. 10 37 Develop cooperative agreements with public school districts, private and charter schools to share school facilities for arts, recreation and education purposes. Short P&R, TM In Progress In Progress • The Parks and Recreation Master Plan project will include partnership opportunities, such as working with Amphitheater Public School District. • Some agreements are already in place but will be further developed through the Master Plan. Additional agreements will also be developed following the adoption of the Master Plan. • The Town Council chambers continues to serve as a viewing location of student art during the school year (temporarily suspended due to COVID-19 but being recognized virtually at Council meetings.) 2A 38 Develop a strategy, including potential financial incentives, to encourage a public or private entity to build or remodel an indoor auditorium to accommodate performing arts based on community needs and feasibility. Medium F, P&R, TM In Progress Maintained • The Town partnered with Tohono Chul Park on the new events pavilion and the Gaslight Theater is also a performing arts facility. There will be ongoing opportunities for the Town to help market both and participate in events. • The Zoning Code permits performing art facilities to satisfy a portion of the 1% for Public Art requirement. The amphitheater at Pusch Ridge Christian Academy is an example of this. 39 Evaluate and address the Town’s community park system conditions and needs by: A. Identifying target locations for needed community recreational amenities. Maintained P&R In Progress Complete • Phase 1 (Needs Assessment) of the Parks and Recreation Master Plan was completed and presented to Council in May 2020. o Connectivity analysis will be included in the plan as well as recommendations. 2A 11 B. Periodically reviewing and updating the Parks Master Plan. Medium P&R In Progress In Progress o Phase II is anticipated to go to Council early 2021 for adoption. 2A C. Developing and integrating strategies that address park shortages, preservation needs and safety upgrades into the Parks Master Plan. Medium P&R In Progress In Progress 2A D. Creating an inventory and maintenance plan for existing parks and open space in the community. Medium P&R In Progress In Progress 2A 40 Study and plan for revenue and funding needs for parks, recreation and trails by: A. Developing and administering public outreach efforts that gauge public support of future funding options to support park improvements. Medium F, P&R, TM In Progress In Progress • The Town launched FlashVote in the beginning of 2019 to gauge public support. • Additional input was gathered and identified in the Parks and Recreation Master Plan, including the use of a statistically valid survey. • The budget includes periodically revisiting membership / user fees, which will be reviewed through the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board. 2A B. Increasing public awareness of the cost to acquire, build and maintain public parks, trails and recreational facilities and to provide programs. Medium F, P&R, TM In Progress In Progress 6A C. Identifying potential revenue sources. Medium F, P&R, TM In Progress In Progress 7A 41 Address the adequacy of Town parks and recreation programs and facilities by: Ongoing CED, P&R In Progress Complete • Phase 1 (Needs Assessment) of the Parks and Recreation Master Plan was 2A 12 A. Periodically assessing the availability of recreation opportunities for all residents within the Town. completed and presented to Council in May 2020. • Phase II is anticipated to go to Council early 2021 for adoption. B. Enhancing and maintaining open space, park and recreation facilities and programs through existing and new resources, private and public recreation providers, partnerships, volunteers and others as appropriate. Ongoing PW, P&R In Progress In Progress 2A C. Considering the affordability and availability of existing and future parks and recreation programs to residents. Ongoing P&R In Progress In Progress 2A 43 Study and evaluate the feasibility of the development of additional and improved public recreation or community education facilities in the community. Long P & R In Progress In Progress • Phase 1 (Needs Assessment) of the Parks and Recreation Master Plan was completed and presented to Council in May 2020. • Phase II is anticipated to go to Council early 2021 for adoption. 2A 44 Develop a strategy to acquire property for larger recreational and community use of sufficient size and location that access can be shared equitably by multiple neighborhoods and all residents. Long CED, PW, F, P&R, TM In Progress In Progress • Phase 1 (Needs Assessment) of the Parks and Recreation Master Plan was completed and presented to Council in May 2020. • Phase II is anticipated to go to Council early 2021 for adoption. 2A 13 45 Review opportunities to repurpose land for small and neighborhood parks by acquiring land or partnering with local stakeholders and agencies. Long CED, F, P&R, TM In Progress In Progress • Phase 1 (Needs Assessment) of the Parks and Recreation Master Plan was completed and presented to Council in May 2020. • Phase II is anticipated to go to Council early 2021 for adoption. 2A 46 Plan for future trail needs in the community by developing and adopting a trails plan that: A. Establishes long-term strategies for trail development, linkages, management and upkeep in cooperation with other local jurisdictions Medium CED, P&R In Progress In Progress • Phase 1 (Needs Assessment) of the Parks and Recreation Master Plan was completed and presented to Council in May 2020. • Phase II is anticipated to go to Council early 2021 for adoption. • The Town continues to work with Pima County in exploring ways to extend paved paths. The County added an extension north of the Oro Valley Village Center (formerly the Oro Valley Marketplace) and is exploring additional Loop extensions. 2A B. Links neighborhoods, open space, environmentally sensitive lands and natural resources. Medium CED, P&R In Progress In Progress 2A C. Integrates with the Parks Master Plan and is periodically updated. Medium CED, P&R In Progress In Progress 2A 47 Create procedures, including public and private contributions, for integrating signs into parks, trailheads, trails and linear bicycle paths and near natural areas that: Inform users of site information and regulations. Medium CED, P&R Future Item In Progress • Sign are integrated in all these areas. • The Zoning Code requires signs in all private parks and for public trails on private properties. Sings include information and rules/regulations. The trailheads also include wayfinding signage. • Staff is currently updating the Design Principles and Standards but recommends expanding the scope to include this item. 14 Educate users about local history and ecology. Medium CED, P&R Future Item Future Item 48 Explore opportunities to integrate family-friendly amenities into the trail system, such as areas for play, rest, water, shade and learning. Long CED, P&R In Progress In Progress • Phase 1 (Needs Assessment) of the Parks and Recreation Master Plan was completed and presented to Council in May 2020. • Phase II is anticipated to go to Council early 2021 for adoption. PUBLIC FACILITES AND SERVICES –REMAINING TASKS 49 Pursuing grants to implement conservation measures. Medium WU Future Item Maintained • The Water Utility applies for grants as they become available. 50 Develop a plan for long-term municipal facilities that considers overall community needs and growth and that addresses parking, facility expansion, satellite offices, central offices, maintenance and fueling facilities and operations. Medium PW, TM, I&T In Progress In Progress • The Town is creating a Town-wide Facilities/space needs plan. This includes an evaluation of existing and future space needs through site visits, reviewing previous documents, and development of overall goals. The donation of property on Oracle Road by the Rooney family, and the impacts of COVID-19 on teleworking have caused staff to take a brief pause to ensure the future analysis addresses these issues. A concept plan will be discussed with Town Council in late FY20/21 or early FY21/22. 4A SAFETY- REMAINING TASKS 52 Plan for the safety and security of the community by developing, implementing and periodically updating strategies and plans for: A. Flooding. Ongoing PW, OVPD, GRFD, WU, I&T In Progress Maintained • Town departments have Continuity of Operations Plan (COOP), which includes both short and long-term emergency/disaster guidelines. The Public Works Division has a COOP that addresses emergency response situations. • The Drainage Criteria Manual is geared towards preventative measures to 4B 15 prevent flooding, and an update to the manual is in the final stages of review. 60 Continue Town programs that limit risk associated with construction dust and the spread of diseases. Ongoing PW In Progress Maintained • The Town has standards to limit dust on dirt roads. • The Zoning Code requires dust control on all clear or graded land. Dust control measures (e.g. decomposed granite, hydro seeding) continue to be reviewed as new methods become available. 63 Address safety issues, including stormwater, in reviewing school and development site plans during the development review process Short/ Ongoing CED, PW In Progress In Progress • Phase II, of updating the Town’s Drainage Criteria Manual (DCM) was initiated in July 2019 with Riley Engineering and their sub-consultant, Mike Zeller. A complete draft of the new manual is under outside consultant technical review. It is expected to be accepted and implemented fiscal year 20/21. 5A 16 ENVIRONMENT ACTIONS 2019 SUMMARY 2020 UPDATE ON THE 43 REMAINING TASKS ACCOMPLISHMENTS (74%) TASKS TO COMPLETE (26%) Completed 30 Completed +7 Total tasks completed 37 Total tasks currently in progress 15 Maintained 43 Maintained +7 In Progress 12 In Progress 15 Total tasks maintained through ongoing operations 50 Remaining tasks to evaluate or complete in the future 14 Future Items 31 Future Items 14 SONORAN DESERT RESOURCE- REMAINING TASKS NO. TASK TIMEFRAME DEPT. STATUS COMMENTS SLP 2019 2020 66 Maintain the Environmentally Sensitive Lands Ordinance (ESLO) by: A. Evaluating and appropriately updating the ESLO for effectiveness at least every 10 years. Medium CED In Progress In Progress • Staff evaluated the ESLO by reviewing the related General Plan policies for guidance review of all code requirements and plans associated with open space conservation, analysis of all subdivisions approved since adoption of the ordinance and identification of known gaps within the code. • Due to budgetary constraints caused by the global pandemic, contracting a biologist and habitat specialist has been put on hold. However, staff is researching additional standards for preservation, health determination and transplant potential for saguaros and ironwoods to create policies to address many of the known gaps. 5A B. Updating design guidelines and standards to incorporate best practices Medium CED In Progress In Progress • Staff analyzed all the subdivisions approved since adoption of the ordinance to evaluate conservation subdivision design. Due to budgetary constraints caused by the global pandemic, contracting a habitat specialist and 5A 17 on site and building design related to environmental conservation. biologist to review staff’s findings has been put on hold. 67 Reviewing and amending the Zoning Code as needed. Ongoing CED In Progress In Progress • Staff evaluated the ESLO by reviewing the related General Plan policies for guidance review of all code requirements and plans associated with open space conservation, analysis of all subdivisions approved since adoption of the ordinance and identification of known gaps within the code. • Due to budgetary constraints caused by the global pandemic, contracting a biologist and habitat specialist to assist with amending the code has been put on hold. However, staff is researching additional standards for preservation, health determination and transplant potential for saguaros and ironwoods to create policies to address many of the known gaps. 5A 68 Connect environmentally sensitive lands, which include wildlife and plant habitats, riparian areas and significant natural resource areas by: Identifying preservation and connection strategies between environmentally Long CED In Progress In Progress • Staff evaluated the ESLO by reviewing the related General Plan policies for guidance review of all code requirements and plans associated with open space conservation, analysis of all subdivisions approved since adoption of the ordinance and identification of known gaps within the code. • Due to budgetary constraints caused by the global pandemic, contracting a biologist and habitat specialist to assist with amending the code has been put on hold. However, staff is researching additional standards for preservation, 18 sensitive lands, including Tortolita Mountain Park, Arroyo Grande, Catalina State Park and Coronado National Forest, in cooperation with other agencies and jurisdictions. health determination and transplant potential for saguaros and ironwoods to create policies to address many of the known gaps. 69 Protect significant biological resources, including key wildlife and plant habitats and special-status species, to prevent their loss or degradation by: A. Maintaining a current and accurate database of significant biological resources, including maps of their locations. Short CED, IT In Progress Maintained • The ESL map is up to date based on current zoning and code requirements. • Due to budgetary constraints caused by the global pandemic, contracting a biologist and habitat specialist to assist with possible amendments to the conservation categories has been put on hold. 71 Conserve scenic views of the ridgelines, hillsides, peaks and foothills of the Santa Catalina, Tortolita, and more distant mountain ranges Medium CED Future Item Maintained • There are not standards specific to parks, but the Zoning Code limits building height along scenic corridors to protect the views of the mountains. These standards protect views from parks and other vantage points in Town. 19 that contribute to the Town’s valued scenic character by: A. Developing land use regulations that require development proposals to maintain and/or enhance the quality of views to and from public parks. B. Monitoring and revising scenic resource regulations as needed to enhance community- wide goals. Ongoing CED In Progress Maintained • A code amendment was approved to revise the scenic corridor standards for consistency between tech-park and commercial uses. Additional amendments may occur over time. 72 Maintain and improve night sky visibility by: A. Updating regulations to incorporate new technologies and best practices that minimize light pollution. Short CED, PW Future Item Future Item • Updating the lighting section of the Zoning Code is on the Planning Work Plan FY19/21. However, due to the budgetary constraints from the global pandemic, a consultant needed to complete these updates has been put on hold. B. Adhering to regional dark- skies initiatives. Ongoing CED, PW Future Item Future Item 20 74 Develop and implement the Town’s Tree Master Plan, which considers the benefits of trees in relation to overall community welfare, while making plans for infrastructure, facilities, new development and the conservation of Oro Valley's scenic views. Medium CED, PW, P&R Future Item Future Item • This is recommended for a future strategic plan item. 75 Periodically review and update the Town's Save-A- Plant program in order to protect healthy, native vegetation. Medium CED Future Item Maintained • Before COVID-19, the Town’s Save-A-Plant program was promoted to developers. Logistics are updated accordingly on a case-by-case basis. For instance, due to the topography of the site, Nakoma Sky hosted a Save-A-Plant table at the Farmer’s Market during 2nd Saturday at Steam Pump Ranch. 76 Evaluate the effectiveness and provide appropriate support to programs or groups that strive to reduce invasive species and the replanting of native species. Ongoing CED, PW Future Item Maintained • Invasive plant species are identified and removed during the development process. • The Town periodically reviews and updates the approved Native Plant list, which requires low-water native plants for all new developments and list of prohibited plants in the Zoning Code. • The Town utilizes volunteer assistance for invasive species eradication along some key roadways. 77 Develop measures that encourage private property Short CED Future Item Future Item • Invasive plant species are identified and removed during the development process. 21 owners to assist in invasive species removal. The Zoning Code also includes a list of prohibited species (Addendum E) available to the public. WATER CONSERVATIO- REMAINING TASKS 82 Reduce dependence on, use and diminishing of the groundwater supply by: A. Exploring the expanded use of stormwater harvesting and recharge areas. Medium WU Future Item Future Item • This is recommended for a future strategic plan item. 83 Expand infrastructure and facilities that provide for a diverse water supply portfolio, including Central Arizona Project water and the use of reclaimed water for irrigation and other purposes. Long WU In Progress In Progress • The Water Utility is expanding and the North West Recharge and Recovery Delivery System (NWRRDS) will be online in 2024, allowing for the delivery of additional CAP entitlements for use in the community. 4B 84 Develop plans, create partnerships and, where appropriate, incentives that increase use of alternative water sources for potable and non-potable uses, including: A. Graywater. Long WU Future Item Complete • In FY 19/20 the Water Utility partnered with a consultant to review and update the Utility’s reclaimed water rate structure and rate setting methodology. The work resulted in an updated rate setting methodology to ensure that the cost of providing reclaimed water was equitable to all customers while incentivizing the use of reclaimed water. 22 B. Passive and active stormwater harvesting. Long WU Future Item Complete • Rainwater harvesting is required for all new developments. Although there are no official incentives for homeowners, the Water Conservation Specialist provides programs and consultation to assist with Stormwater harvesting. Additionally, the Town does not collect a conservation fee. 88 Explore the feasibility, value and public interest in fluoridation of Oro Valley's water supply. Short WU Future Item No Further Action • This item has been evaluated and is not being pursued at this time. A very small amount of disinfectant (Sodium Hypochlorite) is added to the water to ensure the water system is free of any waterborne diseases such as cholera, dysentery and typhoid. • Adding fluoride to water for the sole purpose of preventing tooth decay (a non- waterborne disease) may be considered a form of medical treatment and is not necessary in a system that already contains naturally occurring fluoride. 89 Provide resources for water course management including: Channelizing to minimize safety threats. Long PW Future Item In Progress • A complete draft of the new Drainage Criteria Manual is under outside consultant technical review. It is expected to be accepted and implemented fiscal year 20/21. 93 Put in place plans, resources and requirements to manage stormwater runoff in order of: A. Increase infiltration into the groundwater. Short PW Future Item In Progress • A complete draft of the new Drainage Criteria Manual is under outside consultant technical review. It is expected to be accepted and implemented fiscal year 20/21. 23 97 Develop and implement a public education program regarding ways to minimize negative environmental impacts of stormwater caused by development. Short PW In Progress Complete • The Town has a formal public outreach program, which was documented on the latest audit from ADWR. 98 Study options and provide opportunities for development or redevelopment to design for, capture and manage stormwater in facilities having multiple benefits, such as stormwater management, recreation, wildlife habitats and groundwater recharge. Short CED, PW In Progress In Progress • Phase II, of updating the Town’s Drainage Criteria Manual (DCM) was initiated in July 2019 with Riley Engineering and their sub- consultant, Mike Zeller. A complete draft of the new manual is under outside consultant technical review. It is expected to be accepted and implemented fiscal year 20/21. 100 Evaluate stormwater management policies, practices and work programs and align with water conservation strategies when appropriate. Medium PW, WU Future Item In Progress • A complete draft of the new Drainage Criteria Manual is under outside consultant technical review. It is expected to be accepted and implemented fiscal year 20/21. CULTURAL RESOURCE- REMAINING TASKS 101 Preserve and share significant cultural Medium CED, P&R In Progress In Progress • The following documents identify and inventory cultural resources in the Town. 24 resources of Oro Valley with the community by: A. Identifying significant cultural resources, including people, events, places and activities in an inventory that is periodically updated. o Rock Art, Ranch, and Residence: Cultural Resources in the Town of Oro Valley o The Oro Valley Cultural Heritage Preservation Plan: Developing and Sustaining a Community Sense of Place • In 2021, the Historic Preservation Commission will be reviewing the Preservation Plan in terms of identifying accomplishments as well as areas to continue their work. B. Collecting oral histories from key persons related to Oro Valley history. Medium CED, P&R Future Item In Progress • Key people have been identified and some oral histories have been collected. A session in Community Academy is about the history of Oro Valley. • C. Creating and executing a plan for the placement of interpretive elements related to cultural resource sites in existing and planned Town facilities and properties with the assistance of outside funding. Medium CED, PW, P&R Future Item Future Item • This is recommended for a future strategic plan item. CLEAN ENVIRONMENT- REMAINING TASKS 25 109 Provide and support safe and convenient waste disposal options for the community by: A. Exploring the creation of a Town-wide recycling program for municipal, commercial and residential uses. Medium PW, OVPD, TM Future Item Future Item • There is no external community wide program. Private companies such as Waste Management offer services to their clients. B. Collaborating with the private sector to offer recycling stations and clean composting sites throughout the Town. Medium PW, OVPD, TM Future Item Maintained • The Town will continue to partner with the City of Tucson and recycling organizations to provide events throughout the town. C. Establish hazardous waste collection and storage facilities in Oro Valley. Medium PW, OVPD, TM Future Item Maintained • The Town conducted two hazard waste events in partnership with City of Tucson. D. Implementing programs that demonstrate best practices in recycling, waste Short PW, OVPD, TM Future Item In Progress • Constituent Services Coordinator has met with City of Tucson regarding recycling. 26 minimization and disposal programs. 110 Promote sustainable practices in the private sector by: A. Developing an Oro Valley awards program to recognize these practices. Medium CED, WU Future Item No Further Action • The Town of Oro Valley defers to national programs such as LEED that are used throughout the industry to recognize these efforts. • This is recommended for a future strategic plan item. B. Establishing development incentives for projects demonstrating an exemplary commitment to sustainability. Medium CED, WU Future Item Future Item C. Partnering with local businesses to create incentives for the education, purchase and/or installation of resource conservation products. Medium CED, WU Future Item Future Item 113 Promote energy efficiency by: A. Reviewing, identifying and addressing Medium CED, PW Future Item Future Item • This is recommended for a future strategic plan item. 27 Town policies and ordinances that enhance renewable energy production, efficiency and conservation. B. Conducting an assessment of emerging renewable technologies for potential application in the community. Medium CED, PW Future Item Future Item 114 Support the use of alternative energy to reduce emissions and air pollution and to enhance environmental quality by: A. Creating programs that incentivize and reduce barriers to the use of clean alternative energy in business, institutional and residential settings. Medium CED, TM Future Item Future Item • This is recommended for a future strategic plan item. 28 B. Exploring opportunities to encourage private industry to develop and maintain convenient alternative fuel stations. Medium CED, TM Future Item Future Item • Recommended for future strategic plan/work plan item. 115 Create energy efficiencies in Town operations by: A. Investigating the feasibility of converting Town vehicles and negotiating agreements with other large fleet organizations to utilize “green fuel.” Medium PW, WU Future Item No Further Action • This has been evaluated this item and all vehicles would need to be updated for this to be economical. This may be reevaluated in the future but is also not practical for every department. 4A 117 Work collaboratively with regional partners to create and maintain web- based information portals such as Solar One Stop, uniform renewable energy standards, inspection procedures and submittal requirements, and Medium CED, PW, I&T In Progress In Progress • The Town will be implementing new permitting software in the FY 20/21 to address this item. • Electronic plan review and permitting is done with all developments and the Community and Economic Development Department went “paperless” in July 2020. 29 provide for electronic permitting. 119 Create programs to enhance air quality by: A. Controlling construction dust and exploring the requirement of reclaimed water use to do so. Long PW Future Item Complete • Where available, reclaimed water is used to support earth working projects as well as control construction dust. • Construction dust is regulated by the Pima County Department of Environmental Quality (PDEQ). B. Encouraging the use of natural gas, multimodal transportation, rideshares and renewable resources. Long CED Future Item Future Item 120 Pursue sustainability and environmental conservation in development by: A. Periodically updating existing low- impact development regulations. Medium CED In Progress In Progress • Staff analyzed all the subdivisions approved since adoption of the ordinance to evaluate conservation subdivision design. Due to budgetary constraints caused by the global pandemic, contracting a habitat specialist and biologist to review staff’s findings has been put on hold. 5A B. Including sustainable and environmental development practices in Medium CED In Progress In Progress 5A 30 Town development review. 31 DEVELOPMENT ACTIONS 2019 SUMMARY 2020 UPDATE ON THE 31 REMAINING TASKS ACCOMPLISHMENTS (65%) TASKS TO COMPLETE (35%) Completed 16 Completed +2 Total tasks completed 18 Total tasks currently in progress 17 Maintained 24 Maintained +5 In progress 17 In Progress 17 Total tasks maintained through ongoing operations 29 Remaining tasks to evaluate or complete in the future 7 Future items 14 Future Items 7 LAND USE AND DESIGN- REMAINING TASKS NO. TASK TIMEFRAME DEPT. STATUS COMMENTS SLP 2019 2020 125 Maintain the unique character of Oro Valley by studying and updating: A. Site design standards. Medium CED In Progress In Progress • Staff is currently updating the Design Principles and Standards but recommends expanding the scope to include creating commercial nodes in strategic locations throughout the Town. 5A B. Land use regulations that define and incorporate effective compatibility standards. Medium CED In Progress In Progress 5A C. Regulations that enable a variety of architectural colors and textures, especially for commercial, that integrate with the community and don’t emphasize sameness. Medium CED In Progress In Progress 128 Develop detailed planning for designated neighborhood-scale growth areas at prominent intersections. Long CED In Progress In Progress • Staff is currently updating the Design Principles and Standards but recommends expanding the scope to include creating commercial nodes in strategic locations throughout the Town. 129 Create development standards, policies and provisions and make Long CED In Progress In Progress 32 available in appropriate locations for: A. Form-based code. • Staff is currently updating the Design Principles and Standards but recommends expanding the scope to include using form-based code for commercial nodes, mixed use zoning and transit-oriented development. B. Transit-oriented development. Long CED Future Item Future Item C. Mixed-use zoning. Long CED Future Item Future Item 130 Update development regulations of Master Planned communities to: A. Incorporate land uses consistent with surrounding development and residential acceptance. Medium CED Future Item Future Item • This is recommended for a future strategic plan item. 132 Plan for the growth of the community through annexations by: Creating an annexation strategy that reflects sound financial planning. Long CED, F, TM, I&T In Progress Complete • A comprehensive annexation policy was adopted by Town Council in July 2020. 1C 133 Investigate the annexation of county islands and peninsulas to facilitate infrastructure expansion and improve operational efficiencies of municipal services. Long TM, I&T In Progress Complete • A comprehensive annexation policy was adopted by Town Council in July 2020. 1C 134 Hold periodic “energy summits” by bringing together providers, key landowners, businesses and Town staff to identify and resolve issues and discuss plans for future growth. Long CED, TM Future Item Future Item • This is recommended for a future strategic plan item. 135 Respond to and plan for the present and future housing needs of the community, while considering changes in demographics and overall growth by: Medium CED Future Item In Progress • A market study was completed in 2017, which included a housing component. • Town staff began updating and adding more specific information for this item by commissioning a third-party 33 A. Developing a housing plan, that addresses the needs of a diverse community. consultant to complete an apartment study. The apartment study only represents one component of the larger housing study, which include all housing types. • Once the housing study is complete, a housing plan and zoning strategies will be developed. B. Developing zoning strategies that implement the housing plan. Medium CED Future Item In Progress INFRASTRUCTURE- REMAINING TASKS 137 Develop a plan for new development and infrastructure that: A. Identifies funding methods and techniques. Medium PW, F, I&T In Progress In Progress • New Impact Fees were adopted in 2020 that go into effect in July 2022. • Regionally, work is being done to create a new iteration of the RTA – to be called RTA Next, a new 20-year regional transportation program to start in 2026. 141 Coordinate infrastructure expansion and future utility services in Innovation Park and other key employment and commerce sites. Ongoing CED In Progress In Progress • This is an identified strategy in the CEDS plan to be implemented within the next 5 years. 1A 142 Increase opportunities for telecommunications and broadband services in the community by: A. Identifying community needs and suitable providers. Long CED, I&T, TM In Progress In Progress • The Comprehensive Economic Development Strategy (CEDS) identified a need for telecommunications and broadband services. • The Chief Information Officer is working on evaluating opportunities to increase broadband services that will be presented to Town Council. 1A B. Assessing suitable locations and the impact on current infrastructure. Long CED, I&T, TM Future Item In Progress 1A TRANSPORTATION/CIRCULATION- REMINAING TASKS 146 Re-examine Zoning Code parking ratios as part of overall transportation planning in areas where transportation options Medium CED, PW In Progress In Progress • Updating the parking code requirements is on the Planning Work Plan for FY19/21. Research is currently underway. 34 other than the automobile are available. 147 Create a complete streets design manual that considers means to calm traffic, traffic safety, neighborhood aesthetics, stormwater management, access management, public health, safety and community vitality. Short CED, PW In Progress Future Item • Preliminary work to update the Town’s Subdivision Street Standards has been conducted. It is recommended for a future strategic plan item to direct further resources needed to complete this task. 148 Complete long-range planning for the roadway network that addresses: A. Proper capacity (20-year traffic volume projection) to serve traffic generated by the land uses depicted on the General Plan Land Use Map. Medium CED, PW Future Item In Progress • This is being addressed by several efforts. First it was reviewed as a 5yr window with the latest update of the Impact Fees. Then it is being constantly monitored by the Town Engineering staff and PAG as a part of the federally mandated R-MAP process. • Lastly it is being addressed within the RTA Next efforts. Within the proposed projects is the extension of La Cholla Blvd. north to Oracle Junction. B. Future transportation needs, access and development on major roadways. Medium CED, PW Future Item In Progress C. Fostering alternative routes to Oracle Road in order to alleviate congestion. Medium CED, PW Future Item In Progress 150 Coordinate with the state to develop detailed planning for Oracle Road that identifies partnerships, funding options and agreements in order to allow for: A. Diverse development. Medium CED, PW In Progress In Progress • The Town is currently working with the new owners of the Oro Valley Village Center (previously known as the Oro Valley Marketplace) to revitalize the center. • A code amendment was approved allowing more employment uses in commercial zones, including those along Oracle and updating the scenic corridor standards to utilize the same standards for both commercial and employment centers. 4A 35 B. An upgraded visual quality. Medium CED, PW In Progress In Progress • Through Street Operations, The Town has a landscaping IGA and subsequent license agreement with ADOT to maintain the vegetation on the Oracle Rd. shoulders. • The IGA could be extended to include maintenance and lane closure permits, as well as identify the resources needed to conduct this body of work. 4A 151 Re-evaluate roadway design standards, especially for arterial and collector roads, to include methods for: A. Reducing fuel consumption, congestion and the number of vehicles starts and stops. Medium PW, OVPD In Progress Future Item • Preliminary work to update the Town’s Subdivision Street Standards has been conducted. It is recommended for a future strategic plan item to direct further resources needed to complete this task. B. Improving the attractiveness of roadways, including public art, landscaping and decorative light poles. Medium CED, PW In Progress Maintained • All public roadway projects include art and landscaping as standard elements. 159 Encourage walkability and safe routes to destinations through the community by: A. Identifying locations where pedestrian facilities and connections need to be upgraded along major roadways. Short PW, OVPD In Progress Maintained B. Developing an assessment process for walkability standards to be used during development review. Short CED, OVPD Future Item Future Item • Walkability and ADA standards are part of development review. However, a protocol to assess walkability has not been created yet. 160 Develop a plan for future transit needs that includes: A. Safe, attractive, efficient transit shelters that enhance the community's character. Medium PW Future Item Maintained • In conjunction with the Pima Association of Governments (PAG), shelters are updated as finding becomes available. 36 B. Pullouts for buses. Medium PW Future Item Maintained • All new road construction projects include this item. C. Efficient transit routes which allow for coordination of trips to common destinations and regional connections. Medium PW Future Item Maintained • The Transit Division (Public Works) provides constant updates, which have become more effective with the new Trip Spark scheduling software. Department abbreviations: CED- Community and Economic Development Department F- Finance GRFD- Golder Ranch Fire District I&T- Innovation and Technology OVPD- Oro Valley Police Department P&R- Parks and Recreation PW- Public Works TM- Town Manager’s Office WU- Water Utility    Planning & Zoning Commission 4. Meeting Date:12/01/2020   Requested by: Bayer Vella, Community and Economic Development  Case Number: N/A SUBJECT: DISCUSSION REGARDING THE PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION SCHEDULED MEETING DATES FOR 2021 RECOMMENDATION: This item is for discussion only. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: N/A BACKGROUND OR DETAILED INFORMATION: N/A FISCAL IMPACT: N/A SUGGESTED MOTION: This item is for discussion purposes only. Attachments 2021 Meeting Dates  2021 Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Dates Commission Meeting Dates (1st Tuesday of each month) 1/5/21 2/2/21 3/2/21 4/6/21 5/4/21 6/1/21 7/6/21 8/3/21 9/7/21 10/5/21 11/2/21 12/7/21